499 réponses à ce sujet

[LucyMaire]

Good!!! I won't give up either, even if it takes the rest of the year.

[Cosmochyck]

Emeraldfern wrote...

I somehow missed this thread but,  I support this. 

In ME2 when romanced, Thane had finally stopped defining himself with his own death and wished for a life with Shepard.
In ME3, his illness is the only thing one can speak to him about. That isn't good writing.
His death is logical when you did not romance him.

As someone who almost lost my mother to stroke ten years ago, and had to watch her come to terms with the scars left behind by the stroke, and finally see her accept that no, she was not defined by her illness.

I really did not need this game to be reminded of the time when I was helpless to aid my mother.
And to my Shepard it would have meant everything to have Thane by her side when she faces the Reapers.

Just like it mattered to those with Liara to have "blue babies", and building Tali a house on the homeworld, Thane's life mattered to me.

And I will not give up. Ever.

Me either!  I've been tweeting like crazy and check my sig for the facebook page.  I miss him.  My Shep misses him. 

[Visii]

Emeraldfern wrote...

I somehow missed this thread but,  I support this. 

In ME2 when romanced, Thane had finally stopped defining himself with his own death and wished for a life with Shepard.
In ME3, his illness is the only thing one can speak to him about. That isn't good writing.
His death is logical when you did not romance him.

As someone who almost lost my mother to stroke ten years ago, and had to watch her come to terms with the scars left behind by the stroke, and finally see her accept that no, she was not defined by her illness.

I really did not need this game to be reminded of the time when I was helpless to aid my mother.
And to my Shepard it would have meant everything to have Thane by her side when she faces the Reapers.

Just like it mattered to those with Liara to have "blue babies", and building Tali a house on the homeworld, Thane's life mattered to me.

And I will not give up. Ever.

Hold the line!

[mnomaha]

You got me too!

[Nube9]

thanks guys! Im writing a much better rough draft, this needs to of course be handled with tact so between this and my other responsibilities is taking a bit longer than I expected. I look forward to posting it here one final time in hopes the rest of you can add to it.

[coldwetn0se]

18 hours, baby!! Supported! Off to bed....getting weird.

[mnomaha]

@Coldi..."getting". ROFL

[Julia_xo]

I won't give up on Thane, either. It doesn't hurt to keep trying. If we scream loud enough, maybe BioWare will finally hear.

[danteliveson]

Tried bringing unloyal Thane into 3 but he died holding the line.

[RShara]

Visii wrote...

Emeraldfern wrote...

I somehow missed this thread but,  I support this. 

In ME2 when romanced, Thane had finally stopped defining himself with his own death and wished for a life with Shepard.
In ME3, his illness is the only thing one can speak to him about. That isn't good writing.
His death is logical when you did not romance him.

As someone who almost lost my mother to stroke ten years ago, and had to watch her come to terms with the scars left behind by the stroke, and finally see her accept that no, she was not defined by her illness.

I really did not need this game to be reminded of the time when I was helpless to aid my mother.
And to my Shepard it would have meant everything to have Thane by her side when she faces the Reapers.

Just like it mattered to those with Liara to have "blue babies", and building Tali a house on the homeworld, Thane's life mattered to me.

And I will not give up. Ever.

Hold the line!

HOLD THE DRELL!

[RogueSentinel]

Oh no, the dying character DIED. Screw you for not thinking his story was awesome the way it was. He even saved your Shep's life (maybe).

[RShara]

RShara wrote...

Daicotje wrote...

Like I've said many times already, it isn't the death of Thane itself that has many fans mad, it's the way that his romance was completely reduced to nothing.
For a Shepard who is only friends with him, I think Thane was okay. But NOT for a Shepard who romanced him.

There are many posts before this one that give you more details about why and how, so I suggest you read those.

[mnomaha]

Licking Holding the Drell!

Saluting the trolls...with both fingers.

[Bocks]

THANE DIES.

DEAL WITH IT.

[Xeyska]

Bocks wrote...

THANE DIES.

DEAL WITH IT.

Read the thread first.

[disc0nnect7]

Bocks wrote...

THANE DIES.

DEAL WITH IT.

no

[mnomaha]

RShara wrote...

RShara wrote...

Daicotje wrote...

Like I've said many times already, it isn't the death of Thane itself that has many fans mad, it's the way that his romance was completely reduced to nothing.
For a Shepard who is only friends with him, I think Thane was okay. But NOT for a Shepard who romanced him.

There are many posts before this one that give you more details about why and how, so I suggest you read those.

[Saodade]

Emeraldfern wrote...

I somehow missed this thread but,  I support this. 

In ME2 when romanced, Thane had finally stopped defining himself with his own death and wished for a life with Shepard.
In ME3, his illness is the only thing one can speak to him about. That isn't good writing.
His death is logical when you did not romance him.

As someone who almost lost my mother to stroke ten years ago, and had to watch her come to terms with the scars left behind by the stroke, and finally see her accept that no, she was not defined by her illness.

I really did not need this game to be reminded of the time when I was helpless to aid my mother.
And to my Shepard it would have meant everything to have Thane by her side when she faces the Reapers.

Just like it mattered to those with Liara to have "blue babies", and building Tali a house on the homeworld, Thane's life mattered to me.

And I will not give up. Ever.

I will never give up either.
Hold our Drell

[Visii]

Julia_xo wrote...

I won't give up on Thane, either. It doesn't hurt to keep trying. If we scream loud enough, maybe BioWare will finally hear.

Yes!

This thread's been able to keep on the first two pages for almost a week now. IF they ever come in here it's not like they can miss seeing us...

[Eowyn77]

Daicotje wrote...

Like I've said many times already, it isn't the death of Thane itself that has many fans mad, it's the way that his romance was completely reduced to nothing. For a Shepard who is only friends with him, I think Thane was okay. But NOT for a Shepard who romanced him.

There are many posts before this one that give you more details about why and how, so I suggest you read those.

Couldn’t have said it better myself. This is exactly what it is about.

mnomaha wrote...

Licking Holding the Drell!

Saluting the trolls...with both fingers.

I second both these notions. :innocent:

Modifié par Eowyn77, 23 mars 2012 - 03:11 .

[utaker1988]

mnomaha wrote...

Licking Holding the Drell!

Saluting the trolls...with both fingers.

Heh heh...definitely on board for the first.  As for the second, as I like to say when I give my seal of disapproval, "look I think so highly of that line of thought, I'm putting up my You're Number One finger."

[Visii]

So...

Thane.

Sick.

Fix.

Now.

[mnomaha]

@utaker...LOL yes, used to be single salute but NZ is an English commonwealth country and they're into doubles.

@Visii...Even a ** writer should be able to understand that.

Modifié par mnomaha, 23 mars 2012 - 09:56 .

[Drimberly]

R.I.P Thane. You are to cool do need somthing close to the ending dlc.

[RShara]

Thanks for signing Drimberly!