Aller au contenu

Photo

Xbox 8.5, PS3 9.0, PC 9.5 Rating


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
35 réponses à ce sujet

#1
ScottyScott3

ScottyScott3
  • Members
  • 9 messages
This makes me very nervious, I wish they had a demo on Xbox now because it has the worse of the three reviews...

Gamespot said the graphics weren't as good. I don't know if I should get it for Xbox now. :unsure:

#2
dynas2001

dynas2001
  • Members
  • 204 messages
Me too. I'm pretty upset that there is suposidly a noticable difference between the ps3 and 360!

#3
foolish_sagacity

foolish_sagacity
  • Members
  • 52 messages
that really IS odd. Usually PS3 and 360 games are indistinguishable from one another. I knew the PC version would be the best, but that's really odd.



I guess you should ask yourself, do you need sparkly visuals? Because the review said the story was in top form, but the visuals were not on the 360.

#4
RageModeMessiah

RageModeMessiah
  • Members
  • 3 messages
Graphics looked fine to me watching all the streaming videos put up on GameTrailers all this time.



Obviously the PC version will score higher than console versions, but I don't understand why the PS3 version scores so much higher than the 360 when there's no real noticeable difference. Regardless, I don't own one, so I'm stuck with the Xbox 360 version; but I doubt anyone will be disappointed.

#5
panos74gr

panos74gr
  • Members
  • 5 messages
The pc version takes up almost 16GB of hard disk space, I suppose that they had to trim down the texture quality a lot on the XBOX 360 version because of the 8.5GB limit of a dual layer dvd.


#6
ukillemwegrillem

ukillemwegrillem
  • Members
  • 7 messages
Once again, Bioware ****** on the 360 fans.


#7
Wogahamsel

Wogahamsel
  • Members
  • 5 messages
I personally thought it was a bit strange the way they reviewed it. I understand how much better the pc version but surely minor graphic improvements on the ps3 with the occasional frame rate difference isnt worth a drop of 0.5 points? Seems like such a big difference over such a small thing especially as the 360 framerate is very smooth

#8
Kbrury

Kbrury
  • Members
  • 26 messages
last time I checked 8.5 is very good and it only got that score because of the graphics.

#9
Lumenadducere

Lumenadducere
  • Members
  • 115 messages

ScottyScott3 wrote...

This makes me very nervious, I wish they had a demo on Xbox now because it has the worse of the three reviews...

Gamespot said the graphics weren't as good. I don't know if I should get it for Xbox now. :unsure:


AS good.  Doesn't mean they're bad.  I'm seeing this type of reaction from 360 users all over the place.  8.5 is still a respectable score, and I don't really understand why people are worried that it suddenly means the game will suck.  Makes very little sense.

#10
Noahsdadiscool

Noahsdadiscool
  • Members
  • 93 messages
Why would anyone play anything BUT a PC game when given teh choice?,....I'm not trying trying to troll, I'm curious is all. :)

#11
Reizarvg

Reizarvg
  • Members
  • 22 messages
Jesus, do you care that much about grahics? Look at the size of the **** game, it's not important.

#12
zippie151

zippie151
  • Members
  • 53 messages
well i cant comment really but it seems xbox has the better frame rate, I would suggest trying to find some ps3 and 360 screens and compare them.

#13
Ekyri

Ekyri
  • Members
  • 312 messages
 

Once again, Bioware ****** on the 360 fans.


:lol:

#14
fooliecooly

fooliecooly
  • Members
  • 25 messages
Glad I decided to get the PC version over its console derivatives...at the cost of buying a new video card LOL

#15
Flamezdude

Flamezdude
  • Members
  • 99 messages
The graphics seem fine on the Xbox from what i've seen on videos and streams, i'm not much of a graphics **** so i don't care much anyway. Prototype didn't have amazing graphics and the console version of Fallout 3 wasn't amazing either.

#16
KotOREffecT

KotOREffecT
  • Members
  • 946 messages
It's ironic really.. I remember when it use to be Xbox that was doing the dominating, the one getting the game first, and the one getting the highest reviews for games like KotOR. PC got the games later, and playstation got no love. Now it looks like the tides have turned. Personally, there really isn't no difference between PS3 and 360 from what I've seen, but what they hey? Obviously this game was made for PC first, so it will have some advantages. But both are still essentially the same game in the end. So 360 buyers, don't get down about this, you will still enjoy this great game.



Just wait until Mass Effect 2 comes out though, then we will see just how top notch and powerful the 360 can get. Dragon Age has been made over the past 6/7 years, no wonder why it probably has been a pain in the ass to get it on the 360.

#17
ZackusMaximus1

ZackusMaximus1
  • Members
  • 25 messages
I read that PS3 has some framerate issues. I would rather play with slightly worse graphics on xbox than framerate issues on PS3. Not that i would ever own a 360 anyway...

#18
ZackusMaximus1

ZackusMaximus1
  • Members
  • 25 messages
Worse graphics for xbox is better than framerate issues on PS3...not that I would ever own an xbox anyway.

#19
jableskage

jableskage
  • Members
  • 222 messages
LMAO ps3 better than 360... that is epic! :devil:

#20
andy4theherd

andy4theherd
  • Members
  • 16 messages
i pre-ordered for 360 the first week of Oct. i was back and forth on what system to get (my pc sucks). at that time there were NO PS3 vids out and the release date was pushed back. so i went with 360. now i am going to head to WalMart and swap the 360 version for PS3.

#21
andy4theherd

andy4theherd
  • Members
  • 16 messages
i pre-ordered for 360 the first week of Oct. i was back and forth on what system to get (my pc sucks). at that time there were NO PS3 vids out and the release date was pushed back. so i went with 360. now i am going to head to WalMart and swap the 360 version for PS3.

#22
minddrifter462

minddrifter462
  • Members
  • 2 messages
For one, I don't actually have a choice...I have to go PC. But if I did have a choice, I'd still go PC. Not only do most major gaming reviewers preach this, but I would always choose an epic game like DA on PC over a console. Before too long consoles become obsolete, or some sort of external hardware for PCs. That's my theory, PC > All, in most cases.

#23
Salz78

Salz78
  • Members
  • 63 messages
Yeah, but 8.5 still is pretty good.

#24
Tech6425

Tech6425
  • Members
  • 23 messages
makin a mountain out of a mole-hill

#25
Flamezdude

Flamezdude
  • Members
  • 99 messages
I REALLY don't see the problem with Xbox 360 graphics. Look at this:

I mean really, thats not bad at all.