385 réponses à ce sujet

[Foxhound2121]

Obvakhi wrote...

Memory issues

you mean xbox issues  >. >

[GothamLord]

I didnt think there was any further to fall in levels of disappointment over BioWare and ME3. Then I saw this scene.

[nupfi]

iakus wrote...

Sil wrote...

Has anyone actually tweeted/facebook messaged any of the Bioware folks regarding this? It'd be interesting to know if they had a reason for cutting it.

I would be really curious to hear a response as well

[RocketManSR2]

 Quick, somebody check the cutting room floor! I think the game we all wanted is there somewhere! Seriously, though, the 2 sides of the ending issue have united on this. Nearly every post is stating they want this back in and are puzzled as to why it was removed. BioWare, you are supposed to remove fluff in the cutting room, not important character development. I know production has only just started on the EC DLC, so I beg you, please put that scene back in! 

I know we can't bump topics, but we can't let this die, not until we get some dev attention.

Modifié par RocketManSR2, 11 avril 2012 - 10:26 .

[Survivalist]

Once a cut scene has been made surely the vast majority of the work has already been done and it is actually wasteful not to include it?

Edit: didn't realise this "cutscene" was actually a slide show.

Modifié par Survivalist, 11 avril 2012 - 10:31 .

[TekFanX]

Wow...I really like this scene.
If it's real or not;).

I think it doesn't get too religious neither too scientific.
It's even less religious than the dialogue about the stuff with the trenches in ME1.
Plus: How can there be memories in Shepards head about the afterlife, if the body was dead?
I don't think there would be any harm done.

The only thing I could think of why BioWare cut it out, is Shepard being uncertain about being really Shepard.
After everyone was afraid project Lazarus wouldn't have brought their Shepard back, BioWare may was afraid this could bring it all up again.

In my opinion, it would have been great if the scene had been in the game.
Maybe instead of "Does it matter?" Ashley could've said something like "I may was uncertain who you are before...with Cerberus. But now...I know who I love and that has always been you." in the last pic. Something a little more sentimental.

Modifié par TekFanX, 11 avril 2012 - 04:22 .

[Pipe 42]

I'll be honest the pics look like they've been recycled from the love scene.

It was an important part of her character and leaving this out was a real shame. There should have been options to discuss it in more detail. I really missed having the options of talking to my squadmates rather than just having ambient conversations. It felt very much like they'd stripped out a large amount of character building.

[mango smoothie]

TekFanX wrote...

Wow...I really like this scene.
If it's real or not;).

The dialogue comes from the script that was leaked back in November.

[Nerevar-as]

TekFanX wrote...

Wow...I really like this scene.
If it's real or not;).

I think it doesn't get too religious neither too scientific.
It's even less religious than the dialogue about the stuff with the trenches in ME1.
Plus: How can there be memories in Shepards head about the afterlife, if the body was dead?
I don't think there would be any harm done.

The only thing I could think of why BioWare cut it out, is Shepard being uncertain about being really Shepard.
After everyone was afraid project Lazarus wouldn't have brought their Shepard back, BioWare may was afraid this could bring it all up again.

In my opinion, it would have been great if the scene had been in the game.
Maybe instead of "Does it matter?" Ashley could've said something like "I may was uncertain who you are before...with Cerberus. But now...I know who I love and that has always been you." in the last pic. Something a little more sentimental.

The last part gets answered in the Cerberus base, at least if you take Liara.

[Unfallen_Satan]

It's a good scene, but I am glad they cut it. I don't have that level of spiritual insight. I don't care if there is light, fire, or just nothing after death. I don't want my Shepard to get bogged down by such concerns either.

EDIT: If it's a dialogue choice, then I am cool with it. People who want to explore it can.

Modifié par Unfallen_Satan, 11 avril 2012 - 06:04 .

[katamuro]

Pain Train wrote...

See, this is the character development I felt lacking in ME3 between a lot of the squad mates. This really should be added into the story some way.

This

[drawnacrol]

I can't believe they cut this!!! Its dialogue like this that made Mass Effect 2 for me.

[lolspawn]

they need to add this back in. bioware i am dissapoint

[AVPen]

Huh, I wondered what the heck happened to that scene, after reading it previously in the leaked script.

Kind of a shame that it got cut since Ashley has, what..... only one damn dialogue scene on the Normandy? 
(hell, at least Kaidan got two scenes plus he moves around the ship and interacts with other crew members, which Ashley never does at all)

Modifié par AVPen, 12 avril 2012 - 01:56 .

[PARAGON87]

Wow, that was a great scene. Shame it was cut, this really gives a lot of insight on Shepard's vulnerability and Ashley's questioning of faith.

[Papa John0]

No clue why this was cut. I'd like to see it back in. Ash's character was so sparsely involved in the game for the last two thirds. It was a real disappointment.

[Spectre Impersonator]

They shouldn't have cut this or Anderson's extra dialogue in his I'm Proud Of You scene. Bad idea.

[ps3oldmike]

Papa John0 wrote...

No clue why this was cut. I'd like to see it back in. Ash's character was so sparsely involved in the game for the last two thirds. It was a real disappointment.

last 2/3s try last 3/4s i was mad that tali seemed to have more lines in the game and you dont get her till the last 1/3 of the game

[sammysoso]

Seriously BioWare, put this in-game. Ash doesn't have much content in the first place. (a real shame, one of the best, most real female characters in video games)

[PlumPaul93]

I didn't mind this being cut tbh

[Holoe4]

JohnShepard12 wrote...

They shouldn't have cut this or Anderson's extra dialogue in his I'm Proud Of You scene. Bad idea.

Hopefully they're gonna add those in with the Extended Cut DLC. But what if they were planning the DLC this whole time and took those scenes out on purpose just so they can be added?
though I can't see any type of advantage they receive by doing so... Speculation time 

[DamonD7]

It just really fits Ashley's character beautifully, that she would wonder like this. And gives Shepard a bit of introspection to a huge event in his life...death...life!

[Baihu1983]

Seems the best stuff got cut

[kegNeggs]

wow now this stuff is exactly why I chose ashley in the first game. a damned shame it got cut out, she really got dumbed down

[Namz89]

Another notch on the "rushed/cut out content" bar