487 réponses à ce sujet

[FarynUEA]

Spot on Vid ... thanks for sharing =)

[danteliveson]

Jahns over this loser any day.

[ZodiEmish]

Sweet.. his review was awesome.. I can't wait to bask in his unchecked rage about the game.

he sounded tired for one, and distressed in the video...

Over all a great vid, and more reason to hold the line and fight for a new ending.

Modifié par ZodiEmish, 18 mars 2012 - 10:03 .

[nicksmi56]

THIS IS SO RIGHT

[Pairikas]

He really get the Importants Problems to the Point.

[cotheer]

danteliveson wrote...

Boring.

danteliveson wrote...

Jahns over this loser any day.

 


Butthurt much? <_<

[goose2989]

SandTrout wrote...

It's hilarious to me that reviewers not dependent on publisher/developer advertising are consistently tearing apart the ending.

For better or worse, welcome to Capitalism

[FRancium]

He understands!

I really feel a lot of people that liked the ending hadn't put in the amount of attention and effort as some of us did. They see the endings and don't feel the same "but that goes against my Shepard's actions" "that's not what we told Saren" "but Javik/EDI/etc just said..."

It destroys lore, it cheapens any choice previously made. and it just makes no sense.

[Slappy Ya Face]

Hit every point.

[Deviant Seraph]

Great points, and nicely fleshed out for people who do not visit the forums and are only exposed to the "they only want happy endings hurr durr" rhetoric that gaming sites spew.

[Vade Katana]

Agreed with every point. Its depressing.

[pablosplinter]

This is good.

[arthurhallam]

There is something compelling about reason 7.

I mean, sh*t, this isn't a piece of avant-garde cinema. Or a literary sci-fi novel by M. John Harrison. It's a space opera. A romance saga. This isn't high art.

There's been a total misjudgement of who plays these games & what they desire.

[BBCH]

Great video!

[Zulufoxtrot]

Good video, loved all his points.

[The Angry One]

Costin_Razvan wrote...

The Citadel, the biggest mass relay in the Galaxy, survives in Control. He makes it a point to state that it sucks that all the Relays get destroyed in all the endings.

Well how about he explains THIS then. This is in control.

The relays are not destroyed because they're mass relays, but because the relay network is the target of the Crucible pulse (on this basis I believe the Omega-4 relay will be preserved, provided the other relay in the system doesn't rupture it). Therefore the Citadel is unharmed when it doesn't transmit the pulse.

Quite why the Citadel doesn't need to send a pulse in control when it spreads through the relay network anyway is.... a plothole.
It's possible they were just THAT damn lazy that they DON'T intend the relays to be destroyed in Control, but still used the same CG of them breaking apart, only omitting the explosion. I'm not sure what's worse.
Either way, they don't tell us.

The Angry One: Why would anyone pick that ending is beyond me really. That there will be peace? Really.

I mean you just gave the Reapers free will in all their actions. Congratulations to the people who picked that I guess.

It's just really baffling that this revoltingly stupid ending is considered the "best" by BioWare, or perhaps second "best" after destroy/Shepard breathes, given that you actually have to work to get this ending (and this ending is NOT what I thought I was gathering war assets for!).

Modifié par The Angry One, 18 mars 2012 - 09:35 .

[spartan5127]

Yes. Great high level analysis on why the endings fail so horribly.

[Darth Sagan]

Agreed with all 10 reasons. 

[deathscythe517]

I've always enjoyed Angry Joe as a reviewer, he's the every gamer, got his share of positive and negative traits, has his moments of fanboyism, but overall a pretty fair reviewer. I may not agree with his opinion on all games but I like that he actually does take into account everything instead of handing out ones and tens like hot cakes.

[Catroi]

The Angry One wrote...

Joe said what most of us have been saying. Brilliant game, some minor flaws. And that ending.
Also his view on that there should be a more hardcore RPG space opera I agree with completely.

^this, that's why ME1 is the best IMHO

[Versus Omnibus]

Thanks for this update. We must hold the line!!

[defenestrated]

Costin_Razvan wrote...

defenestrated wrote...

Costin_Razvan wrote...

He ignores one ending that is very important, and yes he DOES do it for the money, like every video he does.

It's a top 10 of the things he hated about the endings. A top 10, by its very nature, implies the list will not be entirely comprehensive. I'm not sure what the problem is?

The Citadel, the biggest mass relay in the Galaxy, survives in Control. He makes it a point to state that it sucks that all the Relays get destroyed in all the endings.

Well how about he explains THIS then. This is in control.

The Citadel is more than a mass relay and all other mass relays are still destroyed. The network of relays is not preserved in any ending. He also incorrectly states Shep lives if you have high enough EMS, not noting that it's only true for the destroy ending but I don't think either minor inaccuracy has any bearing on his main points.

[RebelByDesign]

Good summation of all the main issues we've been discussing. Good work, Joe.

[Angmir]

Damn I just saw that quotes from Bioware at the begining of the video and I realised how much I have been fooled. I dont understand how could they pull something like that on us after what they intendeed.

I would understand if the mid-game of Mass Effect 3 was not of the higfhest quality, but the conclusion of the series ?? So far final missions were a trademark of a Mass Effect Series, and the end of Mass Effect 3 ooks like it was done in 2 weeks, insead of 2 years. I think they should work on this from the very start to deliver the most intense and rewarding experience in the series for thouse final moments, and then give us some fan-service epilogue for us to be able to say farewell to all characters we came to Love !!

[RiGoRmOrTiS_UK]

we need to keep this video bumped. If Bioware cares about the fans they'll answer these issues directly. rather than giving us PR guff right before a weekend.

Modifié par RiGoRmOrTiS_UK, 18 mars 2012 - 09:38 .