M0keys wrote...
yeah it's not what I'd call scientifically sound. I agree there. and I guess if you had Chris L'Etoile working on it too, it'd be more technical, but.. I dunno *shrug*
It seems to me like he was focusing more on characters than anything? Ultimately in the end that your space buddies and the emotions you'd feel were more important than what tactics? That's just my opinion though.
If you have any suggestions that would make it more solid in terms of canon details, I'd be more than happy to pass them along and have him see what he can swing. the endings aren't carved in stone :
Well I actually wrote an
alternate Paragon ending that pretty much kept the original versions of the three choices but then added a forth when Shepard convinced The Reapers (Starchild gets replaced pretty quickly) that they were no longer necessary. But I couldn't just have them leave only to come back in a hundred years, having changed their mind and a straight up battle wouldn't have worked because of the Reapers elsewhere in the galaxy.
So what I did was create a scenario where Shepard spoke to three Reapers, each represented by holographic projections of the species they had come from before being turned into Reapers. I called them Chronicle, Order and then you had Harbinger. They were the first Reapers. The fourth would have been Sovereign but obviously he's gone. Shepard makes his case and eventually convinces Chronicle and Order that the Reapers should leave. Harbinger though disagrees and for the first time in the history of the Reapers, there is division between them. Harbinger and those who follow him vow to continue the cycle. Chronicle and Order say they won't turn against their own, no matter what.
I did rewrite the original three endings, with "Destroy" being a failsafe to destroy the Relays, dooming galactic civilization, Control being humanity becoming the guardians of the galaxy with help from the Reapers, charged with keeping synthetics from being created and resulting in humanity dominating the galaxy, a rebellion by the alien species and ultimately the extinction of many of those species, with Shepard hailed as a hero on Earth and a tyrant in the rest of the galaxy. Synthesis was rewritten to be the first stage of natural ascension. In essence, the choice the first Reapers made a billion years earlier that would see the galaxy take the first steps towards becoming the next generation of Reapers but on their own terms.
After a little more debating, Chronicle and Order agree to reprogram the Crucible, creating a new, fourth option that's basically reverse Sythensis. Instead of combining synthetic and organic, it separates the two components. The Reapers, being synthetic beings born from organics will literally be torn apart. While the new configuration is targeted at Reapers it also has side effects for others, like anyone with Biotic implants. It could kill them or simply shut down the implants, either way it's a lot of pain.
But it will take time for Chronicle and Order to complete the reconfiguration and Harbinger, knowing full well what they're going to do, is on his way to destroy the Crucible. Only those that support Harbinger's decision will attack the Crucible. The other Reapers will stay back, not attacking the fleet or Harbinger. What this allowed me to do was have a situation where the fleet could engage Harbinger's forces, a formiddable but still smaller force than the entire Reaper armada. I also had the Normandy crew on Earth evacuating injured Hammer troops to the FOC with the LI trying to reach the beam to get to Shepard.
While the story was a full paragon ending, there were various points where EMS and various decisions would come into play. For instance, Harbinger's forces set up a blockade to prevent the fleet from getting to Harbinger. Only the Normandy gets through and takes on Harbinger alone, with Joker deciding overload the drive core and crash the Normandy right into Harbinger as a last resort. Then the Rachni show up, giving the fleet the chance to break through, allowing Joker to veer off and survive. On the ground, Jack and Wrex can show up and whether they do or not will determine what squad members die in the final assault, if any, which in turn helps determine whether or not Shepard lives or dies. Even getting the fourth option relies on uniting the Quarian and the Geth and even with that, if your EMS is too low, Harbinger will destroy the Crucible and the Reapers will continue to harvest the galaxy.
Now I'm not saying that what I did is needed here. My own intent was to find a way to make decisions and EMS count with the fate of everyone depending on what you did in the three games, while allowing for a final confrontation with Harbinger and a potential victory at Earth that would affect Reapers across the galaxy.