262 réponses à ce sujet

[Atheosis]

Topographer wrote...

Drell Adept is Gold tier. It always has been except now he gets up to 8 grenades
He is your spawn nuker

Yep.

Lots of holes in this list.  Lots of holes.

[G. P. Burdell]

This whole thread seems kind of discouraging really. People, maybe new players who aren't that knowledgeable about the game yet, are going to come in here and see God Tier: Geth Infiltrator and never play anything else again. Or they will shun all adepts except asari because asari are A and all others are inferior. If you can rock a female Quarian then more power to you. I don't want people who could do great on other classes to never even try them because they have a predisposition against it because of some silly popularity contest forum post. We don't need tiers, this isn't a competitive game, if you aren't pulling your weight then you will know it and it's up to you to decide if making a class change is worth it. If you are pulling your weight then your teammates will know it and shouldn't care what class you are. All this thread does is give people an excuse to dole out unwarranted criticism and promotes false stereotypes. It enables people to form biases based on character classes that are unhealthy to the gaming community as a whole.
Whew, yeah maybe that was a little extreme but the points in there somewhere.

[Looper128]

Ok, from now on we will be doing it like this:

I will create polls for evry singel char so everyone can just vote. Keep in mind I have to wait a bit in betwen creating Polls so all of them wont be up right away. We start things of with the Geth infil.

[eldrjth]

G. P. Burdell wrote...

This whole thread seems kind of discouraging really. People, maybe new players who aren't that knowledgeable about the game yet, are going to come in here and see God Tier: Geth Infiltrator and never play anything else again. ....

if a new player tries GI they will wonder why its in the top teir cause it keeps dropping onto the ground after a couple of hits. if they try the SI on the other hand (and have maxed krysae) then they prob wont need to play anything else. though a new player only has the basic classes unlocked and probably very few rares. so you can argue that human infil or human sentinel is the best for new players out of the common unlocks, or drell adept of quarian infil out of the uncommons.

[humes spork]

Firebase hydra, no consumables, FOX GETH INFLITARTOR ONLY.

Modifié par humes spork, 05 juin 2012 - 04:06 .

[Looper128]

Human adept poll is up.

[Atheosis]

Lopper128 wrote...

Ok, from now on we will be doing it like this:

I will create polls for evry singel char so everyone can just vote. Keep in mind I have to wait a bit in betwen creating Polls so all of them wont be up right away. We start things of with the Geth infil.

Hmm...this should be interesting.  Not that popular opinion is necessaril correct, but it should be interesting to see how the community sees things.

[kirby145]

Lopper128 wrote...

Ok, from now on we will be doing it like this:

I will create polls for evry singel char so everyone can just vote. Keep in mind I have to wait a bit in betwen creating Polls so all of them wont be up right away. We start things of with the Geth infil.

Not really necessary. The people saying grenade classes are top tier have the grenade upgrade. If you don't have that, grenades are like a wasted skill on the class othewise.

People are basing things off certain weapons or items that other people do not even have.

[Grimy Bunyip]

one for every class?
thats a lot.
wont people just vote for their favorite classes?

[Atheosis]

Grimy Bunyip wrote...

one for every class?
thats a lot.
wont people just vote for their favorite classes?

Are people really such simpletons?  Oh right, they are...

[Looper128]

If they do they do, the list b4 was clearly not sufficient so this was my best idea, I'm also really curius to see how the list will look in the end.

Human vanguard (hosting) is up.

[Tangster]

I'm voting, but I am trying to keep in mind the difficulty and skill level required to make the best use of the classes.
Which is why a GI is only A tier for me, lots of people can't play glass cannons.

[Looper128]

Batarian soldier is up

Modifié par Lopper128, 05 juin 2012 - 04:45 .

[kirby145]

Way too many polls lol. Better when you just listed your opinion.

[Looper128]

That list was based more on ppls opinions in this thread then my own.

And I know I know 1000 polls but this is the fairest way to do it. everyone get one vote and hopfully we can just make some kind of tier out of all that.

on that topic: Justicar is up and away!

edit. besides its me doing all the hard work here, puting togheter those 1000 polls

Modifié par Lopper128, 05 juin 2012 - 04:53 .

[JaimasOfRaxis]

I personally would bump the Krogan Soldier and Sentinel to C tier.
Let me explain why.

The two Krogan classes offer borderline-identical options for defense, and have solid overall offense due to their armor-destroying powers (Carnage, Incinerate) and ready access to grenades that are useful for crowd control and debuffing or setting up biotics. Whilst their actual battlefield utility can be difficult to discern, their staying power and ubiquitous nature makes them pretty darn useful in general, and a team is almost always better with one than without..

[Looper128]

Geth engineer is up~

[Atheosis]

kirby145 wrote...

Way too many polls lol. Better when you just listed your opinion.

Shhh you.  I actually like this idea.

[Xaijin]

Poll and tier formation are diametrically opposed, sorry. With is the reason sample size and tiering don't mix.

[Skittls]

Atheosis wrote...

kirby145 wrote...

Way too many polls lol. Better when you just listed your opinion.

Shhh you.  I actually like this idea.

Agreed. Alas, it is sleepy time now, so I shall vote on the remainder of the polls in the morn.

[Looper128]

A bunch of new polls added, hopfully I can get the rest done later today or tomorrow.

[GiroX-]

I agree with your original tier rankings, especially the A rank.

Only thing I would move is Human Engineer to B class. Its an AoE SE.

[GodlessPaladin]

The recent patch/DLC gave massive buffs to both Infiltrators and grenadiers when they were already great.  Asari Adept no longer has a place in the same tier as the Drell Adept, for example.

Modifié par GodlessPaladin, 05 juin 2012 - 07:16 .

[Looper128]

Turian soldier added, more on its way~

[Looper128]

All polls are up! Get on voting, tell your friends! Togheter we can make a comunity decided tier list! And dont forget to keep discussing so as many ppl as possible can see and vote =)