Dave Hoffman wrote...
It all reminds me of Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic 2. Those not familiar, Google it. To make their Christmas shopping deadline, Obsidian shoved that thing out the door with an ending thrown together with sticky notes and masking tape. Some smart people dug into the game files and found loads of spoken dialog and cut-scenes for an ending that was never developed.
This whole situation has given me flashbacks to KotOR2 as well. Glad I'm not the only one.
As for subject at hand, I think the sharp contrast between the pre-release quotes and the last 20 minutes of ME3 serve to accent why fans are so upset, but I'm not sure I entirely agree about the false advertising claim.
In my mind, wiping out the mass relays pretty much equals destroying the Mass Effect universe or turning it into something so unrecognizable as to be about the same thing. Thus, it felt like no matter how many weighty decisions had come before, it was all rendered moot after that point. If that is true and additional 'content initiatives' bear that conclusion out, then I will jump on the false advertising bandwagon no problem.
However, if BioWare's opinion of that event (pretty sure there are some fans with this view as well) is that the destruction of the mass relays somehow does
not mean everyone in Shepard's timeline dies (or suffers horribly and then dies) then I feel they can make a case about the 'wildly different endings'.
Why? Because in a sense, you are deciding what races will live and die throughout the game. If I chose to let the geth wipe out the quarians in my game, but you chose to make peace between them in yours, then we could argue that the universe after that point would indeed be very different, regardless of which colored explosion stopped the Reapers in the last 10 minutes.
For me, the relays are the sticking point. I could use my imagination and assume the rest of my crew was off doing whatever they had planned before the final battle, but not if the state of the universe is indeed as hopeless as it currently appears to be after Shepard gets done 'saving' it.