1291 réponses à ce sujet

[aliengmr1]

101ezylonhxeT wrote...

DaeJi wrote...

101ezylonhxeT wrote...


There is no valid reason for liking the endings.

As someone who hates the endings on every level it is possible to hate something, this is not true. There are many valid reasons for anyone who wants to to like, even love the endings.

There are no valid reasons for saying the endings are good though.

As i said there are no valid reasons to like the endings period.

and you are wrong. People do like them. That is a fact and nothing you say can change that.

Modifié par aliengmr1, 01 avril 2012 - 03:30 .

[The Angry One]

Karrie788 wrote...

Upsettingshorts wrote...

"The Blight was ended!" I DONT CARE

Also: Vigil hates this entire ****ing thread.

See, the Ultimate Sacrifice ending to DA:O was brilliant. I personally sacrificed my Amell character because she was doomed from the start in my mind. It worked because I saw what happened to all the people she cared about afterwards. I learnt that Sten went back home saying that he met "one" worthy human being. I learnt that Oghren named his kid after her. I learnt that Alistair became a mess because his loved one died. I had closure, resolution.

We have none of these things in the ME3's endings. I don't know how Garrus is gonna cope with Shep's death. I don't know if Wrex will ever be able to go back to Tuchanka and to see Baraka and their little Mordin. I don't know if the forces I united are going to be able to make it him. I can only speculate. And no, it's not good, it's lazy writing and it goes completely against what the game was all about in the first place.

This. Except I never could sacrifice my characters, and I appreciate that BioWare gave me the choice not to.
But even when you have to sacrifice, you get closure, you preserve the world. It's not some nebulous future you're saving, it's everything you love.

[Quietness]

101ezylonhxeT wrote...
There is no valid reason for liking the endings.

god d*** i cant believe im about to do this....

This is your opinon. Your opinon does not make it fact for everyone. I ABHORE the ending on the highest level. I however respect another person's vision. You are however turning your opinon into fact. You hate the ending, i hate the ending, lots of people hate the ending, but some do not. As long as they provide their views ( AS WE SHOULD) without turning opinon into fact than there is no reason to not be social.

TL:DR Your opinon does not = fact , dont treat it as such it makes you sound foolish.

[DrowVampyre]

Yeah, so much this.

[Dreogan]

DaeJi wrote...

101ezylonhxeT wrote...


There is no valid reason for liking the endings.

As someone who hates the endings on every level it is possible to hate something, this is not true. There are many valid reasons for anyone who wants to to like, even love the endings.

There are no valid reasons for saying the endings are good though.

It seems like a subtle disctinction, but it means everything.

[Texhnolyze101]

Karrie788 wrote...

101ezylonhxeT wrote...


There is no valid reason for liking the endings.

Actually, there are. The themes that are introduced are interesting. Personally I think they're completely out of place but some people can appreciate or even love them. No need to attack them or hate them for having an opinion. Freedom of speech is important.

There. Is. No. Valid. Reason. To. Like. The. Endings.

[The Angry One]

101ezylonhxeT wrote...

Karrie788 wrote...

101ezylonhxeT wrote...


There is no valid reason for liking the endings.

Actually, there are. The themes that are introduced are interesting. Personally I think they're completely out of place but some people can appreciate or even love them. No need to attack them or hate them for having an opinion. Freedom of speech is important.

There. Is. No. Valid. Reason. To. Like. The. Endings.

Oh for god's sake find a new song.

[Karrie788]

101ezylonhxeT wrote...

Karrie788 wrote...

101ezylonhxeT wrote...


There is no valid reason for liking the endings.

Actually, there are. The themes that are introduced are interesting. Personally I think they're completely out of place but some people can appreciate or even love them. No need to attack them or hate them for having an opinion. Freedom of speech is important.

There. Is. No. Valid. Reason. To. Like. The. Endings.

Look, I loathe the endings just as much as you do. But people have different opinions. Please aknowledge that. It's not a terrible thing.

[WildcardCharlie]

LOTS OF SPECULATION

[Texhnolyze101]

Quietness wrote...

101ezylonhxeT wrote...
There is no valid reason for liking the endings.

god d*** i cant believe im about to do this....

This is your opinon. Your opinon does not make it fact for everyone. I ABHORE the ending on the highest level. I however respect another person's vision. You are however turning your opinon into fact. You hate the ending, i hate the ending, lots of people hate the ending, but some do not. As long as they provide their views ( AS WE SHOULD) without turning opinon into fact than there is no reason to not be social.

TL:DR Your opinon does not = fact , dont treat it as such it makes you sound foolish.

The people who like them don't matter and il say it AGAIN there is no valid reason to like the endings.

[Zardoc]

101ezylonhxeT wrote...

Karrie788 wrote...

101ezylonhxeT wrote...


There is no valid reason for liking the endings.

Actually, there are. The themes that are introduced are interesting. Personally I think they're completely out of place but some people can appreciate or even love them. No need to attack them or hate them for having an opinion. Freedom of speech is important.

There. Is. No. Valid. Reason. To. Like. The. Endings.

