218 réponses à ce sujet

[MrBurntToast]

Star Wars galaxy would hulk smash just about any other sci-fi fleet. Their engines don't find a new way to travel to avoid light speed complications, they just compensate and plow right on by. Weapons, shields, etc, much more powerful than even the Protheans.

[Warrior Craess]

mooney6023 wrote...

jarms48 wrote...

mooney6023 wrote...

Wave 8: The United Federation of Planets. I mean, are the Reapers that much worse than the Borg?

Star Trek? I don't see them faring as well as the Mass Effect Galaxy and the Borg medicore.

Well, the Borg cubes and spheres seemed to be on par with reapers in size.  But I have know idea what the stopping power of a phaser or photon torpedo is comparitively.

The real question is.  Could the Royal Manticorian Navy and Honor Harrington take them out in wave 9?

Yay someone else was thinking this.  I think with it's latest weaponry, that the RMN (royal manticoran navy) crushes the reapers.  The reapers Energy weapons would be practically useless against the  Gravity fields of the Honorverse ships.  Which isn't counting that unholy long stand of range that the RMN has with their new  Missiles (which deliver Laser warhears using gravity lences to focus Nuclear explosions into lasers. )

Yeah the RMN would barely pause, and they would tell jokes about the lack of reaper discipline and their inability to fight in a tight formation. 

[Warrior Craess]

Iwillbeback wrote...

Mixxer5 wrote...

Iwillbeback wrote...

101ezylonhxeT wrote...

Anything in star wars will kill a reaper with absolute ease.

Nothing can damage a Sovereign class Reaper without the Sovereign class reaper damaging itself.

In ME universe probably. But SW universe is far more advanced technologically. 

Doesn't matter only Sovereign class ships can kill themselves.
They would wreck millions of ships with ease.

this is incorrect. 3~4 ME drednaughts could destroy a reaper capital ship.  Please reader the codex for ME 3. 

[Rolling Flame]

The Covenant would easily destroy the Reapers, thanks to the fact that plasma is their weapon of choice. While powerful, the Reapers still use conventional kinectic barriers, which don't protect against extemes of heat.

Furthermore, Reaper capital ships are 2km in size, the length of a conventional Covenant crusier. Hell. a Covenant Supercarrier is 26km long.

[PsYGuY508]

Mass effect is pretty weak compared to most scifi, you can't deny that.

[Zix13]

40k... lolz. One Tau tank could kill a sovereign class reaper.

[JY Thriller]

Reapers using Indoctrination is the only thing that will make fighting them difficult in any universe. Thinking about SW universe if the reapers can Indoctrinate Jedi/Sith, that would probably be their first priority. Indoctrinating the Emperor and Vader would make a huge difference, that is if Force users aren't immune to it somehow.

[BearcatPrideEZF]

I think you guys HIGHLY underestimate the Spartans of UNSC. With their MJOLNIR Mark V armor, they can survive atmospheric entry. MC would do work.

[jarms48]

MrBurntToast wrote...

Star Wars galaxy would hulk smash just about any other sci-fi fleet. Their engines don't find a new way to travel to avoid light speed complications, they just compensate and plow right on by. Weapons, shields, etc, much more powerful than even the Protheans.

Need I say more?

[Arl Raylen]

jarms48 wrote...

MrBurntToast wrote...

Star Wars galaxy would hulk smash just about any other sci-fi fleet. Their engines don't find a new way to travel to avoid light speed complications, they just compensate and plow right on by. Weapons, shields, etc, much more powerful than even the Protheans.

*snip*

Need I say more?

Jesus...that's immense...

The SW Universe does have Cruisers that would rival that ship in size better than a standard 1.6km Star Destroyer (like that one Super Star Destroyer with a Death Star Laser on it), but that's still waaay bigger than the average Star Wars ship.


It's very ornate and oldfashioned looking though, interesting architecture. I wonder what they do with all that real estate on that ship. Do they have vehicles in the ship to get around faster?

Modifié par Arl Raylen, 26 mars 2012 - 01:40 .

[Legendaryred]

Halo Universe pwns the reapers, the covenant would completely obliterate the reapers.

[Oakenshield1]

Wave 1: We're screwed unless the planet works non-stop to make an Nuclear arsenal, hundreds of vertically positioned Large Hadron Colliders that fire large particles, and rail guns for flak cannons.

Wave 2: Stands a better chance than modern day.

Wave 3: The covies tech can could hold them off pretty well but eventually the Reapers will win.

