164 réponses à ce sujet

[saracen16]

ME1>ME3>ME2.

But ME1 is the most memorable for me: it had that polished, classic, sci-fi feel.

[Asilos S A T AN]

 ME3(it was an amazing game up until the ending)-ME2(Probably tied with ME3 for my favorite)-ME1

[Favourite store on the CitadeI]

I was actually thinking about this the other night.
In terms of combat;
3
2
1

In terms of story gratification & progress;
1
3
2

[salbi]

Schrijver wrote...

BatmanPWNS wrote...

ME2
ME3
ME1

This.

This.
I have to agree with the general critics score. In terms of the game itself:
ME2 > ME3 >>> ME

In terms of story:
ME > ME2 > ME3

Modifié par salbi, 19 mars 2012 - 05:02 .

[Alithinos]

I mostly enjoyed 2 because it was better in most different aspects.

My best of the trilogy is ME2 because:

*The camera direction was the best I have seen in games.
*Graphics where very fresh and good,was a jump later after ME1.
*Character development was the best I had seen,they where the most believeable characters I have seen in a game.
*Gameplay was balanced right between rpg and shooter elements.

Second is ME1 because:

*It had a very interesting and intriguing scenario.
*It felt longer than any other game of the series.
*It had larger areas to walk around.
*It had driving sections. (Yes,I liked them)
*Its gui was complex and hard to get used to. (pc)
*Battles could be better.

Last is ME3 because:

*It lacked on the technical department,didn't felt fresh but dated instead.
*Its content was less. (dialogues,places,bars,mini-games)
*It screwed lore and left lots of plot-holes.
*The way it ends destroyed people's motives for replaying the trilogy.

Modifié par Alithinos, 19 mars 2012 - 05:24 .

[Grellow]

2,3,1

[rozar]

3>2>1. The ending may be horrible, it stays the best mass effect. i just hope i can put a 4 in front of this list in a couple of years.

[FaWa]

Pre ending: ME1=ME3>Me2
Post ending: ME1>ME2=ME3

[ElrondDragon]

1. ME2
2. ME
3. ME3

[tyranolol]

I have really love the three games the only problem of me3 is the ****ing ****ty ending so i say me1=me2= me3

[Kaija]

ME2 I found to be the best overall. Then ME1 with ME3 third as it feels like it was rushed.

Modifié par Kaija, 19 mars 2012 - 06:13 .

[Kakita Tatsumaru]

Knut0 wrote...
Good point there, but I am one of the people who dont think of the ending as a part of the game. I just felt Shepard was more of a person this time over, showing actual feelings. I played as a paragon, so I can get why renesheps feel this is not something for them.
It is a matter of personal preferences.

I also feel that conversations are more dynamic, thogh it came with the cost of more dialog options.

I have no problem with that, just don't call it roleplay (which implies choices, and the more the merrier).
Perhaps "good writing" (for a parangon Shepard at least) would be better (until one speaks of the endings ^^).

[WhitenameB]

ME2 best ending of all series and big improvement in gameplay and overall presentation.
ME1 inventory management and planet exploration on mako were very tiresome experience. Still had better ending than 3.
ME3 ending that ruined the trilogy. Felt that the choices Made throughout the series were just a number (EMS) and nothing more.

[Hawkamania]

ADelusiveMan wrote...

In their chronological order for me.

This.

[Subject M]

I cant really rate them like that.

ME1 had better overall story then ME2, but suffered from children deceases when it came to game-play. ME3 had better gameplay then ME2 and was the conclusion of the two earlier installments in terms of story. Overall it would have been the best "act" in terms of satisfaction (as the final acts are supposed to be I guess), if not for the ending.

Modifié par Subject M, 19 mars 2012 - 07:49 .