There is if you look at them seperated from the rest of the ME trilogy.

[Julie the bogan]

Well said Angry One.

So I wasn't the only one who wanted to scream at Miranda "LET ME HELP YOU WOMAN I TRULY WANT TOO" ?

[alterIncogn1T0]

EXACTLY.

I mean it's already been proven in the Mass Effect lore than regardless of a Reaper invasion every 50,000 years, organic life will continue to evolve into a new cycle of advanced, space-faring civilizations. So what if we ended the cycle for a future 10,000 years ahead of us? If the lore is correct, we may as well have let the Reapers win and be done with it.

This alone proves how broken the endings are.

[Dreogan]

101ezylonhxeT wrote...

Karrie788 wrote...

101ezylonhxeT wrote...


There is no valid reason for liking the endings.

Actually, there are. The themes that are introduced are interesting. Personally I think they're completely out of place but some people can appreciate or even love them. No need to attack them or hate them for having an opinion. Freedom of speech is important.

There. Is. No. Valid. Reason. To. Like. The. Endings.

I like lady gaga's Telephone. There's such thing as bad taste.

There's no valid reason to defend the endings from a perspective of craft, though. I will give you that.

[Texhnolyze101]

Karrie788 wrote...

101ezylonhxeT wrote...

Karrie788 wrote...

101ezylonhxeT wrote...


There is no valid reason for liking the endings.

Actually, there are. The themes that are introduced are interesting. Personally I think they're completely out of place but some people can appreciate or even love them. No need to attack them or hate them for having an opinion. Freedom of speech is important.

There. Is. No. Valid. Reason. To. Like. The. Endings.

Look, I loathe the endings just as much as you do. But people have different opinions. Please aknowledge that. It's not a terrible thing.

Sure I'll acknowledge them once they realize liking the endings is a stupid thing to do.

[Penitent]

+1

[billida]

parangon conversation with javik who is asking if shep cares about his friends. Shep says something like "of course they matter, if I didn't have them, there would be only death in my life, and it is not enough".

This is exactly why i loved the trilogy, and purely wholeheartedly HATED the ending.

[jvara]

Karrie788 wrote ...

Completely agreed. Mordin said it best in ME2: since the galaxy doesn't have a face, he gave it his nephew's face. That way he can fight for it.

That's exactly it, Bioware goes against themselves and their own rules, sentences and concepts in so many ways with this endings that I can't even begin to understand how some people do actually agree with them.

[The Angry One]

Zardoc wrote...


There is if you look at them seperated from the rest of the ME trilogy.

I despise the endings, but I actually think they could, with some adjustments (e.g. get rid of the Normandy scene) work as A ending. Just not THE ending.

[devSin]

DJBare wrote...

Excuse me folks if I'm over stepping my bounds...

Bait? PM A MODERATOR
Troll? PM A MODERATOR

Don't be a part of the problem.

If you have a problem with trolls, send a message to a moderator.

DO NOT USE THE REPORT THIS POST BUTTON!

Reporting a post sends a message to EA support, who will at their discretion and according to some secret rules possibly decide to do something. None of our friendly moderators, nor anybody who even works for BioWare, will know about the reported post.

If you want timely and just attention, PM a moderator with a link to the offending content.

Modifié par devSin, 01 avril 2012 - 03:39 .

[Persephone]

101ezylonhxeT wrote...

Quietness wrote...

101ezylonhxeT wrote...
There is no valid reason for liking the endings.

god d*** i cant believe im about to do this....

This is your opinon. Your opinon does not make it fact for everyone. I ABHORE the ending on the highest level. I however respect another person's vision. You are however turning your opinon into fact. You hate the ending, i hate the ending, lots of people hate the ending, but some do not. As long as they provide their views ( AS WE SHOULD) without turning opinon into fact than there is no reason to not be social.

TL:DR Your opinon does not = fact , dont treat it as such it makes you sound foolish.

The people who like them don't matter and il say it AGAIN there is no valid reason to like the endings.

It's nonsense like this why the Retakers are called whiny, entitled and rude.

[Vhalkyrie]

alterIncogn1T0 wrote...

EXACTLY.

I mean it's already been proven in the Mass Effect lore than regardless of a Reaper invasion every 50,000 years, organic life will continue to evolve into a new cycle of advanced, space-faring civilizations. So what if we ended the cycle for a future 10,000 years ahead of us? If the lore is correct, we may as well have let the Reapers win and be done with it.

This alone proves how broken the endings are.

According to Reaper logic, these poor organics will eventually make synthetics who will kill them.  So better to have obliterated all life in the universe because the cycle will just begin again anyway without the Reapers.

[JMA22TB]

We're all suffering from what happens when the climax is reached and there's no falling action or denouement. Add an asspull / deus ex machina as well as the big bad turning into the legions of terror of a brand new big bad that acts like he's God.

It's bad writing

Modifié par JMA22TB, 01 avril 2012 - 03:40 .

[DaeJi]

Persephone wrote...


It's nonsense like this why the Retakers are called whiny, entitled and rude.

We Retakers were called this and worse before nonsense like this. People who want and work for chance normally are.