Aller au contenu

Photo

HOLD THE LINE for MASS EFFECT 3-Billboard Campaign (TARGETING EA/BIOWARE)-NEED YOUR DECSION WITH POLL! [UPDATE 1: POLL IS UP!][UP2: We're listening alright!?][Up3: Under Evaluation]


1189 réponses à ce sujet

#1051
Jamie9

Jamie9
  • Members
  • 4 172 messages

Calbeb wrote...

Vilegrim wrote...

John Epler wrote...

A) If you have nothing constructive to post, please don't post. You aren't adding anything to the board or the thread.

B) That being said, anyone who you'd hope to make aware of your concerns via this method is aware of your concerns. At the end of the day, though, it's your money, and you can certainly spend it however you'd like. But if you're trying to spread your message this is not going to do much more than waste 5$ from 1800 people. Again, though - it's your money.


Then why was the response a flat no to the issues raised? Also known as we have to agree with space hitler?


Did you just refer to Bioware as Hitler because they didn't do what the fans said they should?

You don't have to buy their games if you don't want to.


I thought he was referring to the Catalyst?

#1052
CrutchCricket

CrutchCricket
  • Members
  • 7 735 messages

Opsrbest wrote...
I don't mean boss battles. I mean from running down the strip to the beam. Moving throguh the citadel to the console etc. The minor aspects of the ending or that begin the ending and continue through. Dialogue wheel options, VO etc. 120 000 is not enough to compensate for all the development costs that would occur.

As for straight up capitalism there are legalities behind it. You can't just buy an ending. 

Ok but again I think we have different ideas of how much needs to be chanced. There is nothing wrong with the "beam run" or anything up to Anderson dying. That can all stay. And in any case I don't imagine $120,000 would be the final cap, just the starting point. What I'm saying is these are impressive sums we have raised (and are looking at raising). Why not target the root of the problem?

Again maybe I don't know the facts but what legalities are you referring to?

#1053
Calbeb

Calbeb
  • Members
  • 407 messages

Jamie9 wrote...

Calbeb wrote...

Vilegrim wrote...

John Epler wrote...

A) If you have nothing constructive to post, please don't post. You aren't adding anything to the board or the thread.

B) That being said, anyone who you'd hope to make aware of your concerns via this method is aware of your concerns. At the end of the day, though, it's your money, and you can certainly spend it however you'd like. But if you're trying to spread your message this is not going to do much more than waste 5$ from 1800 people. Again, though - it's your money.


Then why was the response a flat no to the issues raised? Also known as we have to agree with space hitler?


Did you just refer to Bioware as Hitler because they didn't do what the fans said they should?

You don't have to buy their games if you don't want to.


I thought he was referring to the Catalyst?


Yah. I haven't slept all night as I work on final papers. Misread it as a nasty dig at Bioware. Completely my bad.

#1054
whoisthis98

whoisthis98
  • Members
  • 151 messages
look casey screw up. He wrote the worst ending in history all there is to it but it's over. They can not bad mouth him at bioware else they will. Forget the billboard the best you can do is NOT buy any EA products and when they look at why sales are way down ( which will also lower their stock ) you let them know why and who is responsible. Then once casey is fired you can rest easy knowing this will likely never happen again for fear of backlash.

#1055
Jamie9

Jamie9
  • Members
  • 4 172 messages

Calbeb wrote...
Yah. I haven't slept all night as I work on final papers. Misread it as a nasty dig at Bioware. Completely my bad.


No problem. Sleep evades the best of us.

Good luck btw.

#1056
Calbeb

Calbeb
  • Members
  • 407 messages

whoisthis98 wrote...

look casey screw up. He wrote the worst ending in history all there is to it but it's over. They can not bad mouth him at bioware else they will. Forget the billboard the best you can do is NOT buy any EA products and when they look at why sales are way down ( which will also lower their stock ) you let them know why and who is responsible. Then once casey is fired you can rest easy knowing this will likely never happen again for fear of backlash.


So you want the guy responsible for the series that you love to be fired because you don't like the ending?

#1057
Calbeb

Calbeb
  • Members
  • 407 messages

Jamie9 wrote...

Calbeb wrote...
Yah. I haven't slept all night as I work on final papers. Misread it as a nasty dig at Bioware. Completely my bad.


No problem. Sleep evades the best of us.

Good luck btw.


