435 réponses à ce sujet

[majinbuu1307]

  UPDATE- Although she states it is her opinion, she has clearly seen what they have in store and is in the loop. Her word is not god, but I will take it.




We don't see sky, or anything like that. I believe its the rubble from explosion he made when he shot up the...whatever the hell he was shooting at. Addition information-If you look at the picture at the bottom of this post, you will see the same cable from the citadel near shepard when he takes a breath.

One of the bioware employees(forget which someone help with this?) stated that we don't actually see the citadel fully explode and to expect most of the people(main characters) on it to have survived. We do however see it come apart. But that thing is HUGE and probably capable of sustaining people even in seperate peices for a while.

That being said- Indoctrination theory is already out of the window, so this is the best explanation and better than he survived reentry and hitting the ground which im sure they know is rediculous. Shepard is still on the citadel, heres to hoping the Extended Cut DLC shows and explains this(Jessica also says meeting up with our LI is a possibility) so only in destroy ending.


P.S. I need some proof that EDI has been shown to be alive in some destroy endings. Videos please? This gives me hope that the Geth are alive somehow since Shepard has synthetic parts in him and he is alive, so the Catalyst could have been wrong on the effects on the Geth somehow. Destroy ending would be the perfect ending then. That and all those dead reapers probably contain tech that could lead to new relays if everyone worked together. Cheers.


To sum up,
FACT-Shepard IS alive. File on PC vesion says Shepalive.avi or something like that.
FACT-They are sticking with their current ending, meaning Indoctrination is WRONG, he did actually get to the Citadel. Let go of them Emergency Induction Ports
FACT-Employees have even said that Shepard could possibly meet up with LI and CREW. Kinda hard if you INCINERATED on the way back to earth on reentry and countless miles of falling and thuding on the ground. 




Furthermore, I'm repeating myself, but it must be made clear...in order for SHEPARD TO BE IN LONDON ONE OF THE TWO REDICULOUS THINGS HAVE TO BE TRUE.

1-Shepard was indoctrinated. Incomplete game, reapers still around. No.
2-shepard flew off the citadel survived being incinerated and the 200 or so miles to the ground.

OR. he survived ONE explosion, got thrown back, and had rubble including a cable from that hall with the bodies in it fall around him.

Hmm... logic...

Modifié par majinbuu1307, 12 avril 2012 - 06:33 .

[majinbuu1307]

bump because of forum speed- props to the other shepard in citadel rubble thread i just saw lol

[majinbuu1307]

2nd bump

[legion999]

Concrete. There is none on the Citadel. And when did Shepard end up in these sealed off areas? And why didn't he bleed out? Also wouldn't kilometre sized debris falling into Earth destroy large areas of it? Wait if the Citadels a mass relay does that mean Earth will be covered in Element Zero?

And no blue tint doesn't mean anything. He could have landed in thousands of different locations.

Modifié par legion999, 11 avril 2012 - 01:12 .

[The_Shootist]

legion999 wrote...

Concrete. There is none on the Citadel. And when did Shepard end up in these sealed off areas? And why didn't he bleed out? Also wouldn't kilometre sized debris falling into Earth destroy large areas of it? Wait if the Citadels a mass relay does that mean teh Earth will be covered in Element Zero?

'cause he's made of Reaper tech.

[majinbuu1307]

legion999 wrote...

Concrete. There is none on the Citadel. And when did Shepard end up in these sealed off areas? And why didn't he bleed out? Also wouldn't kilometre sized debris falling into Earth destroy large areas of it? Wait if the Citadels a mass relay does that mean Earth will be covered in Element Zero?

And no blue tint doesn't mean anything. He could have landed in thousands of different locations.

They didn't say it fell to earth. Could be floating up there in orbit like a disabled Internation space station. Eventually falling but probably has time.

Also he didn't bleed out cuz he's shepard.

[Zardoc]

The_Shootist wrote...

legion999 wrote...

Concrete. There is none on the Citadel. And when did Shepard end up in these sealed off areas? And why didn't he bleed out? Also wouldn't kilometre sized debris falling into Earth destroy large areas of it? Wait if the Citadels a mass relay does that mean teh Earth will be covered in Element Zero?

'cause he's made of Reaper tech.

Yeah, no. That's not it. Nice try though.

[majinbuu1307]

Zardoc wrote...

