302 réponses à ce sujet

[Giskler]

1. Catalyst/Guardian
2. Jacob Taylor
3. Diana Allers

Modifié par Giskler, 10 avril 2012 - 10:34 .

[Adam2190]

1. Allers: No explanation required.
2. Vega: He just doesn't fit in for some reason, i always thought there was something a little off about him.
3. Kaidan: His voice alone drives me mad, besides he whines too much.

Modifié par Adam2190, 10 avril 2012 - 11:30 .

[Esther]

Diana Allers.
Udina.
Kai Leng.

[pablosplinter]

Jacob
Catalyst
Shepard - "Hello Space Wizardt, can i choose red please?"

Modifié par pablosplinter, 10 avril 2012 - 11:39 .

[4stringwizard]

1. Starchild
2. Starchild
3. Starchild

Excuse me if this has been said already.

[Astralify]

4stringwizard wrote...

1. Starchild
2. Starchild
3. Starchild

^This.

[daigakuinsei]

1. Jacob
2. Ash
3. ME1 Tali

I'd say starkid but that thing is barely a character.

Modifié par daigakuinsei, 11 avril 2012 - 10:46 .

[Virtual winter]

Star brat
Allers
Jacob

[cogsandcurls]

Casper the hateful ghost
Kai Leng
Allers

None of them added anything positive and at worst, they actually had a negative impact on the wider lore of the ME universe (The death of Emily Wong, Leng's stupid "watch out we've got a badass over here" incompetent space-ninja schtick, and obviously).

There are other characters I disliked, but my dislike of those characters is due to a success in the writing - I hated them because they were well-written and I didn't get on with them as people on some level or another. These guys? I dislike them because I see them as a weakness in the writing.

[AtlasMickey]

You guys know you can kill the Catalyst, right? He even stands there and let's you do it. You'd think that would satisfy your hatred. You can kill him with FIRE lol.

VibrantYacht wrote...

AtlasMickey wrote...

Garrus
Garrus
Garrus

You thought I was trolling BEFORE.

Seriously, though, in ME1 Garrus annoyed me because he never stood up to me. No matter what I said to him, he was always like, "yeah, I guess you're right," while equivocating between his original opinion and mine. Annoying. Plus I play Infiltrator and, yes, Garrus, I am a better shot than you. On occasion I would look down my scope and see an enemy drop to the echoing boom of your Mantis rile, before I could get a shot off of my own, but that was only on occasion. Usually I got it first. And yes as I approached ArchAngel's hideout, watching enemies in front of me drop to the same sound, I thought, "gosh that reminds me a lot like Garrus" that does not mean you are the end-all-be-all of this game, like you are to so many girls. You're a kissass and you're creepy. The fact that you spend your free time as a vigilante shooting people in the slums screams problems.

Liara was my LI through all the games and an excellent squad mate, but I didn't like how distant she became. Never really got the sense she was really committed to me. Like I upset her life when I came back to her in LoTSB. Then she acted as if she was waiting for me to die in my short human life, so she could get on with another 900 years of her life. I was a temporary, if passionate, curiosity for her. Can't really blame her. That's how feelings are.

ME3's narrative is not a dating sim. The objective of the game is not to live happily ever after with your LI.

Lastly, hmm, Dr. Chuckles. She needed more involvement with the crew. The way she always seemed so alone and isolated, never seeing her work. Yes I know the game is complex and the developers can't do everything, but she's the chief medical officer. Where are the dramatic life-saving medical procedures that she comes up with to save the day? Sad that I can't imagine her really doing anything medical.

There's... something wrong with your reasoning. It's broken. The fact that he doesn't stand up to you doesn't really... mean anything. It doesn't make him weak as you made him sound. It doesn't make him anything. He likes justice and is having a hard time figuring out how justice-getting should be done. Any suggestions you make can be accepted by him. By ME2 he knows how he wants to carry the justice-seeking out. By being a vigilante. Also, he's funny and probably one of Shepards best friends. I'm a not a girl, and I do not play as a femshep, but Garrus is still in my top 3 favorite characters of ME. He's like a confused Javert (from Les Miserables, the novel/book/whatever) with a tiny bit of Batman.

A "confused Javert" ... wow, that's certainly a new perspective. I'll have to look at him again with that in mind.

