219 réponses à ce sujet

[AxisEvolve]

MSNBC has a habit of only seeing one side of the spectrum. I am (mostly) liberal but I can't deny their bias or their inability to look past a viewpoint other than their own.

Modifié par AxisEvolve, 23 mars 2012 - 08:38 .

[thebigbad1013]

He didn't see any plotholes? Okay, either he A: didn't play the game or any of the others,B:played the game with his eyes closed, or C:is just plain lying. Either way...disappointing.

[Chai Te]

Dridengx wrote...

DVZ wrote...

ticklefist wrote...

Same dude also called SWTOR the 2011 GOTY.

Another Bioware title. Surprise surprise.

Instead of thinking everyone is paid off did you ever consider maybe he's into Sci Fi? Star Wars is legendary, Mass Effect is the biggest Sci Fi rpg of this generation. It doesn't take a genius to notice the connection. You guys said it yourselves ME3 is amazing 99% of it except the last 10mins. So how far fetched is his review if he enjoyed the ending? stop making yourselves look so awful, wasn't the Charity enough for tonight?

If 75 out of 100 people in a class get a 100% on a test I'm more likely to think "rampant cheating" than "those folks must really know the material."

[Sevorast]

This guy is probably the worst reviewer in the history of bad reviewers. MSNBC at it's finest here folks, between them and Faux news you can sum up everything I hate about humanity pretty succinctly.

[wright1978]

Clearly indoctinated. Come on there's some huge plotholes.

[Turbotanden]

Siggs84 wrote...

ARE YOU KIDDING ME?  Watch this video... 

This Todd Kenreck guy needs to go back to playing pong.

Highlights:
"ME3 had, what I felt was a perfect ending to one of the best sci fi series ever"
"ME3 recieved a 10/10 from me and recieved 74 perfect scores from other video game critics"
"The ending was smart imaginative and in some cases may have gone over a few peoples' heads"
"it is a complex ending and a broader idea than many stories end on... as far as plot holes? I didn't see any"

It takes special skills to create more plotholes after using Deus ex machina. Literally God in the machine (Godchild in the Citadel).

[jkflipflopDAO]

VoodooDrackus wrote...

Look, we get it, you think the ending sucks and you feel there are plotholes, you feel Bioware gave you an inferior product, etc.

But the way most of you are behaving is much more confrontational/insulting/violent than a reviewer saying that the ending may have gone over some peoples heads.

Most of you seem to believe that anyone who doesn't think there are plotholes in the story, like me, is paid off or a total fan boy. Anyone who loves the ending and feels completely satisfied with it, like me, just doesn't see how it sucked or is obviously stupid or paid off.

What is sad is that no matter how much I try to explain my point of view, express how I feel about the ending it will just be discounted like I see others opinions being discounted throughout the threads. That sucks.

How can you be taken seriously if you won't even try to understand the opposite point of view or act a little more civil. I understand why the ending can be confusing and/or unintelligible. None of it is explained in clear terms. For me it is all about context, it is about knowing that you have stumbled those last steps from that long journey over the course of 3 games to change the galaxy forever. Your story is over, you are not watching someone elses story being played out to you, it is your story. You wouldn't really know what happens next. We are lucky we get anything at all after our sacrifice.

You know what? It doesn't matter. I am just giving my point of view, my opinion, my experience of the ending of the game. It is what I got out of it. It is my journey and I am not going to let anyone else taint that. I know it may not be yours, I know yours may have sucked and wasn't what you wanted and that is ok. But discounting anything anyone says by being hostile towards them doesn't help anyone. And you guys are doing it over and over again when the people you are being hostile to, that have a difference of opinion from you, are not being hostile to you at all.

Wait wait wait wait. . . 

You don't think there are any plotholes in the story?

Please, explain these, then.

[Anteocitis]

this is pretty much to be expected from all of the reviewers who scored the game perfectly.

They HAVE to defend their own review scores, and the easiest way to do that is to say that complaints only come from those who cant understand the complexities of the ending.

Self-fulfilling argument and patent tosh.

Of those 75 "perfect score" reviewers one has to wonder how many wrote their reviews before finishing the game, I imagine it would be the majority, although you will never get to see them admit as such.

[Kreid]

Opinions and all, but saying is perfect is a little too much. I don't outright hate the ending like many do, but I admit there are not only many plot holes but also that it feels rushed and makes player choice irrelevant.

[majormajormmajor]

'Likes: Penny Arcade'

No fecking surprise there

[AAAAAJKKRRRRYZZ]

Well this is MSNBC for you. Why do you think it has the worst rating on cable news?

[joe1852]

bioware payed him!!!!!!!!!!11!!1!!!

[Coolfaec]

Oh look, the media's STILL against our movement, how refreshing.

[thegame30]

wright1978 wrote...

Clearly indoctinated. Come on there's some huge plotholes.

/nod

Oh Marauder Shields you try to warn us but we didn't listen.

[gammle]

i wounder how much dollars they pay people to say what they want...then i mean Bio***...

since it seems alot news and media thinks the ending is so uber great and its nothing wrong whit it

[zhixson]

Siggs84 wrote...
blah blah blah
"The ending was smart imaginative and in some cases may have gone over a few peoples' heads"
blah blah blah

This is starting to bug me more and more each time it surfaces. 

"Oh, you just didn't get it." No, I got it, it was just 32 shades of stupid.

These hack reviewers are starting to look worse and worse as the weeks roll on. Do they really not see that they are pissing off large chunks of their readership whenever they open their mouths this way? I guess not, as they apparently see us as some sort of vocal rabble that is simply on a lower intellectual level. 

[mumwaldee369]

The emperor has no clothes. You can say we're not intelligent enough to understand all you want you freakin' sellout.

[ThatGuy39]

Well, considering that EA is probably one of MSNBC's advertisers... what would you expect him to say, the game sucked? These guys aren't going to tell the truth, not when it might hit them in the wallet.

[Zardoc]

What's MSNBC?