Wave 4: Protheans are boned.

Wave 5: This is more even. Death Star >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Crucible

Wave 6: Everyone is just as screwed  as they were before joining forces.

[Oakenshield1]

I want to see Reapers vs the Borg.

[Faded-Myth]

You forgot Wave 7: Reapers VS. Velociraptors.

Space-faring Velociraptors with helmets and lasers shooting out of their toe claws.

[Slash1667]

Oakenshield1 wrote...

I want to see Reapers vs the Borg.

Borg for the win.

Look we just blew up one of the Cube shaped ships.

Continue firing!!!!

umm....err....no effect Harbinger.

And again, no kenetic weapons on the Borg ships. Nothing but good old energy beams......oh and for good measure, let's just tractor them so they can't run away or land and have to waste drones.

[Oakenshield1]

axecop.com/images/uploads/Wexter_03%282%29.png

[RevvyDrayen]

Reapers vs The Q Continuum.....

[Zkyire]

Iwillbeback wrote...

Nobody killed Sovereign class Reapers.
Capital ships aren't sovereign class reapers.

ME3 Final battle.

You see standard ships blowing the **** out of a "Sovereign-class" Reaper.

After only a few seconds of fire.

There is no way in hell that the Reapers could stand up to the Galactic Empire of Star Wars or the Imperium of 40k.

The Reapers are powerful, but only in the confines of Mass Effect.

Modifié par Zkyire, 26 mars 2012 - 02:18 .

[ReaperMAC]

I'd like to see how the Reapers fare against the Tyranids. You wanna harvest all organic beings huh? The Hive Mind (not even the Zerg compare) would like a word with you.

Heck, the lack of the Imperial Navy from the Imperium of Man on that list makes me sad.

[Zardoc]

ReaperMAC wrote...

I'd like to see how the Reapers fare against the Tyranids. You wanna harvest all organic beings huh? The Hive Mind (not even the Zerg compare) would like a word with you.

Heck, the lack of the Imperial Navy from the Imperium of Man on that list makes me sad.

I firmly believe if the Reapers were to encounter the Necrons they'd be best friends in no time.

[ReaperMAC]

Zardoc wrote...

ReaperMAC wrote...

I'd like to see how the Reapers fare against the Tyranids. You wanna harvest all organic beings huh? The Hive Mind (not even the Zerg compare) would like a word with you.

Heck, the lack of the Imperial Navy from the Imperium of Man on that list makes me sad.

I firmly believe if the Reapers were to encounter the Necrons they'd be best friends in no time.

Well if they don't have any souls to harvest, they would .

Another interesting comparison would be the Krogan (pre-genophage) vs. Orks. WAAAGH! 

[Marixus99.9]

Can't believe I read 7 pages of this .. also why are people bringing up numbers on the size of ships? .. Its the firepower and the durability that matters not the size .. Heck eve online's titans dwarf Reapers with the length of 13-18 km, but I don't know how they'll actually handle a Reaper's firepower and vice versa.

[Alamar2078]

IMHO it's not really fair to compare universes but if I had to I'd say the Reapers roll over everything up until the "Star Wars" galaxy where they are probably WTF PWNED based on comparative lore and power levels.

A fully prepared Prothean fleet + this cycle's fleet would be interesting. I still don't think they win a conventional war but they at least make the Reapers pause and have to make sure they don't get sloppy.

[Zkyire]

Marixus99.9 wrote...

Can't believe I read 7 pages of this .. also why are people bringing up numbers on the size of ships? .. Its the firepower and the durability that matters not the size .. Heck eve online's titans dwarf Reapers with the length of 13-18 km, but I don't know how they'll actually handle a Reaper's firepower and vice versa.

The point is that SW and 40k ships dwarf the Reapers.

In those universes, making such absolutely massive ships is common place.

In Mass Effect, making a Drednought is a hefty investment.

That alone sums up the technological and manufacturing cdifferences between each universe. A single battlegroup of Star Wars or 40k ships could steamroll their way through the entire Mass Effect universe combined. They're that powerful.

Modifié par Zkyire, 26 mars 2012 - 02:32 .

[Sangheili_1337]

The UNSC wouldn't have any problem with the Reapers. Their super MAC gun fires a 5000 ton slug at .4C. I believe their ship borne guns are 600 tons at a tenth the speed of light. Reapers only have kiloton level firepower. The Protheans should be moved up to wave 2 because in all probability they are not even on the UNSC's level. They lost to the Reapers after all.