152 réponses à ce sujet

[Amaranthy]

There were 3 big plotholes in the end for me:

1) Shepard lives in the destroy option even though The Catalyst said that he would die since he was part synthetic. If Shepard lived then so do all other synthetics?

2) Why was Joker speeding away from the shockwave? Why wasn't he near Earth? From what I understand, it was impossible for him to use the Mass Relay (the Mass Relay wasn't even near Earth), only being able to use Normandy' FTL to escape, so where exactly did Normandy land? Didn't seem like our solar system.

3) Why didn't Liara and Garrus show their teleportation skills earlier (they were my squadmates on Earth)? Funny how they were suddenly on Normandy

Modifié par Amaranthy, 21 mars 2012 - 12:03 .

[Soaringeagle78]

Umm... You listed three...

[Generic Name]

All of the above. They are all equally major.

[Avissel]

The biggest one for me was the whole "Sovreign has to open the citadel even though the citadel is an intellegant entity that is on the Reapers side" thing.

[Dragonfable of Dain]

I have a big problem with your first big plothole, dosn't that mean all advance tech gets destroyed?
That would result in countless more deaths...

[ploppy54]

why does my shepard appear back on the normandy after the credits roll?

[Simpfan]

Normandy.

Thats the only thing that confuses me.

[StealthTH]

I want to know why the star around Haestrom was dying so young!!!! (plus others that you mentioned)

[Maike91]

Why did my crew leave me so they could crash on a planet where two of them are going to starve?

[XxBrokenBonezxX]

How my LI comes out of the Normandy like NOTHING HAPPENED

[Noatz]

Oh I can't choose, there are simply too many.

Ok probably the Normandy crash scene. It contradicts so many established facts it can't possibly be true.

Modifié par Noatz, 21 mars 2012 - 12:01 .

[whydoyouwanttoknow]

Shepard spending the entire 3 games fighting against the Reapers and then at the end he meets the enemy leader and doesn't exactly what that leader tells him to do without question or thought.

[vkt62]

No pre-Prothean back story from the one person who can answer it.

No answers on who the star child is and what are the Keepers specially after talking about them in ME1 and ME2.

If they want to keep the ending thats fine, but please justify it with enough back story. Part of the problem was that you went from meeting the star child to making the choices in less than 5 mins without back story.

[JrSlackin]

I think the Normandy fleeing is the big one honestly.

With everything else we could easisly sit here and do all the "discussing on the ending". With the Normandy fleeing it was just an added, "why is my crew and Joker running?"

That to me is the big plothole.

[Hudathan]

The whole series is filled with plot holes.

[spiriticon]

Earth surviving the destruction of the Mass Relays. Can't explain that one in my head.

[Maike91]

Hudathan wrote...

The whole series is filled with plot holes.

There are so many holes that there is no more plot left.

[Carlthestrange]

Joker was obviously trying in vain to outrun the plothole. But sadly it caught him.

[clarkusdarkus]

shephard telling saren his an idiot for being controlled then doing it himself

[Alexraptor1]

Biggest plothole for me is the entire retcon of the reapers and their motives.

In ME1 Sovereign considered him, themselves, as the pinnacle of evolution, and that they were beyond the comprehension of organics.
Organic life was just an accident, a random mutation, and that the only reason it exists is because its been "allowed to".

But in ME3 suddenly, the reapers are all about saving and preserving organic life, and that it is the sole reason for which they were created......WTF?

[LilyasAvalon]

StarChild: I created the reapers.

Me: ...Kay', so who are you?

Starchild: The citadel.

Me: . . .

[soozy]

The destruction of the mass relays and the terrible consequences that they entail: do they destroy all life except for the Normandy? Is everyone stranded on earth since fuel to get everyone back to their star systems is likely unavailable? If the best case scenario is that millions of people are stranded around Earth, what about the consequences these have, for example is peace on Tuchanka is impossible now with Wrex being stranded?

I think that if these questions were addressed at some point I'd be happier. I'd still think the ending was incredibly bad, but it wouldn't ruin the series for me like it is right now.

[Johnnycide]

The biggest for me, is why would Shepard after resisting the Reapers so ardently and suspecting nearly anyone of being indoctrinated suddenly resign themselves to accepting the choices presented by the Catalyst who admits to being in control of the Reapers?

[Amaranthy]

Soaringeagle78 wrote...

Umm... You listed three...

Fixed

Thank you for pointing that out.