733 réponses à ce sujet

[Asuka Bianchini]

It deserves more attention, awesome video!

[Fazumar]

So so sosososososo Good!

I agree 110% with EVERYTHING said in this video.
Except for the Destroy ending... Change the collateral damage to Minnesota.

[MrFob]

It's a great video and it excellently sums up the major points of why the ending just doesn't work while also conveying how most fans feel about the series as a whole. Kudos.
If I have criticism, it is ironically about the ending of that vid. IMO it should have ended after he says that he doesn't want to give BW suggestions. That is exactly my opinion as well. We told them hat we don't like the ending, why we don't like it and why the ending is bad in the general terms of storytelling. We told them over and over and over again and we wont stop until something tangible happens. However, the question what to do about it, how to fix it, that is theirs to answer. It is their product, their story and they showed that they can tell amazing stories with the rest of ME3. So let them do their job and avoid pushing your own idea at them. So retconning the ending can work but only if it is done well. expanding the ending can work but only if it is done well. The Indoc theory can work but only if it is done well. That is what counts. IMO it is all in the execution. I'd rather just leave all the options open for debate and see what BW comes up with in the end.

[o96o]

This is it.

[SaladinDheonqar]

Amazing video. Thanks OP for bringing it to our attention, and MrBtongue for a heck of a job!

[pomrink]

i wish this could get stickied

[Chaota Vos]

I like his Q and Fry jokes. Dissertation of the series is fantastic, too

[Niostang]

This vid is really worth watching. Simple, coherent, sincere and funny.
It also goes great with chilli con carne.

[MeatShieldGriff]

 I don't get how all of this intelligent analysis and debate is thrown aside so quickly by bioware.

[the red boon]

I pray bioware watches this or at least scrapped the old ending.

[Elcirith Origin]

Utterly brilliant video! Also, he reminded me why I love the Mass Effect 3 soundtrack...

[Hunter_Wolf]

I agree with most of everything said. But I don't necessarily agree with the whole take out the kid. Yeah it's dumb but fix it, don't trash it. It ends up just hiding the problem. Put a twist to it, work with it and give more dialog that addresses the outcry - why we shouldn't listen to the kid and how it's just telling us BS to make us make a poor decision.

[Greyze2k]

Long Video, Fantastic Video.

[TheMadBlimper]

That was an extremely well done video. Bravo.

[eoinnx03]

He's trying too hard to be plinkett, but he made all valid points which Bioware as per usual will choose to ignore.

[GuardianAngel470]

wheelierdan wrote...

holy christ 40 minutes?

wheelierdan wrote...

actually this is pretty good.

This right here Bioware! This is how you do a double post! Go back to the drawing board and try again!












Sorry, I just found this double post extremely funny. Good job, no malice here.

[jzzabelle]

BRILLIANT VIDEO

If the length is turning you off...I suggest going through at least half of it. It is VERY informative


ALSO, BIOWARE SHOULD WATCH THIS AND SEE WHAT THEY SCREWED UP.

It is not about plot holes or anything nit-picky, it is about the series as a whole and why the ending does the trilogy INJUSTICE.

BIOWARE WATCH THIS AND LEARN

[Blindspy]

I was super skeptical at first. A lot of these "random internet personalities that I've never heard of" kept cropping up, and they were... eh, so-so. This guy, though, is someone I'm going to be showing to all of my friends. His video was beautifully crafted, with the right amount of logic, humor, formatting, and editing. This is easily the best "thoughts on the ending" video I have seen to date.

Thanks for the link, OP. Thanks to the video's creator, if he ever reads this.

[foxlockbox]

eoinnx03 wrote...

He's trying too hard to be plinkett, but he made all valid points which Bioware as per usual will choose to ignore.

Too hard? Hes acknowledges it in the video that he is doing it on purpose and IF he tried too hard he would try to imitate Plinkett's voice and wouldn't be using his "normal" voice (can't detect hints of him changing it) and he didn't do any basement cutscenes I was skeptical about his style first, but then I realised its just a shout out for the cult reviews, not an attempt to copy it.

[Sal86]

Great video. I don't think there's a clearer explanation out there, thanks OP.

[katamuro]

This reignited my fire of anger about this. tnx i was loosing it there for a bit and calming down

[Devils-DIVISION]

Fantastic video!
BioWare watch this and read the thread post "Musings of a Screenwriter" -- that should tell you what is wrong with the ending.

[earthonline]

 great video

also for reference, here is a list of the current ME3 endings:
Mass Effect 3 Endings List

[Mixon]

Fantastic and awesome video.

[Sirsmirkalot]

Bumping for greatness.