The_Shootist wrote...

legion999 wrote...

Concrete. There is none on the Citadel. And when did Shepard end up in these sealed off areas? And why didn't he bleed out? Also wouldn't kilometre sized debris falling into Earth destroy large areas of it? Wait if the Citadels a mass relay does that mean teh Earth will be covered in Element Zero?

'cause he's made of Reaper tech.

Yeah, no. That's not it. Nice try though.

Eh he may be bleeding but not to death. See Nathan Drake in Uncharted 2. Shot in the gut, bleeding forever, lives.

[FatalX7.0]

Zaeed got shot in the face and lived. And Shepard already died once and all it did was ****** him off.

I could see the rubble being the crap that he shot at in the destroy ending. All burnt and scorched, kind of a stone/rocky look.

But just speculation for everyonesssss.

[majinbuu1307]

So far my "speculations" are the geth made it since shepard did and the catalyst just couldn't calculate EVERYTHING.

[majinbuu1307]

FatalX7.0 wrote...

Zaeed got shot in the face and lived. And Shepard already died once and all it did was ****** him off.

I could see the rubble being the crap that he shot at in the destroy ending. All burnt and scorched, kind of a stone/rocky look.

But just speculation for everyonesssss.

It's the only logical explanation really. The whole, reentry or indoctrination stuff...no.

This makes sense.

[legion999]

majinbuu1307 wrote...

legion999 wrote...

Concrete. There is none on the Citadel. And when did Shepard end up in these sealed off areas? And why didn't he bleed out? Also wouldn't kilometre sized debris falling into Earth destroy large areas of it? Wait if the Citadels a mass relay does that mean Earth will be covered in Element Zero?

And no blue tint doesn't mean anything. He could have landed in thousands of different locations.

They didn't say it fell to earth. Could be floating up there in orbit like a disabled Internation space station. Eventually falling but probably has time.

Also he didn't bleed out cuz he's shepard.

The Citadel exploded large chunks of it will head to Earth. And still how did Shepard survive the blood loss, tube explosion, Citadel explosion, red beam, the vacuum of space and the burns from Harbinger's ray? And re-entry and impact (if the likely thing happens and the Citadel falls towards Earth)?

[AlienSpaceBats]

The rubble looks like London.
I'm imagining Shepard somehow got knocked into the beam that zipped him/her up there, or that plain ol' SPACE MAGIC© was involved.

[Shallyah]

Why are people trying to find logical explanation to why Shepard lives after they've been travelling with blue aliens that can have babies only thinking of it? It doesn't have to make sense, it's Sci-Fi. Could have three dozens of explanations as to why Shepard survived the bleeding. Afterall, he had just survived a direct Reaper Beam impact which we saw tearing cruisers appart.

It's true Shepard might be in the Citadel, I read twits from Bioware staff members saying that even a fraction of the Citadel could probably maintain Life Support systems and own atmosphere, though we'll have to wait for Extended DLC to really know.

Modifié par Shallyah, 11 avril 2012 - 01:26 .

[majinbuu1307]

Something in orbit would not crash to earth right away also

[majinbuu1307]

AlienSpaceBats wrote...

The rubble looks like London.
I'm imagining Shepard somehow got knocked into the beam that zipped him/her up there, or that plain ol' SPACE MAGIC© was involved.

how can you tell london rubble from citadel rubble, its blown up and burnt, plus I don't see the blue glow from the beam needed to believe he was indoctrinated, i refuse REENTRY lol

[majinbuu1307]

Shallyah wrote...

Why are people trying to find logical explanation to why Shepard lives after they've been travelling with blue aliens that can have babies only thinking of it?

It doesn't have to make sense, it's Sci-Fi. It's true Shepard might be in the Citadel, I read twits from Bioware staff members saying that even a fraction of the Citadel could probably maintain Life Support systems and own atmosphere, though we'll have to wait for Extended DLC to really know.

Thank you thats what I was getting at lol, as I said, we dont see it fully explode, could probably maintain life support, people like aria still alive etc, would take a long while for it to drift out of orbit and crash to earth, by that time methods could be in place to try and move it.

[FatalX7.0]

majinbuu1307 wrote...

Something in orbit would not crash to earth right away also

Yeah, that'd take some time.

And it'd also be even more burnt up, scorched and broken.

