376 réponses à ce sujet

[MikeRoz]

2484Stryker wrote...

Now I'm concerned that IGN will lump those who haven't played it with those who enjoyed the ending and say "oh look, only ~50% disliked the ending!"

I mean, why create a poll asking people about the ending and then have those who haven't even played it vote? Shouldn't it just be "yes, I liked the ending." and "no, I didn't likte it"...

Maybe I missed something in statistics 101...

Even if they do, it doesn't look good to say that those who disliked the ending are *only* a majority.

Modifié par MikeRoz, 19 mars 2012 - 03:37 .

[-Skorpious-]

Somebody needs to printscreen the graph at regular intervals so IGN cannot claim that we are the minority on THEIR OWN POLL if they decide to pull a fast one and combine the "Like" and "Haven't finished" options into one category.

Modifié par -Skorpious-, 19 mars 2012 - 03:40 .

[gee666]

1 in 5 like the ending

[AusitnDrake]

-Skorpious- wrote...

Somebody needs to printscreen the graph at regular intervals so IGN cannot claim that we are the minority on THEIR OWN POLL if they decide to pull a fast one and combine the "Like" and "Haven't finished" options into one category.

That was excatly why I said earlier. Glad I'm not the only person that thinks so.

AusitnDrake wrote...

I suggest everyone get a Print Screen of the page, at the very least once.
So we have proof of the disperity between Yes!s and Nope!s.
That way they can't alter the data and claim most people like it anyway.
As we will have proof, at least of the numbers at the time of the Print Screen.

[Dark Specie]

MikeRoz wrote...

Even if they do, it doesn't look good to say that those who disliked the ending are *only* a majority.

Right. Though they can always try to pull the "We are the smart & enlighted minority!" card

[AusitnDrake]

Dark Specie wrote...

MikeRoz wrote...

Even if they do, it doesn't look good to say that those who disliked the ending are *only* a majority.

Right. Though they can always try to pull the "We are the smart & enlighted minority!" card

Then we can just pull the "then explain all the plot holes in detail for us "unenlighted" majority" card.
So far I haven't seen someone able to convinvingly plug one let alone all of them.
Every close attempt has only lead to the creation of more plot holes.

Modifié par AusitnDrake, 19 mars 2012 - 03:48 .

[Untamed98]

Dark Specie wrote...

MikeRoz wrote...

Even if they do, it doesn't look good to say that those who disliked the ending are *only* a majority.

Right. Though they can always try to pull the "We are the smart & enlighted minority!" card

It doesn't matter what card they pull since the purpose of a poll is to look at the numbers. It would be like a President losing an election just to be given the presidency anyway because "His voters must have been smarter just because!".

[FRancium]

85% of finished voted they didn't like the ending.
even if you add in the unfinished votes, it's coming out at 64% unhappy.

I don't know if I should feel vindicated, or just sad.

[AusitnDrake]

FRancium wrote...

85% of finished voted they didn't like the ending.
even if you add in the unfinished votes, it's coming out at 64% unhappy.

I don't know if I should feel vindicated, or just sad.

Sad for IGN? Why? They wanted proof. There it is.
Not the proof they wanted. But they did ask for it.

I suppose it is sad in a pathetic sort of way.

Modifié par AusitnDrake, 19 mars 2012 - 03:51 .

[Dark Specie]

AusitnDrake wrote...
Then we can just pull the "then explain all the plot holes in detail for us "unenlighted" majority" card.
So far I haven't seen someone able to convinvingly plug one let alone all of them.
Every close attempt has only lead to the creation of more plot holes.

There's that, I guess...

[FRancium]

AusitnDrake wrote...

FRancium wrote...

85% of finished voted they didn't like the ending.
even if you add in the unfinished votes, it's coming out at 64% unhappy.

I don't know if I should feel vindicated, or just sad.

Sad for IGN? Why? They wanted proof. There it is.
Not the proof they wanted. But they did ask for it.

Nah, sad for the franchise:wizard:

[SandTrout]

Still at 85% of all completions disliking the end.

[Dark Specie]

FRancium wrote...

AusitnDrake wrote...

FRancium wrote...

85% of finished voted they didn't like the ending.
even if you add in the unfinished votes, it's coming out at 64% unhappy.

I don't know if I should feel vindicated, or just sad.

Sad for IGN? Why? They wanted proof. There it is.
Not the proof they wanted. But they did ask for it.

Nah, sad for the franchise:wizard:

Agreed. This isn't how I imagined thigns would be...

[Jayce]

It's important to note people who click I haven't finished yet can't go back and give a verdict either way when they have.... a sublty devious way of skewing the result. 

scratch that, they can. was just my fb page playing silly buggers.

Modifié par Jayce F, 19 mars 2012 - 04:08 .

[bpzrn]

Battalion wrote...

Ewww. IGN.

Agree I wont do a thing for or with them, no credability after the BS reviews and articles.

[Empiro3]

More than 85% of people who have finished don't like it. That's about as close to "universally hated" as you can get. For comparison, congress only has an 82% disapproval rating.

[JohnnyG]

JohnnyG wrote...

As of right now...

Yes: 935
No: 4,887
Haven't finished it yet: 2106

That was three hours ago.  Here is where it stands now...

Yes: 998
No: 5,757
Haven't finished it yet: 2192

Wow.  If that rate of growth continues, it will be amazing to see what it is like in the morning when I wake up.  Anyhow, I am heading off to bed.  Please try to keep this page up if you can so that people will continue to vote.

[wijse]

Why bother with IGN?

[JohnnyG]

wijse wrote...

Why bother with IGN?

LOL!  I love that pic.  And as to why bother, its really a matter of using their own poll against them so that they can't say "Hey, look, those people who don't like the ending are just small percentage".  That's my thought anyhow.

[TurambarEA]

zennyrpg wrote...

Voted, then closed. Gotta wash the ign off my hands now...

This. Every time I hear "IGN" I get flashbacks to a deadpan fourth-wall breaking Allers 'news report'.

[FRancium]

wijse wrote...

Why bother with IGN?

haha  
but seriously insulting IGN won't get us anywhere. Pointing out their mistakes make them look foolish enough.

[Kumekerion]

Spread the word, the more major polls we answer the better!

[FRancium]

must bump this. Whatever you thought of the ending, Please vote people!

[M12311]

Voted

[SAVIOUR OF ORB]

Yeah more proof that we "passionate fans" are not a minority. That and honestly you really don't need to be one to know that the ending doesn't work on so many levels.