118 réponses à ce sujet

[Dendio1]

cogsandcurls wrote...

Well, this certainly seems to be getting interesting.

/gets the popcorn

Ill grab drinks, coke or pepsi

[Cazlee]

Dendio1 wrote...

Cazlee wrote...

KingNothing125 wrote...

I don't believe the "most used squadmate" theory. Every time I've done destroy, it's been Joker, my LI, and Javik. And I only bring Javik on a couple missions. Thessia and maybe one other random mission.

Same for me.

Ive always had joker, liara and ashley come out

And I barely used ash, liara being the LI

The only time ive seen edi is synthesis..like everyone else

Maybe the third person is supposed to be the most used squadmante you didn't bring on your Earth mission?
Or maybe it only counts missions like Thessia?

[Wabajakka]

No this goose chase is over. I can't get anything out of them, they've deleted it and stopped replying.

Although, if someone else is willing to attempt to report this "as a bug" at another time we may catch them slipping.

[Falcon509]

This just proves that A) the Destroy ending is the best ending (which isn't saying much), that spacedouche is lying out his ass to save himself, and C) the Indoc Theory still holds water.

[shepskisaac]

Falcon509 wrote...

This just proves that A) the Destroy ending is the best ending (which isn't saying much), that spacedouche is lying out his ass to save himself, and C) the Indoc Theory still holds water.

It is pretty much a fact that he lies at least to certain degree. He says all synthetic life will be destroyed and that even you are partially synthetic, clearly trying to make Shep think "ohh noes I will die". Obviously, we that it doesn't happen, which makes EDI survival also prfectly possible not to be a bug in such case.

[VoodooDrackus]

silverstreakusa wrote...

Cazlee wrote...

Do any of you have first hand experience with EDI living after choosing the destroy option?
Videos depicting it could have just switch the red/blue exit scene.

on xbox version i had her get out of the normandy after the bad (red) destroy ending fallowed by garrus who was in my squad on earth.

Why don't you load up your save "Restart Mission Citadel: The Return" and try again.

I have the 360 version as well. I have had EDI and Liara in my group for pretty much the entire game. They were with me during the final push to the Citadel as well.

I only had 2 options in my first play through. My initial choice was Control. Liara and then EDI step out of the ship in the end.
I reloaded from that save and chose the Destroy option. Liara and then Garrus ( who I hardly had in my group) step out of the ship.

--------
I now believe that you did see EDI step out after choosing the Destroy option. My EMS rating was not that high. I did not get the 3rd synthesis option. My Shepard is never shown breathing after.
So it stands to reason that with a higher EMS rating, your Shepard lives, EDI lives and the Geth live. Reapers are the only synthetic lifeform that is disabled. I think that explains everything actually.

Modifié par VoodooDrackus, 31 mars 2012 - 10:24 .

[Pottumuusi]

Maybe EDI is secretly organic, I dunno.

Lots of speculation from everyone.

Modifié par Pottumuusi, 31 mars 2012 - 10:53 .

[Giga Drill BREAKER]

anyone ever get video evidence of this

[spz123]

They're having a laugh with that twitter account. Either say something and stick by it or not at all. Too many silly games being played.

[Lozark]

Destroying all synthetics doesn't even make any sense. How does a beam of energy or an explosion know the difference between a computer, which is made out of synthetic materials, and a capital-S Synthetic? Do all biotics explode because of the implants in their spines? Did all the guns stop working too, since they're made out of synthetic materials? Did a large portion of the galaxy suddenly find themselves naked, since they're dressed in synthetic fibers?

[Epantiras]

Lozark wrote...

Destroying all synthetics doesn't even make any sense. How does a beam of energy or an explosion know the difference between a computer, which is made out of synthetic materials, and a capital-S Synthetic? Do all biotics explode because of the implants in their spines? Did all the guns stop working too, since they're made out of synthetic materials? Did a large portion of the galaxy suddenly find themselves naked, since they're dressed in synthetic fibers?

You're damn right

[VoodooDrackus]

Lozark wrote...

