Aller au contenu

Photo

Jennifer Hale (femshep) article - no contact with BioWare


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
239 réponses à ce sujet

#151
Craigolas

Craigolas
  • Members
  • 105 messages

ReggarBlane wrote...

If she's not involved with BW for this, then EA's telling the truth that they're not adding or changing endings. BW will obey.


No, they are just not going to add any scenes that involve the voice of anyone. The endings aren't changing, I agree. That doesn't mean they won't be clarifying what your choice actually meant to the galaxy (and previous choices you made such as saving the Rachni Queen, etc.)

#152
Duzaman7

Duzaman7
  • Members
  • 220 messages
Somebody call up Seth Green, maybe we'll get some Normandy SR2 crash site DLC. This hurts me Bioware, it makes me want to become an alcoholic, go back to 2007, punch myself in the face and say,"Just stick to Halo 3 and Fallout 3, you'll be better off. Trust me."

#153
Wolfen919

Wolfen919
  • Members
  • 196 messages

DreamTension wrote...

Take it however you want, but Ms. Hale was quoted here:
The article says, "Hale says she knows nothing of what's coming in the new content that BioWare CEO Ray Muzyka says will address people's complaints over the game's ending. She hasn't been contacted by the team, hasn't had a recording session, or been given any indication that she will be needed for this new content"

Some quotes:
"I have mixed feelings about [the prospect of a new ending]," she admits. "I really respect the team and what they did and how hard they worked. And endings are hard! They're cutting new ground; the players are so involved in this game that to come up with an ending to something everyone's got their hand in is a huge challenge."

"So maybe it's going to take a little work to get everything sorted in a way that's going to make everybody happy."When asked if she had any idea how developer Bioware might respond if fans don't care for the second stab at the ending, Hale laughed and said: "I don't know. Thank God I'm not a writer!"



I'm not a writer, but I can for damn sure write a better ending than Mass Effect 3 that a good majority of the fans would accept. I respect the hard work a writer has to go through, but the plot holes should have been fixed before releasing the final product. Any writer could come up with an ending to a series, but a good one would have found an ending that wouldn't tie any lose ends and make some sense with the overall theme and plot of the series.

#154
The Angry One

The Angry One
  • Members
  • 22 246 messages

humes spork wrote...

The Angry One wrote...
Also, it did change it significantly solely because you lived.
At the time it was made, the protagonist dying was a big deal for Bethesda. Yes, there was the option to have what's her face die instead but the game basically attacked you for taking this option.
So changing this was a big change in the plot and theme of Fallout 3, after Bethesda realised it just didn't work.

FO3 is to date the first and only game in the FO series, spinoffs included, to have a playable epilogue, by the way. FO2 only had an interactive ending, opposed to a fully-realized playable epilogue in the conventional sense. I "thank" the people that expected post-apocalytpic Elder Scrolls for that.

And, even in BS the game called you a great big puss if you sent Lyons, or the rad-immune companions, in Project Purity nevertheless.


In that sense neither did Morrowind or Oblivion. They technically did with their expansions, but you could do those before the end of the main quest.
Likewise with Fallout 2 you could still do other quests you missed in the post-game.

#155
Mcfly616

Mcfly616
  • Members
  • 8 998 messages

Orthodox Infidel wrote...

byne wrote...

Capeo wrote...

A twist makes everything that came before it in the plot wrong or misleading intentionally.



Everyone you meet tells you Revan is dead. Suddenly it turns out nope, you're Revan.

I fail to see how that isnt 'intentionally misleading'


It's intentionally misleading, but once the reveal happened, it made perfect sense. If you go back and play KOTOR again, it's clear that all the Jedi Masters know that you're really Revan, and that they're talk about the "Dark Lord returning" is from "a certain point of view."

If the Mass Effect 3 ending is a "twist," then what's the explanation that makes perfect sense for the ending? There isn't one. "Indoctrination Theory" doesn't count because it's a total muddle. Compare that to KOTOR's actual twist: Everyone who played KOTOR knows that the player is Revan, and it's presented so clearly that nobody questions it after finishing the game.


That's because, if the ending of ME3 is in fact a "planned" plot-twist, then they have yet to reveal it to the player...hence why there will be dlc taking place after the fact....if it was all planned that is....

I admit, that is the only way we will know it is a twist....and we won't know until Bioware officially comments

#156
ofish

ofish
  • Members
  • 291 messages

DreamTension wrote...

