stonxx wrote...
Companies are there to make a buck.
I read that argument a lot. I think that this is somewhat true today but it wasn't always, especially in regards to computer games. Many companies started out making shareware games and their intention was first and foremost to create amazing games an maybe make a buck with it. In those days I would have had no problem regarding a game as art.
Somehow gaming became a huge industry and now we have companies like EA and Activision which really are only interested in maximizing their profit. And you see it in the games today: their is very little innovation, many games seem rushed and are full of bugs on release day and there's DLC everywhere (not that I'm completely against DLC), online passes so you can't sell your games anymore, sometimes game-crippling DRM, always-online singleplayer games (I can't play ME3 if EA servers are unreachable). I cannot consider games employing any of these "features" art, simply because they just feel like they've been made to generate as much profit as possible and not to be as great a game as possible.
Mass Effect has been an exception for me. I was sceptical when I bought the first game because of the big EA logo at startup. But I was surprised in a good way. Maybe there was hope after all.
Then in ME2 they went a bit over board with their DLC and I never understood why they changed the weapon systems to use thermal clips ( I really liked the cooldown system because it was different and it worked and the explanation was good).
Both points I would see as ways to gain more profit by making the game accessible for a broader audience. Nevertheless I really liked ME2 and I had more playthroughs with it than any other game I had ever played.
And then there's ME3: I have only two explanations for what happened with the ending:
1) They ran out of time because of strict deadlines set by EA and thus couldn't really take all the actions of the player into account. Thus they just put together some cutscenes and painted them differently. If that was the case then why include MP? When I first read about MP in ME3 I was very confused. I didn't want it. I couldn't see a way to even implement it. But they did it. And frankly: It's not that bad, actually quite fun. Would anyone have missed MP if it had never been announced? I don't know. I certainly wouldn't have.
2) The writers of ME just think differently. Maybe it makes more sense for them because they have created the world and have their vision of it in their heads. They have information we don't have about the world because there must be ideas that never made it into the game.
If that is the case, I think it's bioware's fault for not managing to convey the meaning to the player. Maybe it's a result of 1) I don't know. All I know is, that I don't get it. And I also know for a fact that I am neither stupid nor intellectually handicapped (like many people sadly say about people disliking the ending).
The rest of ME3 was absolutely awesome. I had a bug in the hanar diplomat quest, which was the only time I came to this forum before I finished. And while looking for answers regarding this quest I read one or two thread titles regarding the endings and I thought those where the usual whiners at work already. The game was so great I couldn't believe they messed up the ending right until I got there. Here are my thoughts from my first and only playthrough (feel free to skip it, it's not my best writing effort:
-------
At first I thought I made a mistake when the laser beam hit me. But then Sheppard got up, badly wounded, blurry vison. I liked that. The enemys where suddenly dead with just one shot and I had unlimited ammo. Hmm... that's strange? Why do that? Then the citadel looks different than before. OK, maybe the reapers can re-arrange it. But how did Anderson get ahead of me? Oh, god dammit why's he standing there like that, I fear he's been... yep indoctrination at work, dammit, not Anderson. Oh hello Illusive Man. Wait, how did he get here? WTF is he talking about. How can he control me. Did I just shoot Anderson? TIM, you're indoctrinated. OK, he shot himself. That didn't stop Saren. but OK. Now what? OK, I go to the console. Now let's see what happens. Ahh final moments with Anderson. But where's the exploding reapers. I'm confused. Wait, Hackett says nothing happened. OK, back to the console.. Oh no, Shepard's too weak and collapses on the floor. Wait. Where'd that elevator come from? Shepard collapsed in exactly the right spot? Seems wrong. That kid again. Is this a dream? WTH is he talking about? Can't wait to tell hoim to shove it. Wait? that's all I can say to him? What do you mean I have these three choices? I don't believe it. There must be something else <panic> What did I do wrong? I made peace between geth and quarian, cured the genophage, unitd Krogans and Turians. Could I have done anything better? I don't want to chose and I don't want to destroy the Relays. Maybe... No, can't kill the Starchild. dammit, have to chose. OK, let's take destroy. No wait, the geth, EDI... can't do that. Synthesis? No, can't do that, either. Can't make that decision for trillions of people. OK, control it is. I'll die, but whatever. Wait. How do I control them if I'm dead? Oh forget it, too late. OK, nice cinematics, But what's with my crew? Ah there's the Normandy ... fleeing? Why? And they get caught, oh no, they're all dead! Ahh, Joker managed to land! Good guy!. Wait! How did Liara get there? She was on Earth with me moments ago. Confusion again. Credits? Already? Isn't there more? Skip. Ahh there's more. But wtf? When how why? Why are they talking about "going to the stars" like there is no space travel? Did I just destroy galactic civilization? What in the name of god did I just witness? Those guys in the forums where right, this is outrageously bad. It's so bad it hurts. I have to reload my last save and see what the other endings are like. All the same? Oh please, you can't be serious. <from here on I can't describe my thought any more because of bad language>
-------
I don't know if anyone even reads this considering the speed at which this forum moves. But I had to get this off my chest,