34 réponses à ce sujet

[Degs29]

Maybe this has already been done, but I thought it'd be interesting to run one myself.  Here's the deal...rate your squadmates from favourite to least favourite and I'll pool the numbers and assign an average to see which squadmate really does come out on top (and in second, third, and so on).  If you never interacted with a certain squadmate, don't include them in your list (for example, if you didn't recruit Morinth or haven't played the Zaeed, Kasumi and/or Javik DLC).  This won't have either a negative or positive effect on their average.  Please number your selection and if you wish to comment on your choices, do it separately at the end of your post.  Here's a list of the 20 squadmates in alphabetical order (first name):

-Ashley
-EDI
-Garrus
-Grunt
-Jack
-Jacob
-James
-Javik
-Kaidan
-Kasumi
-Legion
-Liara
-Miranda
-Mordin
-Morinth
-Samara
-Tali
-Thane
-Wrex
-Zaeed

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Current Standings (After 7 Rankings):

1) Garrus - 2.71
2) Mordin - 5.86
3) Wrex - 6.00
4) Legion - 6.71
5) Thane - 7.14
6) James - 8.14
7) Kaidan - 8.57
8) Miranda - 9.83
9) Liara - 10.43
10) Javik - 10.67
11) Grunt - 10.71
12) Kasumi - 11.43
13) Ashley - 11.57
14) Jack - 11.71
15) Samara - 12.00
16) EDI - 12.14
17) Zaeed - 12.71
18) Tali - 13.00
19) Jacob - 17.71
20) Morinth - 18.00

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

My own rankings:

Awesome:
1)  Liara
2)  Mordin
3)  Garrus
4)  Miranda
5)  Legion
6)  Wrex

Good:
7)  Thane
8)  EDI
9)  Jack
10)  Ashley
11)  Grunt
12)  Samara

Not Interesting (to me):
13)  James
14)  Zaeed
15)  Tali
16)  Kaidan
17)  Kasumi
18)  Jacob

Modifié par Degs29, 20 mars 2012 - 06:26 .

[Avolie]

Love
1) Garrus

Like
2) Legion
3) Mordin
4) Thane

Still like
5) James
6) Kaidan
7) Wrex
8) Kasumi

Don't care
9) Liara
10) Javic
11) Tali
12) EDI
13) Zaeed
14) Ashley
15) Jack
16) Samara

Dislike
17) Miranda
18) Grunt (liked him in ME 3 though ... but in ME 2 he was just annoying)
19) Jacob
20) Morinth

Modifié par Avolie, 20 mars 2012 - 02:28 .

[Aggie Punbot]

My absolute favorites:

1). Kaidan
2). Garrus
3). James.
4). Javik.
5). Jack.
6). Grunt

Still pretty good:

7). Wrex.
8). Legion
9). Mordin
10). Thane
11). Kasumi
12). Zaeed

Don't really use them that often but they're still top notch:

13). Ashley
14). Miranda
15). Liara
16). Samara
17). Tali
18). EDI
19). Jacob
20). Morinth
----------------
I think the reason Miranda and Jacob aren't rated higher is because I always get Kasumi and Zaeed right off the bat and since I roleplay Shepards that detest Cerberus, my Shepard isn't overly fond of taking those two out on any missions (under the belief that they're spying on him/her for TIM).

I try to keep a relatively balanced team when we're out on missions, and since Kaidan is always on my squad whenever he's available, the other team mate depends entirely on what class I'm playing (normally something with biotics so I don't ever really *need* Liara on my team). If the balance doesn't matter, I take whoever's got the most interesting banter.

Modifié par TS2Aggie, 20 mars 2012 - 02:55 .

[Zulufoxtrot]

 

Bro for Life:
1. Garrus

Awesome:
2. Mordin Solus
3. Legion 
4. Zaeed 
5. Miranda
6. Tali

Good: 
7. Wrex
8. Samara
9. EDI
10. Ashley
11. Grunt
12. James
13 Javik
14. Thane

Not Interesting to me

15. Kasumi 
16. Kaidan
17. Jach
18. Jacob
19. Morinth
20. Liara

Modifié par Zulufoxtrot, 20 mars 2012 - 02:55 .