[DrFrankenseuss]

1. Catalyst
2. Conrad Verner
3. Chobot

Runners up:
- All Volus. They just annoy the living bleep out of me
- Ashley. She's just plain annoying, and I don't think it's entirely intentional.

[beyondsolo]

Space Kid: What the I don't even...

Diana Allers: Any ME2 squad member or Emily Wong would have been better. This character is utterly unproductive for the plot, the interviews with her are not even completely written out and pointless. Hell, I'd even take Al Jilani instead of her.

Kai Leng: I think this was just a matter of poor design choice. I thought he was an interesting villain in Retribution. But his Raidenification and exaggerated smugness in ME3 make him more annoying than anything else. I could have taken him seriously if he had been a hard working operative, convinced of his cause/indoctrinated, but the way he seemingly accomplishes everything with little effort makes him out of place at best, unrealistic at worst.

[KingNothing125]

Spacebrat
Kai Leng
Diana Allers

[NaastyNZL]

1 - 'Starchild' -
2 - Diana Allers - Ingame advertisement for IGN.
3 - Tali - She's overrated...

Runner ups:
VS
Jacob

[BigBad]

Diana Allers - Completely pointless character, horrible voice acting, literally added nothing to the game except a set of breasts, and took a place and role that could have been filled by a much better selection of established characters.

Kai Leng - This guy. Just . . . this guy. I absolutely hate fights you're not allowed to win, and frankly I found it insulting to have this guy punking me in cutscenes and getting away scott-free for most of the game.

Aria: I know everybody loves Aria for being so badass or whatever, but I hate this character. She's rude to Shepard, but more importantly, she treats him like an errand boy and always frames his favors so that it appears he's on her payroll and subservient to her. And she gets away with it. Shepard even drinks the Kool-Aid and tells multiple NPCs not to mess with Aria. C'mon, dude. Shoot her in the face for being smug to a Spectre.

[EvilChani]

1. Starbrat with a god complex - Worst. Idea. Ever.

2. Kaidan - The man is a douche.

3. Kei Leng - Not only did this asswipe lead to Thane's death, but he's a plethora of stupid stereotypes thrown into one lousy character.

[Spectre Hal Jordan]

Star Child
Kai Leng
Allers

[Asch Lavigne]

Miranda - I cannot put into words how much I dislike her
TIM - Only because in the end he was a Saren rip-off
EDI - I wanted to rip her out of my ship in 2 and they made her a squadmate in 3. Really!?!?!

Modifié par Asch Lavigne, 11 avril 2012 - 11:13 .

[kal_reegar]

Spacebrat aka Catalyst aka Stachild
nobody can hope to compete with him.

[YayForYuffie]

1) Star Kid.
2) Kai Leng.
3) That volus who lost his credit chit at the salarians tech shop in Mass Effect 2.

[ADeadDiehard]

Kaidan - The Geth Prime on Rannoch had more personality
Delan - Whiny coward
Saracino - Compares aliens to Hitler ("Well meaning naivete led to declarations of 'Peace in our time'.") and you can't tell him to go to hell

[77boy84]

1. Starchild
2. Allers
3. Kai Leng

Lets not kid ourselves here, people. I think we can all agree that these three are objectively the worst characters in the trilogy. I know some people don't like Jacob, or Vega, and Kaiden, but come on. They weren't bad characters. I personally don't like Tali at all, but I don't think she's a bad character. I just don't like her.

NO ONE likes Starchild, Diana Allers, or Kai Leng (maybe some people like him, but not many), they are terrible additions to the trilogy. They are objectively bad.

[Cosmochyck]

1) Kai Leng
2) Star Child
3) Diana Allers

They just didn't add anything to the ME experience, and if anything, took away from it.

Modifié par Cosmochyck, 11 avril 2012 - 11:26 .

[Ariaya]

Starchild is just a given.

But also...

Jacob Taylor
Jacob Taylor
Jacob Taylor

[Visserian99]

Catalyst - obvious reasons
Allers - We had Emily Wong, why does this character exist.
Ashley - Never really liked her, her personality always rubbed me the wrong way.

Dishonorable mention - Jacob. God he was just so boring.

Modifié par Visserian99, 11 avril 2012 - 11:35 .