Take it however you want, but Ms. Hale was quoted here:
The article says, "Hale says she knows nothing of what's coming in the new content that BioWare CEO Ray Muzyka says will address people's complaints over the game's ending. She hasn't been contacted by the team, hasn't had a recording session, or been given any indication that she will be needed for this new content"


ugh:o

#157
DreamTension

DreamTension
  • Members
  • 470 messages

Orthodox Infidel wrote...

byne wrote...

Capeo wrote...

A twist makes everything that came before it in the plot wrong or misleading intentionally.



Everyone you meet tells you Revan is dead. Suddenly it turns out nope, you're Revan.

I fail to see how that isnt 'intentionally misleading'


It's intentionally misleading, but once the reveal happened, it made perfect sense. If you go back and play KOTOR again, it's clear that all the Jedi Masters know that you're really Revan, and that they're talk about the "Dark Lord returning" is from "a certain point of view."

If the Mass Effect 3 ending is a "twist," then what's the explanation that makes perfect sense for the ending? There isn't one. "Indoctrination Theory" doesn't count because it's a total muddle. Compare that to KOTOR's actual twist: Everyone who played KOTOR knows that the player is Revan, and it's presented so clearly that nobody questions it after finishing the game.


Everyone knew that your avatar is Revan because the game TELLS YOU.  IDT is basically saying BioWare has not TOLD US yet. 

I guess we have to agree to disagree because the IDT makes total sense to me.  Not saying it's perfect or even saying it's a fact, but it coimpletely makes sense.

#158
Strategyking92

Strategyking92
  • Members
  • 172 messages
yikes, well I guess come April 6 all hope will be gone. Thanks Bioware, you ruined by birthday you ******s.

#159
The Angry One

The Angry One
  • Members
  • 22 246 messages
Well you never know, maybe Hale has already recorded lines where Shepard has told the Catalyst to spin on it in various colourful ways and since she hasn't played ME3, has no idea why people are upset with this awesome ending.

Maybe.
Possibly.

....

Please. :crying:

#160
xsdob

xsdob
  • Members
  • 8 575 messages

ReggarBlane wrote...

If she's not involved with BW for this, then EA's telling the truth that they're not adding or changing endings. BW will obey.


By your logic than bioware would have been making no content for mass effect 3, since they still would need her to voice shepards diolouge, or do you think that dlc will be maleshep exclusive?

#161
Catroi

Catroi
  • Members
  • 1 992 messages

They gave him full access.  This is what people don't get.  BW loved the endings.  They've had them planned this way for ages.  They were expecting nothing but accolades from the fans.  They weren't worried about hiding their "brilliance".  

There is no conspiracy afoot, no hidden ending and no new ending coming.  The game is done as far as BW is concerned.  The most we may get is some "clarifying" epilogues that likely won't even have VA.


Then why did one of the writer said on reddit (he had been using this account for 2 years) that the team had nothing to do with the whole endmission? That it was only Casey and the main writer? And that the whole team was like "wtf?" when they saw the ending?

Oh yeah and mods here said it was fake even if this account has been used by a legitimate member of the writing team for 2 years... :bandit:

#162
DarkShadow

DarkShadow
  • Members
  • 371 messages

Quietness wrote...

You forgot Prince of Persia as well.


Yeah, you're right, but I kinda repressed ever playing that huge dissapointment of a game...
The difference to ME3 was that, while PoP's ending was also dumb and made the game pointless, I didn't really care about that game at all.

Modifié par DarkShadow, 04 avril 2012 - 05:59 .


#163
Dendio1

Dendio1
  • Members
  • 4 804 messages

Animositisomina wrote...

It's an old quote though, from about a month ago, prior to this article.


This is  worth achknowledging. Mass effect 3 was released about a month ago.

#164
DreamTension

DreamTension
  • Members
  • 470 messages

The Angry One wrote...

Well you never know, maybe Hale has already recorded lines where Shepard has told the Catalyst to spin on it in various colourful ways and since she hasn't played ME3, has no idea why people are upset with this awesome ending.

Maybe.
Possibly.

....

Please. :crying:


+1 holding the line...

#165
humes spork

humes spork
  • Members
  • 3 338 messages

The Angry One wrote...
In that sense neither did Morrowind or Oblivion. They technically did with their expansions, but you could do those before the end of the main quest.
Likewise with Fallout 2 you could still do other quests you missed in the post-game.