[utaker1988]

Loved/Took Everywhere:
1. Thane
2. Javik
3. Wrex

Good
4. Garrus
5. Kasumi
6. James
7. Mordin
8. Legion
9. Grunt
10.Jack
11.Samara
12.Zaeed
13.Tali
14.EDI
15.Ashley
16.Miranda

Didn't Like/Killed them first chance I got
17.Morinth (vents)
18.Jacob (vents or Thane biotic bubble w/Miranda and Jacob)
19.Kaidan (Virmire'd or Udina Coup)
20.Liara (stripped of plot armor having very low EMS and worst Destroy option)

[LadyofRivendell]

Absolutely Adore/Never left my side:
1. Kaidan
2. Ashley (dead)
3. Miranda

Love:
4. Liara
5. Garrus

Like:
6. EDI (Dead?)
7. Wrex
8. James
9. Kasumi
10. Samara
11. Mordin (Dead)

Meh:
12. Thane (Dead)
13. Legion (Dead)
14. Grunt
15. Tali

Didn't like/Never used
16. Javik
17. Jack
18. Zaeed
19. Jacob
20. Morinth (dead)

And I'll assume my opinion is radically different from the majority.
Edit: Added who's alive and who's dead. Only Morinth and Ashley died by my doing, and only Morinth died by my doing and my entertainment.

Modifié par LadyofRivendell, 20 mars 2012 - 03:53 .

[Degs29]

Awesome guys!  Looks like Garrus is currently the undisputed champion.

Current Standings (After 7 Rankings):

1)  Garrus - 2.71
2)  Mordin - 5.86
3)  Wrex - 6.00
4)  Legion - 6.71
5)  Thane - 7.14
6)  James - 8.14
7)  Kaidan - 8.57
8)  Miranda - 9.83
9)  Liara - 10.43
10)  Javik - 10.67
11)  Grunt - 10.71
12)  Kasumi - 11.43
13)  Ashley - 11.57
14)  Jack - 11.71
15)  Samara - 12.00
16)  EDI - 12.14
17)  Zaeed - 12.71
18)  Tali - 13.00
19)  Jacob - 17.71
20)  Morinth - 18.00


Support your favourites and denounce your most hated!  Submit your own rankings and I'll add them.

[sammcl]

• Mordin
• Miranda
• EDI
• Legion
• Kasumi
• James
• Javik
• Garrus
• Thane
• Grunt
• Wrex
• Tali
• Kaidan
• Samara
• Liara
• Zaeed
• Jacob
• Jack
• Ashley

[kookie28]

1. Miranda
2. Garrus
3. Grunt
4. Legion
5. Mordin
6. Wrex
7. Thane
8. Samara
9. Jacob
10. Tali
11. Zaeed
12. Ashley
13. Jack
14. Javik
15. James
16. Kasumi
17. EDI
18. Kaiden
19. Liara

[mythlover20]

Love:
Thane.
Garrus

Awesome:
Jack
Kasumi
Samara
Legion

Good
Mordin
EDI
Grunt

Not Interesting (to me):
Jacob
Kaidan
Ashley
Wrex/Weave
Zaeed
Miranda
Liara
Tali

[Knightly_BW]

Love (Most used in teams)
1 - Miranda
2 - Thane
3 - Kaidan
4 - Liara

Love (Not regular team members)
5 - Jack
6 - Legion
7 - Mordin
8 - Grunt

Like
9 - Ashley
10 - Tali
11 - Garrus
12 - Zaeed
13 - Morinth

Indifferent
14 - EDI
15 - Samara

Disliked (Went all renegade and killed if opportunity arise)
16 - Jacob
17 - Vega

Edit: Added Morinth to list whom I forgot.

Modifié par Asperius, 22 mars 2012 - 02:52 .

[NGC1300]

1.Kaidan
2.Kaidan
3.Kaidan
4.Kaidan
5.Kaidan
6.Kaidan
7.Kaidan
8.Kaidan
9.Kaidan
10.Kaidan
11.Kaidan
12.Kaidan
13.Kaidan
14.Kaidan
15.Liara
16.EDI
17.Miranda
18.Jack
19.Samara

sorry... those are actually the only squadmates that I used throughout the entire 3 games =/ (excluding the forced squadmates, of course)

[Cosmochyck]

LOVE:
1) Thane
2) Mordin

Very good:
Garrus
Kasumi
Samara
Jack
Legion
Zaeed

Good:
Kaidan
Wrex/Wreav/Grunt
Liara

Never take anywhere, ever
EDI
Jacob
Ashley
Miranda
Tali

[Julia_xo]

