Aller au contenu

Photo

Romance scene Tali v. Liara v. Jack v. Traynor talk about not even!


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
197 réponses à ce sujet

#151
Jomino

Jomino
  • Members
  • 29 messages

Shallyah wrote...

I actually think it would be beautiful if Tali+Shepard romantic affair ended up with them adopting Jona since they possibly can't have a child themselves (or whatever was the name of the quarian little girl that loses her mom in ME2 and her dad in ME3).

Though then we might as well rename the game "The Sims Effect"...


Wait, what quarian child, I don't recall seeing that??

#152
joshko

joshko
  • Members
  • 502 messages

Skyblade012 wrote...

CDHarrisUSF wrote...

Shallyah wrote...

Tali is also about the only LI that really cares for Shepard ...

Bulls#!t. Liara goes through hell for Shepard when everyone else left him to rot. She tracks down his dead body, steals it from the Blue Suns before they can deliver it to the Collectors, then takes it to Miranda so the Lazarus Project can bring him back to life. If you question her on Ilium, she feels guilty about turning you over to Cerberus and admits that she did it all because she just couldn't stand to lose you.

As for not being a shallow one night stand, Liara makes you promise in LotSB that you'll always come back alive before continuing the relationship. They even talk about marriage, lots of little blue children, and old age. The gifts she gives Shepard and their conversations are also deep and thoughtful. For me, all of that pales in comparison to the thing that really tips the scale in her favor: as part of being an asari, she is the only love interest that can ever truly understand Shepard. With the burden on his shoulders, that is very important. They can become one with each other during the joining... sharing emotions, thoughts and memories. This is where the only thing I didn't like about the Tali romance (at least in ME2) comes in: the way Tali describes her feelings makes it sound like hero worship. Liara feels like she treats you as an equal. Also, sure, Tali is a nerd (tech expert)... but so is Liara (archaeologist).

Of course, it doesn't hurt that the sex is great either. Liara would have several things going for her in that regard. 1) Asari are some of the most (if not the most) powerful biotics. I imagine the two of them (my Shepard is also a strong biotic) could find some uses for that. 2) Asari can join their nervous systems together and are able to consciously control nerve stimulation. 3) Asari are just naturally comfortable and confident with expressing their sexuality. Contrary to rumors and wishful thinking, this does not mean that they are more promiscuous.

You know what they say: "Once you go blue, nothing else will do."


To expand a bit.  This is my opinion only, and others are of course welcome to their own, but I'll try to explain as best I can.

I believe that Liara is the only perfect match for Shepard.

Tali's romance is too much of a case of hero worship.  Tali can't ever see Shepard failing.  Tali can't ever conceive or believe Shepard being wrong, or being weak.  Liara can.  Liara is always, always there, whenever Shepard wavers, and not only knows what is eating at Shepard, and why, but knows what to bring up and how to talk things around to get Shepard back in the game.  Tali doesn't really think Shepard needs her.  It's as though Shepard is gracing Tali with the romance, rather than a relationship of equals.  As awesome as Tali is, she's just not right for Shepard.

Ashley is too guarded.  Ashley can't just trust Shepard.  While she would never have Tali's issue of seeing Shepard as someone above her, she still can't just take Shepard's word about what is going on.  Shepard has to work way too hard for her trust.  Relationships are built on trust, and Ashley just doesn't trust Shepard.  Too much has happened, they've been broken apart too much, and Ashley just isn't able to rebuild what was lost.

Liara is perfect.  She never questions Shepard's positions.  She knows that, whatever happens, Shepard will always be Shepard, will always hold Shepard's views and morals true, no matter what (which is why the ending is a betrayal to her as well, as Shepard backs down from her own morals and accepts those of the enemy).  She knows that if Shepard is working for Cerberus, it's for a dang good reason, one Shepard believes is absolutely necessary.  Yet she also knows that Shepard is not infallible.  She calls out Shepard for self-doubt, or for getting run down and depressed as things go to hell.  And Shepard calls her out as well, for her own self-doubt, or the times when she gets too distant from the universe.  The two anchor off each other.  Each gives the other the eternal port in the storm.  No matter where Shepard goes, Liara will always be there when Shepard needs her, and vice versa.  Be that fighting through a fleet of Reapers, or just needing a hand off the floor of the cabin.

She's the only one who understands fully both Shepard, and the threat they face.  She's the one who realizes the chance for failure, who plans against it, and plans to save as much as she can should everything fail.  She also is the only one who understands that they need not weather this storm.  That they can leave, fly away in peace, and let the galaxy die.  But that they won't.  That neither one would let that happen.  That they are there, bearing the brunt of the storm, by choice.  Liara and Shepard can both entertain the idea "why does the galaxy need me", but they both know the answer, without even having to vocalize it.

