259 réponses à ce sujet

[Valk72]

No, that's a step in the good direction but it's not enough, at all.

[Whimper]

As I said before, it all depends on how much they clarify, and how.

[LyletheBloody]

 It depends on how the DLC is executed.  If Shepard still dies no matter what, then no.  If there is no respect paid to choice, no.  If the Star Child still makes no sense, no.

It just depends.  Will they be BioWare quality or ME3 quality?  That will determine if they are good enough.

[slimshedim]

Cogneter wrote...

Mr Massakka wrote...

No. That's not what we asked for, ever.

Makes one wonder who were BioWare "listening" to.

They're way too busy patting eaqch other's backs because of ART and being voted the worst company in the US!


Seriously, better expect an additional pink, purple and yellow ending this time or you might end up being disappointed, once again.

Modifié par slimshedim, 06 avril 2012 - 08:19 .

[TweedleDee66]

If the ending was good in the first place and made sense then a “clarification” download wouldn’t be necessary. Hell, it should have been in the game in the first place.

The ending was worse than I imagined it to be after seeing all the spoilers about it. There is just something about experiencing it as you play the game to really give you perspective about just how messed up it was. As it is I wont play the final chapter, Cerberus Base and Earth. I may not even play the game again considering it took me an hour to get an import character to look like how she did in ME2. They couldnt even give me the right skin color. Not rushed out the doors my ass.

-Sorry, I keep spewing comments like that in almost every comment I mkae here and elsewhere. I just cant get over how this trilogy that started off with a bang just ended in such a bad way.

As for this download being enough? I voted absolutely not.

I just don’t see how a few cinematic scenes and epilog text or dialog can fix this ending. I’ll keep an open mind (and pray that its good) until I see it online since I’m not wasting my hard drive space for this thing. But with their track record of downloads I don’t have high expectations at all. Anyone remember the Alternate Appearance Packs and how they managed to mess up them AND not even finish them?

A simple download that picks up right after we see all the cinematic scenes would work. Bethesda did it just fine with Fallout 3 with Broken Steel. If you use the indoctrination theory the ending is simple to do really. It took me less time to think up my idea than to type it up. But nope, BioWare cant do that I guess.

[Cogneter]

TweedleDee66 wrote...

A simple download that picks up right after we see all the cinematic scenes would work. Bethesda did it just fine with Fallout 3 with Broken Steel. If you use the indoctrination theory the ending is simple to do really. It took me less time to think up my idea than to type it up. But nope, BioWare cant do that I guess.

Yeah, that's rather simple technically-wise. But that would require BioWare to admit their mistakes and dismiss the current ending as a dream sequence, which would surely hurt their "artistic integrity".

[DeepSchist]

I'd say that additional dialog and closure PLUS one additional ending would be fine. An ending in which you reject the star child's claims and let the battle outside conclude to whatever end.

[Cogneter]

DeepSchist wrote...

I'd say that additional dialog and closure PLUS one additional ending would be fine. An ending in which you reject the star child's claims and let the battle outside conclude to whatever end.

I believe it has been established throughout the series that the Reapers can't be defeated by conventional means. Thus, I would rather prefer an ending where Crucible just does its work and destroys the Reapers, no strings attached.

If they add the ending to reject starchild just in spite, dooming the entire galaxy to extinction in this cycle, that would make Shepard look like an ass.

Though, if combined fleets manage to destroy at least half of Reaper forces, the next cycle might actually have a chance.

[OntologicalShock]

No. The poop still stinks and all they've offered is to tell us why it stinks so bad. I want something that isn't poop, please.

[Azmahoony]

I've stopped caring.

looking towards the next game to waste my money on. (prototype 2)

[AnuzaGray]

 1600 people is too small to give an accurate sample size, but if it reaches 20,000 and is still around 80% voting for a changed ending well...that just reinforces how much Bioware fudged it up.

[PlumPaul93]

Depends on how much "Clarification" there is. Though if it explains what happened to who and why it'll be enough for me.

[nranola]

Personally I think it wouldn't be enough, but it's the least that they can do. It would make accepting the ending a little easier on some folks.

But of course, it also depends on the execution, so... Wait and see, I guess.

[PlumPaul93]

AaronXR wrote...

I've stopped caring.

looking towards the next game to waste my money on. (prototype 2)

Heh, I've started playing FO3 again. Amazing game.

[The_Crazy_Hand]

 To be fair, this should say expansion, clarification would just be a codex entry or something.  We're getting more than that, but my problem is that Bioware is more concerned with their "vision" than making fans happy.

[dkear1]

New ending!

[TsaiMeLemoni]

I am conflicted, because I know so many have been so disappointed by the endings that it would be nice to see them get the option they actually want.

However, I also feel it's kind of too early to start throwing stones again. Who knows, maybe the clarification will at least make the endings make sense.

[Azmahoony]

PlumPaul82393 wrote...

AaronXR wrote...

I've stopped caring.

looking towards the next game to waste my money on. (prototype 2)

Heh, I've started playing FO3 again. Amazing game.

Oh yeah for sure, spent many hours grinding through them wastelands!

[Cogneter]

PlumPaul82393 wrote...

AaronXR wrote...

I've stopped caring.

looking towards the next game to waste my money on. (prototype 2)

Heh, I've started playing FO3 again. Amazing game.

Without Broken Steel?

[Azmahoony]

Point lookout inbred/hicks (whatever you want to call them) sure did make me run alot! lol

[AnuzaGray]

Like hell it is.

[Necrotron]

DeepSchist wrote...

I'd say that additional dialog and closure PLUS one additional ending would be fine. An ending in which you reject the star child's claims and let the battle outside conclude to whatever end.

I'd rather the starchild be retconned into the abyss, but...that'd be better than what it sounds like is currently planned.

[goofyomnivore]

I'm going to wait and see. If I get an ending where the relays don't blow, Normandy crash is removed/clarified/they're not all dead and a cinematic/text epilogue of the future I'll be content. It won't be the best ending ever, but it is an ending I can work with.

Modifié par strive, 07 avril 2012 - 07:43 .

[Damien Nightwind]

Bioware clearly wasnt listening AT ALL to their fans, if thats what listening is then to all the guys here, go to your girlfriends or wives and when they ask you if you are listening to them, slap them in the face and then slap them again but make it take longer. Then see if they are satisfied with it.

Modifié par Damien Nightwind, 07 avril 2012 - 07:46 .

[dorky24]

I'll have to reserve judgement on the DLC contents. It will be extremely tough for them to be able to properly explain the ending in a way that actually makes sense.