Thanks man :)

#1058
Kanon777

Kanon777
  • Members
  • 1 625 messages
[reverse psychology]

As a pro-ender i support this idea 100% and the response this thread is clear proof this will do nothing but good to the Retake movement and ME fans in general, go ahead OP dont let anyone try to convince you otherwise

[/reverse psychology]

#1059
SilencedScream

SilencedScream
  • Members
  • 853 messages

John Epler wrote...

...At the end of the day, though, it's your money...


You're absolutely right.
It'll stay that way too, until I find a developer that will address the major criticisms levied against them by the majority of unsatisfied customers that bother to visit their website at all.

Bringing up the Star Child in the last ten minutes of the game - even if clarified in the "extended" version - still leaves the problem of there being a simple "off-switch" and "A,B,C choice," both of which Casey stated weren't the case.

#1060
AcesRedd

AcesRedd
  • Members
  • 293 messages

GBGriffin wrote...

AcesRedd wrote...

What I mean to say is that as the days pass by I see there is a clear decline in the talk related to how much the ending sucks. I'm not saying people are changing their minds or even pleased with the results (though I'm sure some might be.) But I think that just like with everything that our short attention spans fixate on people are simply losing interest and moving on to a different game or drama.

The game came out right now, it did not meet expectations, but much more importantly it betrayed what had been a great series. Whether people enjoyed the ending or not, they were lied to and given a subpar product, right now while the iron is hot we can still cause a change (hopefully  more than what I think the community has already done,) but three months from now I don't think even a very passionate group will be able to rally the support to cause any effect whatsoever. 

That being said I've seen a few discussions on the billboard and I feel it is a bad idea. Still, I would be very open to put my money toward something that will have an effect. Though I am passionate about what I want, I don't think it is unreasonable (though it might be from someone else's point of view.) 

What I want personally, is someone who is responsible for all this BS. Either the executive whatever or the head of whatever, be that from EA or EAware. Someone who says "I rushed them", or "I cut their budget" or "I simply got lazy." Whatever, accepts responsibility and goes looking for new job opportunities.

The other thing I want is for them to just come out and say something vaguely resembling, "alright fans, look it was bull ****. We knew it was gonna suck, we just didn't realize how much you'd hate it. We will fix it, we're sorry for all the bull****, we were just scared and there were budgets and deadlines and it sucks, but forget the artistic bull****, we're sorry. We really mean it and we will do our best to fix this."


So, you feel that the forums should be filled with daily reminders of how much the endings suck, even as people have admitted to wanting to just wait for EC? 

People know the endings suck; it's why we started protesting . The difference is that maybe people don't feel as passionately about it as you do because something finally happened. They commented on it, they announced the EC, and while you might feel it isnt enough for you personally...I don't think people are just going to forget about the EC. If your goal is to keep people in a constant state of anger until then...I don't think that's healthy for anyone.

My point is, protest it then and turn up the heat then, not before. Otherwise, it truly is whining about getting something for free that is the direct result of a prior protest. You might have to accept that some people, shockingly enough, are willing to let it go, and that's even without the DLC in their hands!

If you're expecting them to fire someone because you didn't get what you want, after they've defended their work, I don't think it'll happen. If your happiness and enjoyment rides on the hope of someone getting fired...that's not healthy. As for a concession, they aren't going to state anything like that in those terms. Take the EC as your concession, because they didn't even have that, and maybe try to calm down a bit and just be patient. Lack of patience leads to awful ideas like this; staying angry for the sake of being angry isn't good.


People want to wait for the EC because they have the hope that the polish will be a fix. I too have that hope, but I think most of us know that as the ending stands there is no way to really fix it that isn't going to have magic or some other easy fix. I think its not that I'm more passionate that most, I actually only recently even found out about the ending, even though I got the game on the first day I'd completly avoided any and all news about Mass Effect in order to be surprised. I didn't finish the game until a week or so ago, maybe going on two weeks now and after feeling rather unsatisfied I came on here and started lurking at first then speaking out a bit.

I know that just like it has died down for everyone it will certainly die down for me, it is simply in our nature, as you've said it is not healty and for the most part not likely to remain angry for an extended period of time. I'm sure people are not going to forget about the EC, and I don't expect people to remain angry for three months (or however long), but I do expect that by the time EC comes out even if it actually makes the game even worse, even if its the biggest middle finger to the fans, there will be less action, because people will simply look at it on youtube and be like, "told ya it would suck," or people will simply be crushed. I know this is just what I'm guessing will happen, but yea kind of like you said, people can simply not stay angry.