It is the only relationship with such a beautiful level of understanding.  I'm probably not expressing it well, but I truly believe there have been few relationships written, especially in the gaming media, with this brilliant level of open emotion and understanding between the partners.


This is because (I believe) Liara is (unfortuantly) tailored to being Shepards LI. Everyone else is for those who for some reason don't want Liara as an LI, but are not canon as far a Bioware is concerned (unfortuanly).

#153
DemonsSouls

DemonsSouls
  • Members
  • 173 messages
 How does never questioning Shepard make Liara perfect for him? That's not a good thing in my opinion. Tali wouldn't stand by and let Shepard kill her people just because she knows "Shepard will always be Shepard".

I'm not saying Liara is a bad romance, but that's just terrible reasoning in my opinion. None of the romances are any less valid than another. That's the point of the game (at least until the ending). You can sit here and bicker about why you think _____ is best for Shepard but that's pointless. Because you know what? It's true... _____ is best for Shepard. Your  Shepard.

Modifié par DemonsSouls, 25 mars 2012 - 07:28 .


#154
ZweiImpulse

ZweiImpulse
  • Members
  • 79 messages
But i felt Liara was way too cold throught the whole game if you romanced her. Its all 'Hello Shepard' 'Hello Shepard' 'Hello Shepard'
Wheres the love LIARA!!??

#155
CDHarrisUSF

CDHarrisUSF
  • Members
  • 414 messages
I decided to put all of the banners in their own thread to avoid cluttering this one.

It's just Liara, Tali, Garrus, Miranda and Jack so far...

#156
sistersafetypin

sistersafetypin
  • Members
  • 2 413 messages

CDHarrisUSF wrote...

I decided to put all of the banners in their own thread to avoid cluttering this one.

It's just Liara, Tali, Garrus, Miranda and Jack so far...


Awesome thanks, because I definitely wasn't using it without the OK ^_^

Modifié par sistersafetypin, 25 mars 2012 - 08:03 .


#157
mauro2222

mauro2222
  • Members
  • 4 236 messages

Skyblade012 wrote...

To expand a bit.  This is my opinion only, and others are of course welcome to their own, but I'll try to explain as best I can.

I believe that Liara is the only perfect match for Shepard.

Tali's romance is too much of a case of hero worship.  Tali can't ever see Shepard failing.  Tali can't ever conceive or believe Shepard being wrong, or being weak.  Liara can.  Liara is always, always there, whenever Shepard wavers, and not only knows what is eating at Shepard, and why, but knows what to bring up and how to talk things around to get Shepard back in the game.  Tali doesn't really think Shepard needs her.  It's as though Shepard is gracing Tali with the romance, rather than a relationship of equals.  As awesome as Tali is, she's just not right for Shepard.

Ashley is too guarded.  Ashley can't just trust Shepard.  While she would never have Tali's issue of seeing Shepard as someone above her, she still can't just take Shepard's word about what is going on.  Shepard has to work way too hard for her trust.  Relationships are built on trust, and Ashley just doesn't trust Shepard.  Too much has happened, they've been broken apart too much, and Ashley just isn't able to rebuild what was lost.

Liara is perfect.  She never questions Shepard's positions.  She knows that, whatever happens, Shepard will always be Shepard, will always hold Shepard's views and morals true, no matter what (which is why the ending is a betrayal to her as well, as Shepard backs down from her own morals and accepts those of the enemy).  She knows that if Shepard is working for Cerberus, it's for a dang good reason, one Shepard believes is absolutely necessary.  Yet she also knows that Shepard is not infallible.  She calls out Shepard for self-doubt, or for getting run down and depressed as things go to hell.  And Shepard calls her out as well, for her own self-doubt, or the times when she gets too distant from the universe.  The two anchor off each other.  Each gives the other the eternal port in the storm.  No matter where Shepard goes, Liara will always be there when Shepard needs her, and vice versa.  Be that fighting through a fleet of Reapers, or just needing a hand off the floor of the cabin.

She's the only one who understands fully both Shepard, and the threat they face.  She's the one who realizes the chance for failure, who plans against it, and plans to save as much as she can should everything fail.  She also is the only one who understands that they need not weather this storm.  That they can leave, fly away in peace, and let the galaxy die.  But that they won't.  That neither one would let that happen.  That they are there, bearing the brunt of the storm, by choice.  Liara and Shepard can both entertain the idea "why does the galaxy need me", but they both know the answer, without even having to vocalize it.

It is the only relationship with such a beautiful level of understanding.  I'm probably not expressing it well, but I truly believe there have been few relationships written, especially in the gaming media, with this brilliant level of open emotion and understanding between the partners.


