221 réponses à ce sujet

[SP2219]

 Thanks very much for doing this

[Soulstice88]

Great survey! Seems there's a lot of focus on what people dislike about the endings so far.

[twincast]

Honestly I would have felt more comfortable with the clarity of my ranking if all of the issues were to be ranked on a single list, but it's a neat effort anyway.

[ofish]

twincast wrote...

Honestly I would have felt more comfortable with the clarity of my ranking if all of the issues were to be ranked on a single list, but it's a neat effort anyway.

They will eventually all be weighted by the last questions overall ranking and put into a single list.

[The Mercenary55]

man tough survey, had issues with most of the points in it lol

[twincast]

ofish wrote...

They will eventually all be weighted by the last questions overall ranking and put into a single list.

Well, what I meant is that e.g. OTTOMH character epilogues are for me personally a nice bonus, but rank far below the other narrative, logic and Catalyst-based issues, while the other two in the narrative category are very close to, if not right at, the top. Hell, TBH for me all eight of my top issues from your lists fall under the same lore- and logic-defying deus ex machina brainfart category anyway, with the barely important decisions throughout the games being a second category and the lack of closure a third, so ranking all but the last of the proposed categories was really extremely hard for me.
I see valid reasons to separate them your way, but they just don't align with my personal perception.

Modifié par twincast, 12 avril 2012 - 12:12 .

[AwesomeDudex64]

Bumping

[MechaGaiden]

Very good survey, I think you got all the important points about the ending in there.

[Sable Phoenix]

This is a very impressive survey. The most impressive thing about it is that it's limited and focused, yet still complete enough to include all the major problems. It would be very easy to weigh this kind of survey down with dozens of options, which ultimately only muddies the waters. Keeping it to five questions with three or four options really brings the concerns of the community to a sharp focus.

[ofish]

Sable Phoenix wrote...

This is a very impressive survey. The most impressive thing about it is that it's limited and focused, yet still complete enough to include all the major problems. It would be very easy to weigh this kind of survey down with dozens of options, which ultimately only muddies the waters. Keeping it to five questions with three or four options really brings the concerns of the community to a sharp focus.

Thank you very much for the kind words.  Just finishing up some updated charts I will add them in a bit.

[ofish]

latest update on survey data

[ofish]

twincast wrote...

ofish wrote...

They will eventually all be weighted by the last questions overall ranking and put into a single list.

Well, what I meant is that e.g. OTTOMH character epilogues are for me personally a nice bonus, but rank far below the other narrative, logic and Catalyst-based issues, while the other two in the narrative category are very close to, if not right at, the top. Hell, TBH for me all eight of my top issues from your lists fall under the same lore- and logic-defying deus ex machina brainfart category anyway, with the barely important decisions throughout the games being a second category and the lack of closure a third, so ranking all but the last of the proposed categories was really extremely hard for me.
I see valid reasons to separate them your way, but they just don't align with my personal perception.

Thanks for the detailed response.  While it was intended to challenge you to make tough decisions regarding what you would prioritize as the #1 issue your problems go beyond that. I have been saving feedback regarding category layout and I will take this into consideration if we end up doing a redesign.

Modifié par ofish, 12 avril 2012 - 05:52 .

[swirlwind]

Interesting survey. Thank you for making it.

[milena87]

A very nice survey, thank you

[ioannisdenton]

bump for awesomeness

[ioannisdenton]

well? please all take the survey

[chris2365]

Send this to Bioware. They need all the feedback they can get, and this is excellent feecback, despite the smalll sample size

[DamonD7]

Done. Nice idea.

[BrutaleBent]

Done

[ioannisdenton]

bump this again. sorry but i think this would be very helpful and insightfull to bioware

[Delaney]

Done and good work! It was hard but hopefully it'll be helpful to BW.

[Noelemahc]

Done. Hope this helps.

[pika9519]

Those updates were interesting.

[ofish]

Thanks for all the kind words I think I am going to replace all of the "least important" pie charts in the first 4 with line graphs.
I am not sure if I should be waiting till I finish with the poll and just post pictures like above with the final data. I have the ability to give them the raw data in an excel table but have no idea where I would send that.

[Sesshaku]

Awesome survey, voted already.