285 réponses à ce sujet

[CrazyRah]

Absolutely!

[Barquiel]

Every single time

[Wynterdust]

No. His actions were understandable and he did the right thing as a soldier. He's an admiral for a reason he knows how to wage war. The geth receiving the code is a complete unknown at the time as well and again he did the right thing in his position. Notice how he backs down when the situation is explained by Shepard properly.
The quarians wellbeing is his top priority just as much as Tali or Koris, I'm not going to punch the guy for doing his job.
I believe Koris' methods and actions were stronger but Gerrel's are understandable.

[Khelish]

No.

[GeneralMoskvin_2.0]

C'mere Gerrel.

I
*Gerrel takes one to the crotch*
punch
*Yet another one*
him
*punch*
every
*ow*
god
*this must hurt*
damn
*ewww*
time
*free vasectomy*

Well yes, I do it sometimes.

[S.A.K]

I can't punch him for shooting the Geth. Not after they sided with the Reapers.

[Spartas Husky]

Cthulhu42 wrote...

Spartas Husky wrote...

He endanger and further causes casualties to the fleet by staying.

Yeah, because retreat was such a viable option, right? Look how successfully it turns out if you fail to rescue Koris and a sizable portion of the Civilian Fleet tries to flee. It's not like they get slaughtered or anything, right?

What with your attitude man.

The option was vialble to shut down after the reaper signal had been destroyed. As legion then explained the geth were under temporary distress until the short range signal was in place. So during that period the geth had reverted back to the normal selfs.

Han also states that the geth have reorganize and are now engandering the fleet.

So you can save your ridiculous attitude and pay attention to the dialogue. There was a window of opportunity for the Quarians to punch through Geth lines and flee from the system.

A window he lost by concentrating on destroying the Dreadnought rather than escaping.

[sH0tgUn jUliA]

S.A.K wrote...

I can't punch him for shooting the Geth. Not after they sided with the Reapers.

No. Because I told Gerrel to counterattack as soon as I got the dreadnought's shields down. Why would I punch him for following the battle plan?

My strategic plan from the beginning once I found they had been successful in the war up to the point of the reaper signal was figuring out a way of destroying the reaper emitting the signal, destroying it, and winning the war, then delivering the Quarian fleet to Hackett.

Mission successful.

Modifié par sH0tgUn jUliA, 20 avril 2013 - 08:42 .

[Ledgend1221]

Of course.
He destroyed the most powerful ship in the galaxy.

[CDR David Shepard]

I wanted to...but I was afraid that renegade interrupt would make Shepard kill him...considering the circumstance. So I didn't click it.

[S.A.K]

Ledgend1221 wrote...

Of course.
He destroyed the most powerful ship in the galaxy.

Lol. The most powerful ship in the galaxy would be Harbinger. You should punch yourself for destroying that one.








jk. I know what you mean.

[Spartas Husky]

S.A.K wrote...

Ledgend1221 wrote...

Of course.
He destroyed the most powerful ship in the galaxy.

Lol. The most powerful ship in the galaxy would be Harbinger. You should punch yourself for destroying that one.








jk. I know what you mean.

Wait wait wait. The Geth flaship is 30% bigger than an average dreadnought. But the destiny ascension is 4 times larger than an average dreadnought.

Modifié par Spartas Husky, 20 avril 2013 - 09:06 .

[cyrexwingblade]

My canon Shep yells at him (she was pushing for retreat, and that was the plan going into the situation), but resists the powerful urge to punch him. Her fist clenching during the queue is quite appropriate for my Shep.

And yes, she's almost purely Paragon, but she's a soldier. You stick to the plan, get civilians out of the way, and *generally try to avoid friendly fire*.

[Dunabar]

I told him to counter attack and I should punch him for following through? Lol no, sorry last I checked that is following up on my request. Yeah getting fired upon wasn't fun, but hey nobody was hurt, and I wouldn't give the enemy a chance to return to full strength either. So I think I will have a drink with Han'Gerrel on Rannoch and we will compare Synthetic-deactivation notches.

[Ryzaki]

My Shep punches him yeah.

The fool. Ah well his "attack attack attack." blows up in his face when he uses it again.

[Kataphrut94]

My Paragon is restrained enough to merely reprimand him. My Renegade and Renegon have no such reservations.

[nani7788]

Of course.

[Reofeir]

Paragade Shepard doesn't like being almost blown up. A punch is needed .

[Jonathan Shepard]

Yeah. I was actually clicking the button to punch him before I even knew there'd be an interrupt. One of the most natural-feeling roleplaying choices in the whole series.

[Galbrant]

I'd kill him if they let me... I couldn't care less if the whole Quarian fleet turns against me. Nobody tries to kills the Shepard and gets away with it.... Unless you're Kai Leng with plot armor and the ability to lower everyone's IQ to a single digit.

[remydat]

Every f**king time.

Gherel was told to retreat once the ship was disabled. I save their a** and he decides to go off script and fire. He risked killing an ally and a guy instrumental in the larger Reaper War because of his little war with the Geth. This would be like risking killing someone important in fighting WWII because of a border skirmish.

Further, if not for Legion, Tali and I may have floated off into space and likely died. This dude is luckly I don't put a bullet in his f**king head and then say, "I am a Spectre b*tch." What the hell are the Quarians going to do? They have spent 300 years getting f**king by the Council and they will shut the hell up and take it because if not then they will die.

Modifié par remydat, 21 avril 2013 - 01:08 .

[MassivelyEffective0730]

Yeah. He nearly screwed his own species just to carry out his misguided vendetta against the Geth.

Even if you debate that it wasn't misguided, he was being directly reckless with the lives of his people, almost blackmailing them to help him instead of getting them to safety.

[frostajulie]

Every ****ing time.