I definitely see and know that people are very willing to let it go. I see some people simply don't care even if they hate it. Some people care but don't care enough to really do anything (I've mostly fallen in that group =/) and some people care as long as they see something might happen but if nobody else seems to care they'll give up. I hope whatever is done gives enough negative attention to lower sales, stock, do something that affects not their "artistic integrity" but their wallets, EA or EAware.

As far as firing someone, I've seen on the boards that people say things like, "how can you wish someone loses their livelyhood." Well it sucks, but if I suck at my job I get fired. If a walmart employee sucks at his job he gets fired too. So do lawyers and doctors. I know this is "just a game" (as people like to point out) but someone was incompetent. Either by creating unreasonable deadlines, by underbudgeting a project, by lying or maybe simply being stupid, either way someone f'ed up. Actually, I'm sure people's jobs are being affected by all the negative attention, its just quiet. Does my own happiness depend on someone being fired? Not at all. But do I feel better about being wronged (though I would have just rather not been wronged) when someone is punished, weeeeell at least a little. 

Now as far as really accepting fault, you're right...unless they're really sorry. I mean really sorry, or at least feel that the only way to stop alienating everyone is to 'act' sorry. (I'll take acting even if they're not as long as they act it out well :D)  And the only way to make a faceless company sorry is to hit their wallet. Pull their fanbase, have the media focus its attention on them in a way that suits their product, and well once they start to see actual effects maybe they'll be a lot more talkative. Or not, but hey if we're bored enough to be on here and we pay $4 for starbucks a day why not see if we can actually cause some change for something we are interested in? (I'd vote if I wasn't a Californite)

#1061
Kanon777

Kanon777
  • Members
  • 1 625 messages

Aznable Char wrote...

This is a grave concern . And also a creepy Parallel about the whole working in a closed group thing that plagued the ending of ME 3 .

Therefore I'll have to amend my

LIST OF SOME BILLBOARD-BIOWARE PARALLELS:
1. COUNTING SUPPORTERS INSTEAD OF THOSE AGAINST
2. PR SPIN OF 'YES WE'RE LISTENING BUT WE'RE NOT GOING TO TAKE IT OFF THE TABLE'
3. THINKING THOSE AGAINST IT ARE JUST PRO-ENDERS AND NOT A SIGNIFICANT SAMPLE SIZE OF RETAKERS
4. 'WE WORKED SO HARD THEREFORE PLEASE ACCEPT OUR BILLBOARD' (replace the word Billboard with Ending)
5. PLANNED ONLY INTERNALLY WITHOUT SEEKING OUTSIDE DELIBERATION TO GAUGE UNIVERSAL APPROVAL


Win!!!

#1062
Bronze65

Bronze65
  • Members
  • 254 messages
The most constructive thing you can do to this thread is locking it.

#1063
Guest_Opsrbest_*

Guest_Opsrbest_*
  • Guests

CrutchCricket wrote...

Opsrbest wrote...
I don't mean boss battles. I mean from running down the strip to the beam. Moving throguh the citadel to the console etc. The minor aspects of the ending or that begin the ending and continue through. Dialogue wheel options, VO etc. 120 000 is not enough to compensate for all the development costs that would occur.

As for straight up capitalism there are legalities behind it. You can't just buy an ending. 

Ok but again I think we have different ideas of how much needs to be chanced. There is nothing wrong with the "beam run" or anything up to Anderson dying. That can all stay. And in any case I don't imagine $120,000 would be the final cap, just the starting point. What I'm saying is these are impressive sums we have raised (and are looking at raising). Why not target the root of the problem?

Again maybe I don't know the facts but what legalities are you referring to?

We do. For me the cohesion of the ending begins at the beam run. The fact that is where you first lose your two squadies at least for me is where the single component of Shepard begins which is why I said it was where the ending initiates itself.

As for the legalities I don't know specifics but I do know that you can't outrightly purchase a new ending because of specific laws. I would think it has more to do with the intended nature of the donation it against what the donation could be used for and since Bioware could face legal reprecussions if even purchased the ending was unsatisfactory
to those who contributed, as well as for the group that would be contributing. Then theres the whole shareholders rights etc.

#1064
AcesRedd

AcesRedd
  • Members
  • 293 messages

Calbeb wrote...

Jamie9 wrote...

Calbeb wrote...

Vilegrim wrote...

John Epler wrote...

