Aller au contenu

What role should the dwarves have in DA3?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
210 réponses à ce sujet

#51
jmd4

jmd4
  • Members
  • 44 messages
Let me make my bias clear immediately: I love dwarves and would love to see more of them in DA, both as playable characters, companions, and love interests (I haven't given up hope on a dwarven LI). DAO and the dwarven origin stories (especially Aeducan, as you might have guessed from my avatar and signature) swept me away in the mystery, power, and tragedy of the dwarves. Unlike dwarves in other franchises in my opinion, such as Warhammer or Dragonlance, the dwarves of DA have depth, dignity, and even beauty. They aren't jokes and are in fact major players in the world in spite of their isolation. I believe dwarves have a huge impact on the world of Thedas, and a big role to play, as well as narrative ideas yet to play out.

Dwarves mine and control the lyrium flow in Thedas, they are arguably the most talented engineers and crafters of all the races, and they also are the most connected to the darkspawn threat. Certainly their production of lyrium is critical--absolutely critical--to the future of mages and templars in DA and thus to the presumed story of DA3.

Beyond that, we have the city of Kal Sharok and all its wonders (and terrors, no doubt) to explore. That could be an entire game in and of itself. And the dwarves patrol and protect the Deep Roads, the most expedient (at least at one time) way to cross from one end of Thedas to the other. Thedas owes the dwarves a great debt, as do the other races (even elves, given that dwarves gave them sanctuary in Cadash Thaig). Even Tevinter owes them a debt for helping to form the Imperium.

I would say that you cannot have a game in Thedas that does not, in some way, take the presence and impact of the dwarves into account. Lest we forget, in some DAO epilogues there was a Circle built in Orzammar! I think this has largely gone forgotten, but this is surely impactful too. The Chantry considers an Exalted March on this Circle, after all! That is pretty important to the Chantry/Circle war.

And personally, I just enjoy the dwarves for themselves, beyond even their narrative importance. When I play a fantasy game I don't want to be a human. I'm a powerless human every day. I would much rather be a strong, decisive dwarven warrior. Or an elf, or qunari, etc. Give me races back, especially dwarves, BioWare!

#52
TheShadowWolf911

TheShadowWolf911
  • Members
  • 1 133 messages

jmd4 wrote...

Let me make my bias clear immediately: I love dwarves and would love to see more of them in DA, both as playable characters, companions, and love interests (I haven't given up hope on a dwarven LI). DAO and the dwarven origin stories (especially Aeducan, as you might have guessed from my avatar and signature) swept me away in the mystery, power, and tragedy of the dwarves. Unlike dwarves in other franchises in my opinion, such as Warhammer or Dragonlance, the dwarves of DA have depth, dignity, and even beauty. They aren't jokes and are in fact major players in the world in spite of their isolation. I believe dwarves have a huge impact on the world of Thedas, and a big role to play, as well as narrative ideas yet to play out.

Dwarves mine and control the lyrium flow in Thedas, they are arguably the most talented engineers and crafters of all the races, and they also are the most connected to the darkspawn threat. Certainly their production of lyrium is critical--absolutely critical--to the future of mages and templars in DA and thus to the presumed story of DA3.

Beyond that, we have the city of Kal Sharok and all its wonders (and terrors, no doubt) to explore. That could be an entire game in and of itself. And the dwarves patrol and protect the Deep Roads, the most expedient (at least at one time) way to cross from one end of Thedas to the other. Thedas owes the dwarves a great debt, as do the other races (even elves, given that dwarves gave them sanctuary in Cadash Thaig). Even Tevinter owes them a debt for helping to form the Imperium.

I would say that you cannot have a game in Thedas that does not, in some way, take the presence and impact of the dwarves into account. Lest we forget, in some DAO epilogues there was a Circle built in Orzammar! I think this has largely gone forgotten, but this is surely impactful too. The Chantry considers an Exalted March on this Circle, after all! That is pretty important to the Chantry/Circle war.