[majinbuu1307]

legion999 wrote...

majinbuu1307 wrote...

legion999 wrote...

Concrete. There is none on the Citadel. And when did Shepard end up in these sealed off areas? And why didn't he bleed out? Also wouldn't kilometre sized debris falling into Earth destroy large areas of it? Wait if the Citadels a mass relay does that mean Earth will be covered in Element Zero?

And no blue tint doesn't mean anything. He could have landed in thousands of different locations.

They didn't say it fell to earth. Could be floating up there in orbit like a disabled Internation space station. Eventually falling but probably has time.

Also he didn't bleed out cuz he's shepard.

The Citadel exploded large chunks of it will head to Earth. And still how did Shepard survive the blood loss, tube explosion, Citadel explosion, red beam, the vacuum of space and the burns from Harbinger's ray? And re-entry and impact (if the likely thing happens and the Citadel falls towards Earth)?

Harbingers ray did NOT hit him dead on, probably get hit by the shockwave of it like he did in the beggining before you find the kid in the duct.
also, he survived the small explosion he made, garrus survived a rocket to the face, nuff said.

[FatalX7.0]

AlienSpaceBats wrote...

The rubble looks like London.
I'm imagining Shepard somehow got knocked into the beam that zipped him/her up there, or that plain ol' SPACE MAGIC© was involved.

Normandy Bathroom looks like my Bathroom.


But it's not my bathroom.

[FatalX7.0]

majinbuu1307 wrote...

legion999 wrote...

majinbuu1307 wrote...

legion999 wrote...

Concrete. There is none on the Citadel. And when did Shepard end up in these sealed off areas? And why didn't he bleed out? Also wouldn't kilometre sized debris falling into Earth destroy large areas of it? Wait if the Citadels a mass relay does that mean Earth will be covered in Element Zero?

And no blue tint doesn't mean anything. He could have landed in thousands of different locations.

They didn't say it fell to earth. Could be floating up there in orbit like a disabled Internation space station. Eventually falling but probably has time.

Also he didn't bleed out cuz he's shepard.

The Citadel exploded large chunks of it will head to Earth. And still how did Shepard survive the blood loss, tube explosion, Citadel explosion, red beam, the vacuum of space and the burns from Harbinger's ray? And re-entry and impact (if the likely thing happens and the Citadel falls towards Earth)?

Harbingers ray did NOT hit him dead on, probably get hit by the shockwave of it like he did in the beggining before you find the kid in the duct.
also, he survived the small explosion he made, garrus survived a rocket to the face, nuff said.

"Rage is a hell of an anesthetic."

[majinbuu1307]

FatalX7.0 wrote...

majinbuu1307 wrote...

legion999 wrote...

majinbuu1307 wrote...

legion999 wrote...

Concrete. There is none on the Citadel. And when did Shepard end up in these sealed off areas? And why didn't he bleed out? Also wouldn't kilometre sized debris falling into Earth destroy large areas of it? Wait if the Citadels a mass relay does that mean Earth will be covered in Element Zero?

And no blue tint doesn't mean anything. He could have landed in thousands of different locations.

They didn't say it fell to earth. Could be floating up there in orbit like a disabled Internation space station. Eventually falling but probably has time.

Also he didn't bleed out cuz he's shepard.

The Citadel exploded large chunks of it will head to Earth. And still how did Shepard survive the blood loss, tube explosion, Citadel explosion, red beam, the vacuum of space and the burns from Harbinger's ray? And re-entry and impact (if the likely thing happens and the Citadel falls towards Earth)?

Harbingers ray did NOT hit him dead on, probably get hit by the shockwave of it like he did in the beggining before you find the kid in the duct.
also, he survived the small explosion he made, garrus survived a rocket to the face, nuff said.

"Rage is a hell of an anesthetic."

This:) or his love for ASH:D

[FatalX7.0]

Also, his synthetic implants made his body much more durable.

Modifié par FatalX7.0, 11 avril 2012 - 01:31 .

[majinbuu1307]

FatalX7.0 wrote...

Also, his synthetic implants made his body much more durable.

They didn't get destroyed either, so I'm assuming the geth are also alive, yup yup.

[Elite Midget]

No, he dies. His skin was fried with worse than 3rd degree burns and he was bleeding out. Without immediate and intense medical aid he's going to die a very slow and painful death.