214 réponses à ce sujet

[AwesomeDudex64]

I like Hale better, deal with it.

[Zkyire]

ericjdev wrote...

Jennifer Hale is perfect, she is the Goddess incarnate, anything she says or does is fine with me.

Not sure if joke or just creepy.

[demin8891]

I liked both Sheps, though I think Hale's was more consistent. It was superb throughout the whole series, whereas, to me, it seems Meer didn't really do an amazing job until 2.

[Avalon Aurora]

I generally prefer femshep, but there is one line where broshep has her beat hands down.

"...big stupid jellyfish..."

He sounded so much funnier there.

[FrozenDreamfall]

I find Meer to be incredibly dull and cardboard like.He may be very talented but I didn't feel the passion and power of Shep's voice while playing with him like I did the fem Shep's.I honestly preferred him in the 2nd and 3rd also,in the 1st I hated it,couldn't feel a damn thing.

[jimbo32]

It's interesting that most people who prefer Meer focus on their dislike of Hale's voice rather than her acting ability. Or that's how it seems.

To get a real nice contrast, watch Thane's death scene as done by each of them (links below). With Hale, the scene is very powerful and emotional. Meer's delivery is completely flat, and completely kills the scene imo. The difference is huge and it all comes down to acting ability.

Not that I think Meer is bad. He's pretty good at some things - giving orders, yelling, some of the banter with companions. I just don't think he has Jennifer Hale's acting range.

Meer
Hale

[P3G4SU5]

Evil_medved wrote...

KenbroSlice wrote...

She's trying way too hard to sound 'badass', and adding a sort of raspyness to the end of literally almost every line.

Yeah, she does that since ME2.

I like her and i let her finish, but Meer is still best Shepard out there.

Same thoughts here, Meer might not be perfect but he does pretty good without sounding irritating.

[Shepard VI]

SiberETP wrote...

IndoctrinatedSpectre wrote...

Meer.
Hale.

Yeah, it isn't even close who's better. Sorry Femshep fans...

In fact, Hale's delivery of the best line in the game is absolutely horrible.

Yeah, actually both those deliveries suck, probably because that's a goofy line. It was fine in 1, buti ts inclusion here just felt like forced fanservice.

Meer's delivery was perfect. Hilarious even. Easily the best part of the game for me.

Forced fanservice? After the ending(s)? Think you might be giving BioWare too much credit...

Modifié par IndoctrinatedSpectre, 28 mars 2012 - 12:25 .

[The Spamming Troll]

in ME1 i really thought shepards voice was really monotone, but it fit for me because i wasnt looking for gruff mcgee.

ME2, i dont care about.

ME3 meer was awesome. idk if it was just the fact that its been his voice from the start but the whole thing really immersed me alot. i dont remember thinking even once about him being monotone or saying comic book ME2-style phrases. it was really perfect for me.

also wanted to say i dont prefer hales voice at all. shes the female version of marcus fenix. i played one female ME1 playthough, solely becasue so many people love hale. i just dont think its worth it.

Modifié par The Spamming Troll, 28 mars 2012 - 12:35 .

[av196vad]

jreezy wrote...

av196vad wrote...

Meer voices maleShep, Volus, Vorcha, and Hanar.

Hale only voices femShep.

Meer Wins

He doesn't voice all the Volus.

Meer still wins.

[Axolotl Shepard]

I started with a BroShep and his voice is great. Like you said, it's got a natural sound to it. On the other hand, FemShep has better delivery and more emotion, and I honestly thought she did a better job during my ME2 run. Haven't started a FemShep ME3 run yet, but am definitely going to.

[ibage]

I like Hale a tad bit more than Meer. However, playing as FemShep will never net you a romance arc with Tali so Meer wins.

In all seriousness, I like them both. But like I said above, I like Hale just a little more.

[Khajiit Jzargo]

FemShep over exaggerates lines and shes to old to be voice acting Shep IMO

[AutomaticDuck]

I actually think they deliver their own take on shepard with enough difference and character that playing both is equally satisfying.

[NegativelyChrgd]

I prefer the male Shepard voice.

[tjc2]

I prefer Hale so much I wish I could overlay her voice on my Male Sheps

[evermandibles]

Love both. I only played as Male Shep b/c, after a while, I had completely forgotten I could even be a FemShep all the way until ME2 started up.

Then I went back, made my lesbian fem shep, and I loved it.

I think I am a lesbian born in a man's body.

[Torrible]

Prefer Meer. A personal preference, that is all.

[Zepheera]

Can't we all just agree that Marauder Shields had the best voice acting in the entire trilogy?

[Chernaya]

I can see where OP is coming from. I think it may be that a female VA who's voicing someone like Commander Shepard wants the character to sound like she's been through hell, tough, and even a bit masculine - so she's trying to fit a role and perhaps masking and changing her voice a bit. Meer can afford to be more natural with his voice, it's already low and the monotone just gives it a feeling like he sounds more professional in his role as Commander. I like both VA's, but I still do prefer Hale's - I just love the emotion. I can tell she's acting with her voice, but it doesn't bother me.

[zingro]

GOOD THREAD!!

Hale is the best! You can all shut up now.

kthxbye

[ibage]

Zepheera wrote...

Can't we all just agree that Marauder Shields had the best voice acting in the entire trilogy?

Best boss fight ever!

[Moosasarous]

RACISM. SEXISM. SPECIESISM. SCHISM.

[AnsinJung]

Panicomatic wrote...

CRISIS1717 wrote...

I also remember that Mark Meer voiced a lot of the Volus as well. Amazing talent right there.

And the vorcha too.

That's what surprises me.  He's good at those roles and sounds like he's reading the script when playing Shepard.  He could be reading Dr. Seuss sometimes.  "See Tad run."  Meer has always seemed reluctant in his role as Shepard, whereas Hale may go over the edge occasionally, but I still prefer her by far. 

I haven't gotten far yet on my 3rd playthrough as MaleShep (just finished Palaven), both because of the fantastic endings I know are coming, plus it's harder to get into MaleShep.

They both sounded a bit silly with the jellyfish line; I wish I was able to follow up Kasumi's thing in game but I never found where to go in spite of meeting her by the embassies.