A) If you have nothing constructive to post, please don't post. You aren't adding anything to the board or the thread.

B) That being said, anyone who you'd hope to make aware of your concerns via this method is aware of your concerns. At the end of the day, though, it's your money, and you can certainly spend it however you'd like. But if you're trying to spread your message this is not going to do much more than waste 5$ from 1800 people. Again, though - it's your money.


Then why was the response a flat no to the issues raised? Also known as we have to agree with space hitler?


Did you just refer to Bioware as Hitler because they didn't do what the fans said they should?

You don't have to buy their games if you don't want to.


I thought he was referring to the Catalyst?


Yah. I haven't slept all night as I work on final papers. Misread it as a nasty dig at Bioware. Completely my bad.


You writing them or grading them?
I'm supposed to be analyzing the development of new cultures from immigrants as portrayed in the media...instead I'm on bsn :ph34r:

#1065
Aznable Char

Aznable Char
  • Members
  • 360 messages

tobito113 wrote...

Aznable Char wrote...

This is a grave concern . And also a creepy Parallel about the whole working in a closed group thing that plagued the ending of ME 3 .

Therefore I'll have to amend my

LIST OF SOME BILLBOARD-BIOWARE PARALLELS:
1. COUNTING SUPPORTERS INSTEAD OF THOSE AGAINST
2. PR SPIN OF 'YES WE'RE LISTENING BUT WE'RE NOT GOING TO TAKE IT OFF THE TABLE'
3. THINKING THOSE AGAINST IT ARE JUST PRO-ENDERS AND NOT A SIGNIFICANT SAMPLE SIZE OF RETAKERS
4. 'WE WORKED SO HARD THEREFORE PLEASE ACCEPT OUR BILLBOARD' (replace the word Billboard with Ending)
5. PLANNED ONLY INTERNALLY WITHOUT SEEKING OUTSIDE DELIBERATION TO GAUGE UNIVERSAL APPROVAL


Win!!!


Before I go to bed I just wanted to let you guys know that the actual architect already posted a few pages earlier that the project is suspended . He didn't know this thread existed until like an hour ago and the OP of this thread wasn't actually part of the project team .

He delivered a rather class act apology and explanation of which I was thoroughly proud and wish that BioWare could have done the same . He can't change the OP so please make sure to let people know that this has already been resolved and would have been resolved earlier if the people at HTL had seen this earlier . Unfortunately this "jim" OP fellow of this thread managed to run a PR nightmare unchecked and everyone assumed he spoke for them =( . Let's try to mend fencers as fellow REtakers .

Modifié par Aznable Char, 10 avril 2012 - 02:10 .


#1066
Calbeb

Calbeb
  • Members
  • 407 messages

AcesRedd wrote...

Calbeb wrote...

Jamie9 wrote...

Calbeb wrote...

Vilegrim wrote...

John Epler wrote...

A) If you have nothing constructive to post, please don't post. You aren't adding anything to the board or the thread.

B) That being said, anyone who you'd hope to make aware of your concerns via this method is aware of your concerns. At the end of the day, though, it's your money, and you can certainly spend it however you'd like. But if you're trying to spread your message this is not going to do much more than waste 5$ from 1800 people. Again, though - it's your money.


Then why was the response a flat no to the issues raised? Also known as we have to agree with space hitler?


Did you just refer to Bioware as Hitler because they didn't do what the fans said they should?

You don't have to buy their games if you don't want to.


I thought he was referring to the Catalyst?


Yah. I haven't slept all night as I work on final papers. Misread it as a nasty dig at Bioware. Completely my bad.


You writing them or grading them?
I'm supposed to be analyzing the development of new cultures from immigrants as portrayed in the media...instead I'm on bsn :ph34r:


I'm writing them. I had to write a linguistic study of Hemmingway's short fiction. I also finished up, a developmental psychology paper. They both have to get in for 5:00, and I'm basically alternating between writing and reading stuff on here.

I'm actually TAing starting next semester so I'll be grading soon though. Terrifying.

#1067
Mastermadskills

Mastermadskills
  • Members
  • 1 212 messages
Please.

Please lock the thread.

Every time I see it on the main, I start to wince.

#1068
jules_vern18

jules_vern18
  • Members
  • 799 messages
I've had some time to think about it, OP...and while I still don't get why this idea is such a big deal, the BSN should have the opportunity to vote on whether or not to do this before you move forward. While I think this may be funny, it's not worth doing if it's going to polarize this many people. People loved the cupcakes idea...you might just have to accept that this one wasn't as popular and tr again with something else.