Haha, yeah right ... :blush:

So perfect little miss Shadow Broker =]

Come on! <_<

#158
DemonsSouls

DemonsSouls
  • Members
  • 173 messages

CDHarrisUSF wrote...

I decided to put all of the banners in their own thread to avoid cluttering this one.

It's just Liara, Tali, Garrus, Miranda and Jack so far...


Awesome job man! No surprise coming from someone with an amazing avatar like that one.

#159
sistersafetypin

sistersafetypin
  • Members
  • 2 413 messages

mauro2222 wrote...

Skyblade012 wrote...

snip - even though I agree


Haha, yeah right ... :blush:

So perfect little miss Shadow Broker =]

Come on! <_<


I don't understand! What's not to love! :huh:

#160
Eterna

Eterna
  • Members
  • 7 417 messages
I do the romances in this game for the emotional impact and depth, not the sex scenes. But that's just me, I didn't see a Garrus sex scene but his romance is still my favorite.

Modifié par Eterna5, 25 mars 2012 - 08:11 .


#161
daguest

daguest
  • Members
  • 670 messages

adam32867 wrote...

i dont know, the 2sec dance with jack was pretty steamy

FYI, the dance is also available if not romanced. Got it on both my femshep and maleshep. Both romancing someone else.

#162
gudman

gudman
  • Members
  • 110 messages

ZweiImpulse wrote...

But i felt Liara was way too cold throught the whole game if you romanced her. Its all 'Hello Shepard' 'Hello Shepard' 'Hello Shepard'
Wheres the love LIARA!!??

Heh. What's fun is that people treat LI as if they all were human. Liara is not a human, and she probably sees relationship as something... diffirent. Also, she's older than Shepard (by actual age I mean), and most of her life she were alone not interested in others. It's perfectly understanable that she wants to spend more time alone. Diffirences between species and all that. 

#163
inb4lock

inb4lock
  • Members
  • 256 messages
I am romancing Liara i most of my games (ME1, 2 & 3) But i have to admit i disapionted with the other romances.

And whats with the permanent underwear? I thought the age restriction was 18?...

#164
Shallyah

Shallyah
  • Members
  • 1 357 messages
I agree with other posters. I believe Liara is what the writers intend us to hit. Perhaps Ash and Kaidan too, if that was your initial choice. All other romances were added at later point, some of them due to popular request and some may be a little lacking.

Though I'll say again, I feel fulfilled with Tali, and being loyal to her certainly paid off. I just wish I could see Tali's flashback when the game ends instead of Liara. Liara is nothing to my Shepard but a friend of many. A good friend, but still a friend with no trascendental meaning to his life.

Modifié par Shallyah, 25 mars 2012 - 11:21 .


#165
Skyblade012

Skyblade012
  • Members
  • 1 336 messages

mauro2222 wrote...

Skyblade012 wrote...

To expand a bit.  This is my opinion only, and others are of course welcome to their own, but I'll try to explain as best I can.

I believe that Liara is the only perfect match for Shepard.

Tali's romance is too much of a case of hero worship.  Tali can't ever see Shepard failing.  Tali can't ever conceive or believe Shepard being wrong, or being weak.  Liara can.  Liara is always, always there, whenever Shepard wavers, and not only knows what is eating at Shepard, and why, but knows what to bring up and how to talk things around to get Shepard back in the game.  Tali doesn't really think Shepard needs her.  It's as though Shepard is gracing Tali with the romance, rather than a relationship of equals.  As awesome as Tali is, she's just not right for Shepard.

Ashley is too guarded.  Ashley can't just trust Shepard.  While she would never have Tali's issue of seeing Shepard as someone above her, she still can't just take Shepard's word about what is going on.  Shepard has to work way too hard for her trust.  Relationships are built on trust, and Ashley just doesn't trust Shepard.  Too much has happened, they've been broken apart too much, and Ashley just isn't able to rebuild what was lost.

Liara is perfect.  She never questions Shepard's positions.  She knows that, whatever happens, Shepard will always be Shepard, will always hold Shepard's views and morals true, no matter what (which is why the ending is a betrayal to her as well, as Shepard backs down from her own morals and accepts those of the enemy).  She knows that if Shepard is working for Cerberus, it's for a dang good reason, one Shepard believes is absolutely necessary.  Yet she also knows that Shepard is not infallible.  She calls out Shepard for self-doubt, or for getting run down and depressed as things go to hell.  And Shepard calls her out as well, for her own self-doubt, or the times when she gets too distant from the universe.  The two anchor off each other.  Each gives the other the eternal port in the storm.  No matter where Shepard goes, Liara will always be there when Shepard needs her, and vice versa.  Be that fighting through a fleet of Reapers, or just needing a hand off the floor of the cabin.

