311 réponses à ce sujet

[DeathScepter]

Rogue Unit wrote...

Miranda wins easily. A more fair fight would be Ashley vs. Jacob

Don't underestimate Jacob, there is a damn good reason that Miranda recurited him to stop the Batarians within ME:Galaxy.

[Sesshaku]

Miranda all the way "in"....(and out)

[cg8900]

Miranda would destroy ash, easily

[sonofalich]

Miranda no question.

[Lawbringer-SR2]

Miranda, of course. I wasn't aware anyone even liked Ashley.

Modifié par Lawbringer-SR2, 28 mars 2012 - 08:20 .

[erikage]

Miranda wins easily. Ashley annoyed me in the first game, took one scene in the 2nd game to be annoying, and no different in 3rd game. She's there for an easy lay.

[pprrff]

As far as i remember, Ashley is usually the toughest squad you can get. In ME1 putting her with Wrex on a team means I can sit in the corner and let the game beat itself. In ME3, I usually pick team based on what dialogue I want to hear, but if it's a really tough fight, then its usually Ashley/Vega or Ashley/Garrus.

Miranda was good at taking out defenses, but I usually play engineer so I don't her skill at all. Plus the fact that squad has no amno limit means once you get widow or the grenade launcher, there is not point to take someone who can't carry either of them.

Modifié par pprrff, 28 mars 2012 - 08:30 .

[Zeppex]

LOL @ the Ashley loses because she is annoying. Please come up with something better.

1, Miranda is genetically enhanced meaning she is smarter, more stam and probably physically stronger.
2. Ashley is soldier she was trained to survive and kill.

They both have their trump cards, if weapons were used I think Ashely wins everytime. But in hand to hand I think Miranda wins everytime.

[Purple People Eater]

Ashley and Miranda - ménage à trois. Nuff said.

Modifié par Purple People Eater, 28 mars 2012 - 08:29 .

[jumpingkaede]

Ashley gets all up on your grill about working with Cerberus to save humanity.

Miranda doesn't get all up on your grill about being Alliance or turning against Cerberus

Winner: Miranda.

Zeppex wrote...

LOL @ the Ashley loses because she is annoying. Please come up with something better.

1, Miranda is genetically enhanced meaning she is smarter, more stam and probably physically stronger.
2. Ashley is soldier she was trained to survive and kill.

They both have their trump cards, if weapons were used I think Ashely wins everytime. But in hand to hand I think Miranda wins everytime.

Ashley almost got punked by two Geth on Eden Prime. 

Pretty sure Miranda could've taken two Geth.  Plus as mentioned above, she's a must on Insanity.  Warp Warp Warp Squad damage!!

Also assault rifle only slightly better than a Locust.  Or Tempest with AI accuracy.  I'd probably give the edge to Ashley there though.  Mattock >

Modifié par jumpingkaede, 28 mars 2012 - 08:31 .

[MattFini]

If I can't choose Jack, who would obliterate them both, I'm going with Miranda.

[jumpingkaede]

I'm really hoping for character DLC similar to the ME2 loyalty missions. (After ending fix of course).

There was so much potential that was never realized.

[Rogue Unit]

MattFini wrote...

If I can't choose Jack, who would obliterate them both, I'm going with Miranda.

I saw how Jack would obliterate Miranda. You see how hard she tossed that chair in Miranda's direction? True badass that one.

Modifié par Rogue Unit, 28 mars 2012 - 08:37 .

[erikage]

Ashley lost to Dr. Eva.

Modifié par erikage, 28 mars 2012 - 08:39 .

[jumpingkaede]

Rogue Unit wrote...

MattFini wrote...

If I can't choose Jack, who would obliterate them both, I'm going with Miranda.

I saw how Jack would obliterate Miranda. You see how hard she tossed that chair in Miranda's direction? True badass that one.

That chair was moving slower than if Jack had thrown it without biotic power...

[Dendio1]

Miranda is better than ashley in almost every way. Shes smarter, has a bigger caboose, Trusts shepard from the jump, and is able to uncover the sanctuary plot, while ash is busy taking orders for udina and almost betraying shepard for arguably the second time.

[cbutz]

Yea there was alot of wasted potential. It would have been cool to see how the two interacted, kind of like a Fire meets Ice comparison.

[SNascimento]

jumpingkaede wrote...

Rogue Unit wrote...

MattFini wrote...

If I can't choose Jack, who would obliterate them both, I'm going with Miranda.

I saw how Jack would obliterate Miranda. You see how hard she tossed that chair in Miranda's direction? True badass that one.

That chair was moving slower than if Jack had thrown it without biotic power...

.
My impression was that Miranda slowed down the chair. 

Modifié par SNascimento, 28 mars 2012 - 08:40 .

[Rogue Unit]

I can crush an Ashley with my biotics or shoot its' head off at 100 yards. Take your pick.

[ahandsomeshark]

You know who would absolutely lose. Jenkins. That dude couldn't even take one shot from a geth drone. Everyone else in the game is taking shot gun blasts and he dies from a flesh wound.

[BatmanPWNS]

Tali would win.

[TomY90]

Rogue Unit wrote...

MattFini wrote...

If I can't choose Jack, who would obliterate them both, I'm going with Miranda.

I saw how Jack would obliterate Miranda. You see how hard she tossed that chair in Miranda's direction? True badass that one.

not forgetting that miranda put the chair to the ground with barely any effort instead of Jack putting so much more effort in to that poor chair.

on the actual topic at hand. I was gutted there was no remarks any shape or form when you bump into such characters whether that be Jack kissing you infront of everyone on Grissom adacemy ... nope nothing.

no comment from Ashley (my previous LI) about Miranda (my LI) on sanctuary etc.

all we get is a mention from the ME1 options about it but thats it.

I do think Bioware really missed an opportunity on that one.

[ahandsomeshark]

If miranda dlc ever gets released I'm using an Ashley/Miranda squad every chance I get. Just on the off-chance they might bicker.

[erikage]

Zeppex wrote...

LOL @ the Ashley loses because she is annoying. Please come up with something better.

1, Miranda is genetically enhanced meaning she is smarter, more stam and probably physically stronger.
2. Ashley is soldier she was trained to survive and kill.

They both have their trump cards, if weapons were used I think Ashely wins everytime. But in hand to hand I think Miranda wins everytime.

Ashley being annoying is a perfectly acceptable reason because OP mentions verbal fight as well. This isn't only about a physical fight. LOL @ not reading OP correctly. Deeerrrpp.