#1069
Calbeb

Calbeb
  • Members
  • 407 messages

jules_vern18 wrote...

I've had some time to think about it, OP...and while I still don't get why this idea is such a big deal, the BSN should have the opportunity to vote on whether or not to do this before you move forward. While I think this may be funny, it's not worth doing if it's going to polarize this many people. People loved the cupcakes idea...you might just have to accept that this one wasn't as popular and tr again with something else.


The campaign has already been suspended.

Hold the Line decided it was a divisive idea and are holding off on it.

#1070
CrutchCricket

CrutchCricket
  • Members
  • 7 735 messages

Opsrbest wrote...
As for the legalities I don't know specifics but I do know that you can't outrightly purchase a new ending because of specific laws. I would think it has more to do with the intended nature of the donation it against what the donation could be used for and since Bioware could face legal reprecussions if even purchased the ending was unsatisfactory
to those who contributed, as well as for the group that would be contributing. Then theres the whole shareholders rights etc.

Hmm, maybe I'll have to look it up but so far all of this seems like it could be handled by a contract. Of course drafting a contract and having it checked by legal authorities would likely add even more to the cost.

It'd be crazy to consider under normal circumstances sure. But since the retake movement is dealing with organizing and fund raising on this level I don't think it'd be too much of a step up.

#1071
MaximusRex

MaximusRex
  • Members
  • 101 messages

John Epler wrote...

A) If you have nothing constructive to post, please don't post. You aren't adding anything to the board or the thread.

B) That being said, anyone who you'd hope to make aware of your concerns via this method is aware of your concerns. At the end of the day, though, it's your money, and you can certainly spend it however you'd like. But if you're trying to spread your message this is not going to do much more than waste 5$ from 1800 people. Again, though - it's your money.


I don't think the point is to spread the message to EA/BioWare, though maybe a billboard on the 101 where hundreds of thousands of communters will drive by it every day might make a different kind of point.  Something odd like that might even garner some kind of unwanted media attention.  

It could certainly change the point of view of someone if the debate were to move from the back pages of gamer websites to the evening news.  If I were the OP and I got this billboard up, I'd also do a Press Release to all the local newspapers and TV news channels.  It would be a longshot, but all the local stations are CNN affliates, and CNN loves to plaster stupid crap like this on their front page, which is a far cry from the back pages of Forbes.com or gamer sites.

#1072
prizm123

prizm123
  • Members
  • 427 messages
seriously? billboards?
.... talk about taking to an absurd extreme

#1073
Sp3c7eR

Sp3c7eR
  • Members
  • 325 messages
I'm part of Retake and I think this idea is taking it too far. Too aggressive in light of Bio's DLC announcement. As much as I dislike "clarification" that goes with a broken ending, I'm fully against the billboard idea, it's not an act worthy of our movement. So far we have expressed our displeasure with kind and heart-warming gestures and we have stayed civil. Let's keep future ideas in that imaginary track.

#1074
Jamie9

Jamie9
  • Members
  • 4 172 messages

Sp3c7eR wrote...

I'm part of Retake and I think this idea is taking it too far. Too aggressive in light of Bio's DLC announcement. As much as I dislike "clarification" that goes with a broken ending, I'm fully against the billboard idea, it's not an act worthy of our movement. So far we have expressed our displeasure with kind and heart-warming gestures and we have stayed civil. Let's keep future ideas in that imaginary track.


They've already stopped the billboard initiative. The OP just hasn't been updated yet because the OP isn't on BSN atm.

#1075
Goroxx

Goroxx
  • Members
  • 184 messages

KeilxKey wrote...

UPDATE 2: 

We're listenting to ALL OF YOUR concerns, and Micheal and me are discussing the best course to take with this. 



My lord...the irony in the above updated OP.   Bioware must be laughing their heads off.

I was proud to have been part of the Retake movement, and the initial charity drive.  

But this billboard crap is too far.  Congratulations for making the whole movement look bad.  Can't wait to see this show up in the press.  You must be very proud of yourselves.

If this is where the whole movement is heading, count me out.

Edited: just saw the last posts where they stopped the campaign.  Glad to see that they are getting rid of this thread so that the discussion can stop about it too.  /sarcasm.  

Modifié par Goroxx, 10 avril 2012 - 02:42 .