She's the only one who understands fully both Shepard, and the threat they face.  She's the one who realizes the chance for failure, who plans against it, and plans to save as much as she can should everything fail.  She also is the only one who understands that they need not weather this storm.  That they can leave, fly away in peace, and let the galaxy die.  But that they won't.  That neither one would let that happen.  That they are there, bearing the brunt of the storm, by choice.  Liara and Shepard can both entertain the idea "why does the galaxy need me", but they both know the answer, without even having to vocalize it.

It is the only relationship with such a beautiful level of understanding.  I'm probably not expressing it well, but I truly believe there have been few relationships written, especially in the gaming media, with this brilliant level of open emotion and understanding between the partners.


Haha, yeah right ... :blush:

So perfect little miss Shadow Broker =]

Come on! <_<


I find her being the Shadow Broker is another advantage.  She's the only one who has a galactic role not defined by Shepard.

Ashley is always going to be known as the second human Spectre (weird, because I thought ME2 implied that there were already more human Spectres, but we'll go with it), and a member of Shepard's crew.  Always defined by Shepard, and in relation to Shepard.

Tali is Miss Tali'zorah vas Normandy.  Again, see the point?  She's a legend among her own people, yes, but to everyone else, she's just another member of Shepard's crew.

Liara is the Shadow Broker.  She's the only one with a position that can stand apart from Shepard.  She is more independent, on a more equal footing.  Again, it's the whole balance thing playing out.


Not that I am in any way unbiased.  As much as I love Tali's character, and voice, I've been a huge Liara fan since the first game, and I love the way the character has been developed throughout the three, but that is still the most honest appraisal I can give the romantic interests.

#166
Kronner

Kronner
  • Members
  • 6 249 messages
That's because Liara >>> Tali/Jack/Traynor.

I mean, asari are pretty much the best hookers in ME universe, right?

#167
shurryy

shurryy
  • Members
  • 556 messages
I agree... With the OP.

#168
Kenta Shuuichi

Kenta Shuuichi
  • Members
  • 72 messages
Please, do not start shipping wars here. As someone said before, everyone of us is a Shepard, with different tastes, and so each LI is perfect for each and everyone of us. Some like Liara, some Tali, some Eyecandyman... Saying one is SO MUCH BETTER would be trying to apply the same standards to every Shepard out there. Is shortsighted.

#169
JexyG

JexyG
  • Members
  • 71 messages
Jack was a ripoff. From what I hear, Tali was also a ripoff, but at least they were together... but yeah, it seemed to lean heavy on Liara. Shoot, even the end when I embrace eternity again... it's all about Liara? Shoot, shes just my friend, give me who I was with, Jack. Or anyone. I hope Ashley's is good. But yeah, this is very disappointing considering what you said about Traynor.

#170
mauro2222

mauro2222
  • Members
  • 4 236 messages

Skyblade012 wrote...

snip


I'm biased too, biased by the fact of Liara being everywhere, doing everything, and furthermore, being shoved down my throat "Romance me, romance me!"...

The forced friendship, the forced jobs, the plot armor...
And the romance... jesus! I hate you Mac Walters, there are 2 reasons to shoot you right now, or 5... :pinched:

Modifié par mauro2222, 25 mars 2012 - 06:38 .


#171
RvB SPARTAN038

RvB SPARTAN038
  • Members
  • 107 messages
For me, I'm kind of torn between Ashley and Tali. In ME1, Tali was a bit emotionless and didn't appeal to me. In ME2, her character was really flushed out and you got to see the emotion behind her and her characteristics. Ash got a total makeover that i prefer in ME3 and she is still the strong, independent character some of us have come to love. They are both great and I romanced both of them in everyone of my playthroughs and right now, im having a tough time deciding on just one.

But ya, go Team Tali.

#172
Taboo

Taboo
  • Members
  • 20 234 messages
There is a big difference between art and pornography.

GRANTS.

No, but seriously a cut to black is just pissing people off at this point.

#173
RvB SPARTAN038

RvB SPARTAN038
  • Members
  • 107 messages

Taboo-XX wrote...

There is a big difference between art and pornography.

GRANTS.

No, but seriously a cut to black is just pissing people off at this point.


Ya, it's about the emotion and to me, Bioware either needed to go all the way, or not do it at all, just make it implied. Its PG-13 material in a Rated M game.

#174
Mitra

Mitra
  • Members
  • 235 messages
Liara forever and ever!

#175
Paragon Auducan

Paragon Auducan
  • Members
  • 301 messages
Tali definately should have had her face shown, not just in the picture. That would have been perfect, same as we have now but show her face and the kiss.