And personally, I just enjoy the dwarves for themselves, beyond even their narrative importance. When I play a fantasy game I don't want to be a human. I'm a powerless human every day. I would much rather be a strong, decisive dwarven warrior. Or an elf, or qunari, etc. Give me races back, especially dwarves, BioWare!


this

and you raise a fair point, Dwarves can't really be forgotton about, they are a little too important, intertwined with all that is going on.

#53
Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*

Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*
  • Guests
The dwarves in Orzammar do not accept interference from outsiders. If you did the quest in DAO there was a church dedicated to Andraste, but only for a short time. If you sided with Harrimont the isolation would be even bigger but if you sided with Behlen the dwarves were more open in trade with topsiders.

And then there is Kal Sharok. We know little of the dwarves that live there. We only know that they had to do some questionable things in order to survive the blight. Due to that blight Orzammar cut of Kal Sharok and for a long time Orzammar thought the thaig no longer existed. We know Kal Sharok holds a grudge against Orzammar for letting them down. Kal Sharok used to be the capital when the dwarves where at their pique. This means that it has to be a big city.

There is reference that there is trade going on from Kal Sharok with the surface. But we do not know how the dwarves their have developed themselves compared to the dwarves in Orzammar. Maybe Sandal is originally from there. And he certainly isn't an ordinary dwarve.

This could give some interesting developments in DA3. 

#54
TheShadowWolf911

TheShadowWolf911
  • Members
  • 1 133 messages
yes it would

#55
Uthenera

Uthenera
  • Members
  • 120 messages
http://social.biowar...index/8120102/2 here they are saying that Sandal is came from house Aeducan and his mother was an elf or human, is it true or just some kind of insult i don't know, but seems interesting, but is it even possible?

Modifié par Uthenera, 24 mars 2012 - 07:05 .


#56
TheShadowWolf911

TheShadowWolf911
  • Members
  • 1 133 messages

Uthenera wrote...

http://social.biowar...index/8120102/2 here they are saying that Sandal is came from house Aeducan and his mother was an elf or human, is it true or just some kind of insult i don't know, but seems interesting, but is it even possible?


another person claimed that Flemmeth was his mother.....

#57
Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*

Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*
  • Guests
I guess that would be speculation. We only know for sure that Sandal was found in the deep roads by Bodahn and that he was all by himself. Sandal being Sandal wasn't capable to know or tell where he came from I think. But could be wrong there of course.

#58
TheShadowWolf911

TheShadowWolf911
  • Members
  • 1 133 messages

sjpelkessjpeler wrote...

I guess that would be speculation. We only know for sure that Sandal was found in the deep roads by Bodahn and that he was all by himself. Sandal being Sandal wasn't capable to know or tell where he came from I think. But could be wrong there of course.


yes but......


www.youtube.com/watch

why would a scary lady stand next to Sandal's bed?

#59
ev76

ev76
  • Members
  • 1 913 messages
It would be interesting to find out more of sandals history in DA 3. I want to know more about Sandal, the last two games it seems like Bodhan might not have told us everything about sandal, he is very over protective.

#60
Uthenera

Uthenera
  • Members
  • 120 messages

TheShadowWolf911 wrote...

Uthenera wrote...

http://social.biowar...index/8120102/2 here they are saying that Sandal is came from house Aeducan and his mother was an elf or human, is it true or just some kind of insult i don't know, but seems interesting, but is it even possible?


another person claimed that Flemmeth was his mother.....


What we know about Flemeth she can be anything. Posted Image

Sandal also an intriguing mysterious character, Some says that he is the maker.  Don't know about much him than, that he blow up things and likes salamanders and enchantments. We don't even know his age, how long was he in the Deep Roads etc. The Unnamed Child Paragon also intrigues me, maybe it's too far off to suspect that they are related in someway? 

#61
Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*

Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*
  • Guests

TheShadowWolf911 wrote...

sjpelkessjpeler wrote...