Destroying all synthetics doesn't even make any sense. How does a beam of energy or an explosion know the difference between a computer, which is made out of synthetic materials, and a capital-S Synthetic? Do all biotics explode because of the implants in their spines? Did all the guns stop working too, since they're made out of synthetic materials? Did a large portion of the galaxy suddenly find themselves naked, since they're dressed in synthetic fibers?

The Catalyst also says "and most of the technology that you rely on" if you choose destroy.

The biotic type energy that is sent out in waves throughout systems will destroy synthetic life, not material. Synthetic technology like implants would no longer work. As an example, you don't see the Reapers dissolve or blow up, you just see them cease operating and fall over.

[Lozark]

Epantiras wrote...

You're damn right

...Well I've never been one to say no to a good naked party.

[VoodooDrackus]

I just realized something on how EDI could have lived with the Destroy ending.

In my play through I did not have a high enough EMS rating to get all 3 options. I only had 2. Also the Catalyst mentions that technology that I rely on would be destroyed as well. In the Higher EMS that line is never said.

In the Destroy option, EDI does not step out of the ship, Garrus takes her place. Also I do not get the scene with Shepard breathing.

Watching a playthrough with a higher EMS rating, Shepard breathes during the Destroy option.

So with a higher EMS rating it may very well be that EDI does survive, with the possibility of the Geth surviving as well. The Reapers are the only synthetic life that is disabled.

In that case it may not be a glitch at all. And those who have seen EDI step out were suppose to see that as a wrap up to their story.

[AllThatJazz]

Yeah, I think it's logical to assume that if Shepard can survive the 'destroy' ending with enough EMS, then so could EDI and the Geth. I think that's kind of what that little scene at the end is trying to tell you. Not that I will ever know this with my Sheps, since I don't play MP and I don't have the apps, so I can't get enough EMS to get that scene :/

[Navasha]

The kid was clearly lying... He also said Shepard would die with the destroy ending... obviously that was false.

[Mcfly616]

I don't see why they would tip toe around their words so much.....its like they're hiding something....

Modifié par Mcfly616, 31 mars 2012 - 12:42 .

[Comsky159]

For any Bioware employees who encounter this thread perchance; this is not "speculation"; this is people grasping desperately for something which seems a little less contrived and nonsensical.

Anyway I'm on ps3 and on my 2nd play through of destroy, Shepard survived and EDI/Tali came out of the Normandy's airlock. So damn confused...

[new_bio]

In my 3 endings (played all from last autosave just before I made choice).
Synthesis - Joker with EDI and Liara (she should be dead after last explosion on Earth).
(BTW EDI also should be dead, because her brain was at back of the Normandy, which blow up during escape from Nova.)
Control - Liara and Joker and last Javik (played with him only 2 missions).
Destroy - Joker next Liara and finally Javik.
Liara was my LI. Javik probably because he is from DLC(?)
Hm. Deep breath N7 was from concrete piles, then I think it was on Earth not on Citadel(?).

[CmdrPwn]

DinoSteve wrote...

anyone ever get video evidence of this

I was just about to ask the same thing.  OP can you record that and post it on youtube?  I've been searching, but I can't find any clips with EDI coming out of the normandy after the destroy ending...

[silverstreakusa]

IsaacShep wrote...

silverstreakusa wrote...

Cazlee wrote...

Do any of you have first hand experience with EDI living after choosing the destroy option?
Videos depicting it could have just switch the red/blue exit scene.

on xbox version i had her get out of the normandy after the bad (red) destroy ending fallowed by garrus who was in my squad on earth.

Bad destroy ending? You mean the destroy ending in which Earth geuts burned too right?

yeah it doesnt show shep breathing after either.

[silverstreakusa]

sometimes edi is there sometimes she isnt its gotta be a glitch.

[Quietness]

Cdr. Pwn wrote...

DinoSteve wrote...

anyone ever get video evidence of this

I was just about to ask the same thing.  OP can you record that and post it on youtube?  I've been searching, but I can't find any clips with EDI coming out of the normandy after the destroy ending...

could not pay me enough to play through it again just to record the ending >.>

[Deventh]

mastergpo wrote...

But ... then that means that brat lied even MORE !

Maybe the brat never existed? Maybe we are in a mental institution?