463 réponses à ce sujet

[alx119]

Taboo-XX wrote...

DangerDavidson wrote...

sorentoft wrote...

It's a theory because it has no proof.

Harbinger death laser = dream trees + marauder shields?
Citadel architecture = cerberus + SB ship + citadel + collector base?
TIM suicide = Saren suicide?
5000 AMS + destroy = only possibility of survival?

Hallucination/Dream = Hallucination/Dream

Apophenia.

No need for speculation.

HEY! If we were promised something that we actually got, was LOTS OF SPECULATION FOR EVERYONE! So go speculate little rascal! 

[Grasich]

People, please go look up the scientific definition of a theory. You seem to be very mistaken as to what it means.

[Turran]

sorentoft wrote...

It's a theory because it has no proof.

No, it was a theory because no one could prove it wrong.

...

That does make sense. 

[DangerDavidson]

ed87 wrote...

This thread is one step away from shouting in the streets at people passing by. This indoctrination theory will always be a theory until the DLC comes out

BUT THEY'RE DOING DUMB THINGS LIKE MAKING CHARITIES TO CHANGE THE ENDING  :**( . 

*VIOLENT SOBBING...

[Jaze55]

HumingTurtle wrote...

Wtf are you saying boy?

Pretty sure he is saying the indoc theory is 100% factual and anyone that doesn't see that is blind and or dumb. 

[Elyiia]

So, you're okay with the fact that the game that was supposed to be the end, didn't have an ending?

[iorveth1271]

So far, there is no official proof. It's simply what it is - a theory put up by fans to make the ending make at least a bit more sense. (IMO makes a lot more sense but doesn't matter) And as long as it's just a bunch of thoughts and ideas to make the game look better while it's not proven true or false by Bioware themselves, it's a theory.

Therefore: Thread quite pointless. Sorry, mate.

[EmGo]

... what?

I read about the IT and saw a video on YT.
Still I don't think it's "not really a theory is it".

Just a lot of assumptions, like all about the ending. You like that theory, great, but let other people to have their own opinions. <_<

[Taboo]

DangerDavidson wrote...

sorentoft wrote...

Apophenia.

No need for speculation.

One of the most successful entertainment companies, responsible for KOTOR, BG, etc etc, suddenly acquiring the storytelling skills of a ten year old: highly likely.

Oh wait. No.

Do you really think that they would do all this without the expectation for backlash?

It's much more likely that they crapped out at the end and turned everything into a gigantic turd.

[garf]

I consider Indoc theory to be a nice idea well crafted by people who just couldn't accept the endings as given. It's sad that the endings are so bad they drive people to heights of creative fantasy usually reserved for the death of a US president, or the alleged one of a Beatle.

[blackangel209]

MassEffected555 wrote...

HumingTurtle wrote...

Wtf are you saying boy?

Pretty sure he is saying the indoc theory is 100% factual and anyone that doesn't see that is blind and or dumb. 

I feel like he's going in 8 different directions with his opinion in a single post. I thought he was calling IT believers crazy for a while.

[Ziggeh]

DangerDavidson wrote...

One of the most successful entertainment companies, responsible for KOTOR, BG, etc etc, suddenly acquiring the storytelling skills of a ten year old: highly likely.

Oh wait. No.

Even if IT were true, that storytelling is still in there.

[DangerDavidson]

Elyiia wrote...

So, you're okay with the fact that the game that was supposed to be the end, didn't have an ending?

Friend, the ending is coming.

[recentio]

I agree that IT isn't a theory anymore. No, it's reached TINHAT status as utter self-delusion at this point.

The only true conspiracy: The Weekes Leak. This is the real explanation, unsavory as it may be.

[Taboo]

garf wrote...

I consider Indoc theory to be a nice idea well crafted by people who just couldn't accept the endings as given. It's sad that the endings are so bad they drive people to heights of creative fantasy usually reserved for the death of a US president, or the alleged one of a Beatle.

Take this lesson to heart people. Conspiracy theories for the most part are all complete bollocks.

[ShepardTheHopeful]

No that's my answer to this entire thread NO. It was never a theory to begin with it's a poorly constructed Hypothesis a horrible cliche, and a freaking family guy joke. It's not real there's more holes in it than the real ending itself and I will gladly tear apart any speculation on it everything and I mean EVERYTHING void of maybe 2 scenes can be explained with logic. This isn't a theory at all I downgrade it to a hypothesis because that's what it is. I was cool with it all until this post.

The indoctrination hypothesis is a blight and you people who believe it are blights. You sir are a blight!

Edit: I realized i somewhat trolled the hell outta this that was not my way I think i've just been in to many Indoctrination hypothesis forums and my headache got the better of me. I am not calling fans of the theory stupid, useless, or wrong as we have no right answer. I simply see that you're all just blights. Also Space magic! 

Modifié par ShepardTheHopeful, 25 mars 2012 - 08:37 .

[blackangel209]

Taboo-XX wrote...

garf wrote...

I consider Indoc theory to be a nice idea well crafted by people who just couldn't accept the endings as given. It's sad that the endings are so bad they drive people to heights of creative fantasy usually reserved for the death of a US president, or the alleged one of a Beatle.

Take this lesson to heart people. Conspiracy theories for the most part are all complete bollocks.

That's what they want you to think!

[nomoredruggs]

sorentoft wrote...

It's a theory because it has no proof.

Exactly.

Also, we're expecting an announcement about what they are going to do in April, not dlc.

[spz123]

Theres some real pointers showing that this could be true. Meanwhile theres a 60 page thread of people thinking "Mass Shift" might be real just on the say so of an anoynomous post on the internet.

But we'll know more in April.

[DangerDavidson]

recentio wrote...

I agree that IT isn't a theory anymore. No, it's reached TINHAT status as utter self-delusion at this point.

The only true conspiracy: The Weekes Leak. This is the real explanation, unsavory as it may be.

OOH the "Weekes Leak" sounds intriguing!!!! : ) Link ?   

[UrgentArchengel]

Can't we all just wait till PAX! Damn.

[Misterdde45000]

@OP " the ending DLC patch that is coming in April is already/mostly complete "

Sources ? Anything ? Then consider it wrong until they have actually said YES officially. They merely declare they would adding closure/explenation. Not a DLC ending.

[zephyr2025]

Can you prove Shepherd wasn't in purgatory? Can you prove you're not dreaming right now? Can you prove we're not in the Matrix? Can you prove God exists?

having a theory about whether something is a dream is easy to make because you can literally apply it to anything.

[ZiegenkonigIII]

DangerDavidson wrote...

ed87 wrote...

This thread is one step away from shouting in the streets at people passing by. This indoctrination theory will always be a theory until the DLC comes out

BUT THEY'RE DOING DUMB THINGS LIKE MAKING CHARITIES TO CHANGE THE ENDING  :**( . 

*VIOLENT SOBBING...

What do you mean by this?

[Baronesa]

A question to the OP.

The Indoctrination HYPOTHESIS... how would you falsify it?