I guess that would be speculation. We only know for sure that Sandal was found in the deep roads by Bodahn and that he was all by himself. Sandal being Sandal wasn't capable to know or tell where he came from I think. But could be wrong there of course.


yes but......


www.youtube.com/watch

why would a scary lady stand next to Sandal's bed?


That's one of the things that makes the mystery surrounding Sandal even bigger. I started a poll about him to gather opinions. He's special and intriging and I really hope he gets a bigger role in DA3.

Let's just think about the possibility that he came from Kal Sharok. Then this could mean that the dwarves there developped differently and that they can use magic too.
I would really like to see some magic using dwarves. Could tip the scale in a completely different direction.Posted Image

#62
TheShadowWolf911

TheShadowWolf911
  • Members
  • 1 133 messages

sjpelkessjpeler wrote...

TheShadowWolf911 wrote...

sjpelkessjpeler wrote...

I guess that would be speculation. We only know for sure that Sandal was found in the deep roads by Bodahn and that he was all by himself. Sandal being Sandal wasn't capable to know or tell where he came from I think. But could be wrong there of course.


yes but......


www.youtube.com/watch

why would a scary lady stand next to Sandal's bed?


That's one of the things that makes the mystery surrounding Sandal even bigger. I started a poll about him to gather opinions. He's special and intriging and I really hope he gets a bigger role in DA3.

Let's just think about the possibility that he came from Kal Sharok. Then this could mean that the dwarves there developped differently and that they can use magic too.
I would really like to see some magic using dwarves. Could tip the scale in a completely different direction.Posted Image


i like this thought.

i'd love to see the Chantry's reaction to Dwarf Magi, whom the dwarves probably wouldn't hand over.

#63
Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*

Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*
  • Guests

ev76 wrote...

It would be interesting to find out more of sandals history in DA 3. I want to know more about Sandal, the last two games it seems like Bodhan might not have told us everything about sandal, he is very over protective.


I thought about that one. Every time Sandal says something that is out of his character Bodahn kinda shuts him up. He went with him to the circle though to have him "tested". He states that the circle said he was a savant (not a mage) but also mentiones that "they were giving him the eye" and they went away.

#64
ev76

ev76
  • Members
  • 1 913 messages
Yeah, I keep thinking sandal knows when to turn it on and when to turn off his abilities. I think he only uses them when people need his services or help, not to show off. I like sandal coming fom Kal Sharok. That would certainly add to the lore of Kal Sharok and give it significantly importance.
I still think the lyrium found in DA2 will also play a significant role or expanded on.

#65
ev76

ev76
  • Members
  • 1 913 messages
And to what TheShadowWolf911 said about the chantry finding out about dwarves using magic. I can see an exalted march heading into the thaigs. Especially if the dwarfs control all if not most of the lyrium trade.

#66
Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*

Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*
  • Guests

ev76 wrote...

Yeah, I keep thinking sandal knows when to turn it on and when to turn off his abilities. I think he only uses them when people need his services or help, not to show off. I like sandal coming fom Kal Sharok. That would certainly add to the lore of Kal Sharok and give it significantly importance.
I still think the lyrium found in DA2 will also play a significant role or expanded on.


I think you're referring to the idol here. DarkAmaranth and I shared our thoughts on that matter on mail not on the forum. The conclusion at the end was that the idol was enchanted lyrium. The reason why it was in the ancient thaig could be that the idol was used as the portal for the Tevinter mages to enter the fade physically to enter the golden city. That could also explain the colour red (blood magic) because lyrium normally is blue.

#67
ev76

ev76
  • Members
  • 1 913 messages
Oh yeah, my mistake. :) Keep forgetting it was an idol.

#68
Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*

Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*
  • Guests

ev76 wrote...

Oh yeah, my mistake. :) Keep forgetting it was an idol.


We are both right its an idol made out of pure lyrium Posted Image.