Love:
1)Thane

Awesome:
2)Garrus
3)Mordin
4)Legion

Good:
5)Jack
6)Miranda
7)Javik
8)Wrex
9)Grunt
10)Samara
11)Kasumi
12)Zaeed
13)Liara

Not Interesting (to me):
14)EDI
15)James
16)Tali
17)Kaidan
18)Jacob
19)Ashley
20)Morinth

[Aquarius]

1) Liara
2) Garrus
3) Tali
4) Mordin  
5) EDI
6) Vega

7) Samara
8)  Jack
9)  Miranda
10)  Ashley/Kaidan
11) Javik
12) Wrex

13)  Thane
14)  Kasumi
15)  Morinth
16)  Grunt
17)  Zaeed
18) Jacob

Modifié par Wasserfrau, 22 mars 2012 - 07:26 .

[Hadeedak]

Love
1) Garrus (he is a vanguard backup MACHINE)

Awesome
2) Thane
3) Samara
4) Mordin
5) Tali
6) Kasumi

Good
7) Jack
8) Javik
9) James
10) Miranda
11) Liara
12) Wrex
13) Grunt
14) EDI
15) Kaidan
16) Ashley
17) Zaheed
18) Jacob
19) Legion

Not interesting to me

20) Morinth

[jdckelly]

Adore
1) Garrus
2) Tali
3) Liara
4) Wrex
5) Kasumi

Like
6) Jack
7) Miranda
8) Mordin
9) Grunt
10) Thane
11) Javik
12) Legion
13) James

Meh
14) Samara
15) Zaeed
16) Ashley
17) Jacob
18) EDI
19) Morinth

Hated
20) Kaiden

Modifié par jdckelly, 22 mars 2012 - 03:33 .

[Mr. Big Pimpin]

1. Tali
2. Garrus
3. Legion
4. Mordin
5. Liara
6. Javik
7. Wrex
8. Thane
9. EDI
10. Jack
11. Kasumi
12. Kaidan
13. Grunt
14. Vega
15. Samara
16. Zaeed
17. Miranda
18. Ashley
19. Jacob
20. Morinth

[evan365]

1.Garrus
2.Mordin
3.Thane
4.Wrex
5.Liara
6.Grunt
7.Tali
8.Legion
9James
10.Javik
11.Jacob
12.Miranda
13.Kasumi
14.Zaeed
15.Ashley
16.Kaiden
17.Samara
18.EDI
19.Jack
20.Morinth

[jmaster888]

 Favorite:
1: Wrex
2: Garrus
3: Grunt
4: Legion
5: Miranda
Like:
6: Javik
7: Tali
8: Liara
9: Mordin
10: Vega
11: Kasumi
12: Thane
Meh:
13: Samara
14: Zaeed
15: EDI (as a squadmate ofc.)
Dislike:
16: Jacob
17: Ashley
18: Kaidan
Hate:
19: Jack

Modifié par jmaster888, 22 mars 2012 - 04:32 .

[Oninotaki]

Here is mine:

1. Jack
2. Garrus
3. Legion
4. Mordin
5. Thane
6. Zaeed
7. EDI
8. Kasumi
9. Samara
10. Wrex
11. Tali
12. Vega
13. Grunt
14. Jacob
15. Ashely
16. Kaiden
17. Liara
18. Miranda
19. Morinth
20. Javik

[istle]

This is a list for in combat, of course.

~~~~~Beyond Awesome
01 Garrus
02 Miranda
03 Thane
04 Liara
05 Javik
06 Grunt
07 Jack
~~~~~Awesome
08 Kaidan
09 Kasumi
10 Wrex
11 Ashley
12 EDI
13 Mordin
~~~~~Never Really Used That Much
14 Tali
15 Samara
16 Vega
17 Legion

And I only used Jacob and Zaeed when the game forced me to really.

Modifié par istle, 22 mars 2012 - 04:34 .

[DHR107]

Played using everyone apart from Morinth because I've never really played a Renegade character. Mordin has the best personality and some of the best lines of dialogue in the game. Shame they changed his voice actor for ME3.... I noticed instantly

1. Mordin (By miles) 
2. Tali 
3. Garrus
4. Thane
5. Liara
6. Legion 
7. Kasumi
8. Wrex
9. Grunt
10. Javik
11. Ashley
12. Zaeed
13. Samara
14. Edi
15. Jack
16. Jacob
17. Vega
18. Kaiden
19. Miranda

Never Used: Morinth...