Most of the NPC's in FO2 switched to their epilogue dialog after you trashed the oil rig, and post-story gameplay was extremely limited.

The core difference between TES games and FO games is FO games have a much more focused narrative. You finish the main quest, and the game is over. Up until the point of no return you're sandboxing, but once you start the final sequence that's it. TES games since Morrowind treated the main story line as just another questline to be completed with no impact on the sandbox nature of the game.

#166
Beti88

Beti88
  • Members
  • 154 messages
10$ Codex Update DLC incoming...

#167
Aweus

Aweus
  • Members
  • 502 messages

The Angry One wrote...

Well you never know, maybe Hale has already recorded lines where Shepard has told the Catalyst to spin on it in various colourful ways and since she hasn't played ME3, has no idea why people are upset with this awesome ending.

Maybe.
Possibly.

....

Please. :crying:

Angry, stop with the tears! Look at you! You sound like Shepard in current "endings" - defeated and broken. We need you in the front line goddammit!

#168
parrmi22

parrmi22
  • Members
  • 220 messages
I . . . well, they could still be at the planning stage . . . or . . . this really doesn't mean anything . . .

Ohkay, I'm grasping at emergency induction ports.

#169
byne

byne
  • Members
  • 7 811 messages

Aweus wrote...

The Angry One wrote...

Well you never know, maybe Hale has already recorded lines where Shepard has told the Catalyst to spin on it in various colourful ways and since she hasn't played ME3, has no idea why people are upset with this awesome ending.

Maybe.
Possibly.

....

Please. :crying:

Angry, stop with the tears! Look at you! You sound like Shepard in current "endings" - defeated and broken. We need you in the front line goddammit!


I didnt even realize that was The Angry One until you pointed it out.

Angry, stop changing your picture, I am easily confused!

#170
jumpingkaede

jumpingkaede
  • Members
  • 1 411 messages

DreamTension wrote...

Capeo wrote...
How many BW games have you played?  Name one with a "twist".  They're not known for secret or M. Knight style endings at all.


Whoaaa....now you just lost me.

that's the one thing they are known for, their twists.  KOTOR, DA, etc...they all have twists. 

Now ENDING TWISTS?  Well...I am not sure if these would be ending twists.  I don't think ANYBODY has done an ending twist like this so that's not really a good point.


It's an ending twist like M. Night Shymalan does.  

Surprise!  It was never about Commander Shepard and stopping the Reapers it was always about the Catalyst, Synthetics, and Organics!!

Sound familar?

Surprise!  It was never about the 1700s-era village and monsters in the woods, it was always about a billionaire's attempt to avoid modern society.

Surprise!  It was never about Bruce Willis trying to treat a child who sees ghosts, it was always about Bruce Willis being a ghost and finishing what he needed to do on Earth before departing.

#171
crimzontearz

crimzontearz
  • Members
  • 16 789 messages
there's like NO point right now in replsying the godamn game


we will not hear anything in months

#172
Taboo

Taboo
  • Members
  • 20 234 messages
THIS ARTICLE IS A MONTH OLD.

THE GAME WAS RELEASED ALMOST A MONTH AGO.

#173
Aurvant

Aurvant
  • Members
  • 372 messages
It appears that my Shepard will forever be holding the line with Marauder Shields. She refused to walk in to the beam and now she fights to hold the line for her love, Liara, for her best friend, Garrus, and for everyone else.

#174
DreamTension

DreamTension
  • Members
  • 470 messages

byne wrote...

Aweus wrote...

The Angry One wrote...

Well you never know, maybe Hale has already recorded lines where Shepard has told the Catalyst to spin on it in various colourful ways and since she hasn't played ME3, has no idea why people are upset with this awesome ending.

Maybe.
Possibly.

....

Please. :crying:

Angry, stop with the tears! Look at you! You sound like Shepard in current "endings" - defeated and broken. We need you in the front line goddammit!


I didnt even realize that was The Angry One until you pointed it out.

Angry, stop changing your picture, I am easily confused!


That's funny. I do the same thing: I look at the poster's picture first and make cognitive relationships with the posts before I look at the name.  It probably says something about me.

#175
DreamTension

DreamTension
  • Members
  • 470 messages

Taboo-XX wrote...

THIS ARTICLE IS A MONTH OLD.

THE GAME WAS RELEASED ALMOST A MONTH AGO.


It was published today. 

It's at the very most two weeks old since it directly mentions the press release by the co-founder.