#69
jmd4

jmd4
  • Members
  • 44 messages
Regarding Sandal, if his mother was an elf or a human, as DA2 seems to suggest, that would be huge! We have not yet seen/heard anything about half-dwarves and it would, I would think, drive the dwarves up the wall, the notion of mixing their pure blood with "cloudheads." I think there is a Dace noblewoman who runs off with an elf mentioned in the game, but that is the only instance of this I can think of. Also, if Sandal's father was an Aeducan and Bhelen sat the throne and knew of his existence, think what would happen! Bhelen would stop at nothing to find Sandal, I think, as another dangerous heir to the throne. That would be some grist for the story mill.

I would like to think Sandal has a connection to Kal Sharok too, though. The more connections to the thaig the better, in hopes of bringing it into a future storyline.

#70
Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*

Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*
  • Guests

Uthenera wrote...

TheShadowWolf911 wrote...

Uthenera wrote...

http://social.biowar...index/8120102/2 here they are saying that Sandal is came from house Aeducan and his mother was an elf or human, is it true or just some kind of insult i don't know, but seems interesting, but is it even possible?


another person claimed that Flemmeth was his mother.....


What we know about Flemeth she can be anything. Posted Image

Sandal also an intriguing mysterious character, Some says that he is the maker.  Don't know about much him than, that he blow up things and likes salamanders and enchantments. We don't even know his age, how long was he in the Deep Roads etc. The Unnamed Child Paragon also intrigues me, maybe it's too far off to suspect that they are related in someway? 


Could you tell me about the Unnamed Child Paragon? Hear this for the first time. Makes me curious.Posted Image

#71
TheShadowWolf911

TheShadowWolf911
  • Members
  • 1 133 messages

ev76 wrote...

And to what TheShadowWolf911 said about the chantry finding out about dwarves using magic. I can see an exalted march heading into the thaigs. Especially if the dwarfs control all if not most of the lyrium trade.


and thus we have a conflict that could take up a 'act' or 'chapter' in the next game.

#72
Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*

Guest_sjpelkessjpeler_*
  • Guests

TheShadowWolf911 wrote...

ev76 wrote...

And to what TheShadowWolf911 said about the chantry finding out about dwarves using magic. I can see an exalted march heading into the thaigs. Especially if the dwarfs control all if not most of the lyrium trade.


and thus we have a conflict that could take up a 'act' or 'chapter' in the next game.


This would be an exalted march to Kal Sharok then if my thoughts about the direction the dwarves went there is true.

#73
Zanallen

Zanallen
  • Members
  • 4 425 messages
Obviously the dwarves are all going to be devoured by blighted gorillas. The gorillas will then go on to sacrifice themselves to a brood mother.

#74
ev76

ev76
  • Members
  • 1 913 messages
Interesting indeed, if the March went to Kal Sharok, how do you think Orzommar will react? Will the mages step in? Definitely deserving a whole act to deal with that. As for jmd4 if sandal was part of the Aeducan family and Behlen went after him using the carta what reaction do you think the Orlesians will have?

#75
Uthenera

Uthenera
  • Members
  • 120 messages

sjpelkessjpeler wrote...

[Could you tell me about the Unnamed Child Paragon? Hear this for the first time. Makes me curious.Posted Image

The Unnamed Child Paragon has a memorial at Caridin's Cross, but it's badly damaged by darkspawns, so the name, the gender, of the child, or the deeds, for which s/he became a paragon is illegible.

Maybe because there's not much knowledge about the Child, became a good source of speculation to me,
Why would they name a child a paragon? 
A small amount of lyrium in his blood made that mechant in Orzammar act strangely, he said something about working the lyrium in himself. So what if an accident with a bigger dose of lyrium made it possible for the Child, to perform miraculous deeds. and what if it has some effect on the kid's ageing or metabolism, so this Paragon could even be Sandal. On the other hand why would If Sandal is the Unnamed Child Paragon why would he suddenly started to grow up normally, when he became into the care of Bodhan, so this connection, thought up by me seems to be more than far fetched. It's probably a clever trick by the writers to make my thoughts head for this way.Posted Image Even so i still see some potential in the untold story of the Unnamed Child Paragon for the future, 

Modifié par Uthenera, 25 mars 2012 - 06:32 .