142 réponses à ce sujet

[Mcfly616]

spyridontrilogy wrote...

In fairness, had Joss written ME3, everyone--EVERYONE--would have died. The universe would have ceased to exist in the final image of the game.

I'm pretty sure that's what happened anyways lol....everybody that survived the relays exploding is going to die a very slow and hopeless death

[Apathy1989]

sammysoso wrote...

Joss is pure genius

Bring back Firefly!!!

Sorry but Dollhouse > Firefly. 


If Joss had written ME3, it would have ended with Garrus betraying shepard, joker getting a spike in the chest, your love interest getting processed, but everyone else surviving to defeat the reapers.

[KingZayd]

spyridontrilogy wrote...

In fairness, had Joss written ME3, everyone--EVERYONE--would have died. The universe would have ceased to exist in the final image of the game.

That would be fine.. as long as it made sense and old Joss has been reliable in the past


and yeah Joss has said it perfectly. 

Also Firefly>Dollhouse.

Dollhouse had potential and i did enjoy it, but wow the ending was rushed. Fox's fault of course.

Modifié par KingZayd, 17 avril 2012 - 05:13 .

[GorrilaKing]

spyridontrilogy wrote...

In fairness, had Joss written ME3, everyone--EVERYONE--would have died. The universe would have ceased to exist in the final image of the game.

Yeah but somehow it would have been a fitting end. Unlike certain other people (*cough*Mac and Casey*cough*) the man knows how to end a great story.

[Mr Indivisible]

Apathy1989 wrote...

sammysoso wrote...

Joss is pure genius

Bring back Firefly!!!

Sorry but Dollhouse > Firefly. 

Hahahahahahaha.

I had to get that off my chest, good laugh.

Whedon is right though, Art is not yours as the artist, its everyone elses. Its this fact that makes so many artists angsty and upset, because in releasing 'art' to the public, you lose all control over it.

The Artist's interpretation is merely a touch point, something for others to say, huh, thats what the artist was trying to do. Really it has no impact on how they perceive the art, and it shouldn't. Otherwise it wouldn't be art, because it wouldn't speak to you. In more interactive mediums, art can take a life of its own and bite the artist in the ass.

[Edrick1976]

Wonder if they will be locking this thread sence its not related to ME 3 in anyway... seams to be what they are doing....

[Wowlock]

spyridontrilogy wrote...

In fairness, had Joss written ME3, everyone--EVERYONE--would have died. The universe would have ceased to exist in the final image of the game.

STILL a better ending than what we have >_>

[Victia]

Sisterofshane wrote...

spyridontrilogy wrote...

M0keys wrote...

spyridontrilogy wrote...

In fairness, had Joss written ME3, everyone--EVERYONE--would have died. The universe would have ceased to exist in the final image of the game.

Funny enough, Whedon's material almost always ends happily or hopefully. People can die in the long run, but it always ends on an "up" one way or another.

AFAIK, anyway. Even Angel ended hopefully or bravely.

Really?  Whedon's kind of known as the king of unhappy endings...a bit hopeful, but definitely not happy.  I think the "up" you mean is more of a "Well, gotta keep truckin' since we're all gonna die eventually."

And, to be frank, a completely dark ending would have fit with ME3.
I for one would have liked to lose to the Reapers, and have the final cutscene be some civilization somewhere in the future finding Liara's data Cache with information on Shepard and the Reapers.  Bittersweet ending - bitter that we lost, but sweet that the next cycle may find their only hope in us.

I loved the ending to Angel (imho one of the best endings to a tv series ever) - to me it was a happy ending if not in the conventional sence but there was something very uplifting and that made me smile when I saw it for the first time and infact even when I see it now! And I would have been happy if not frustrated if ME3 had done the same but I would not have been upset.

I would have liked there to be a loose to the reapers option, and the so called 'disney' ending (even if I disagree with the fact that it could ever be a disney ending with so much death and chaos), I think the one thing that JW has always been so good at is reading his audiance and producing an ending (when he has been allowed to) that fits with both the themes of the show and the viewer expectations - ie angel was darker, more mature and almost hopeless than buffy therefor the ending reflected that! And this is what bioware failed to do even if we had a forced ending it should have been in keeping with ME's themes and fan expectations.

Anyho I digress basically Joss Whedon = yay

[Mojenator12345]

CharlesdeTalleyrand wrote...

For a while, I thought it would be great if Firefly could be continued in video game form, hopefully made by BioWare with Joss Whedon as Lead Writer. Not so much anymore. But, who knows, maybe BioWare can reclaim its former glory. Either way, I think Firefly would be best continued in video game form.

I would still pay a lot for a Joss-written BW-style game, whether it's Firefly or something else.  Particularly if the protaganist is voice-acted by Nathan Fillion.  And maybe with Neil Patrick Harris playing the trusty sidekick.  

[Sifr]

At least with Joss you KNOW someone is likely going to die and it'll be a poweful punch to the gut.

Not a disappointing and collective kick in the quad.

Modifié par Sifr1449, 17 avril 2012 - 05:55 .

[Garlador]

spyridontrilogy wrote...

In fairness, had Joss written ME3, everyone--EVERYONE--would have died. The universe would have ceased to exist in the final image of the game.

But it would've made sense, given closure, and everyone would've gone out in an awesome blaze of glory that makes the Spartans in 300 seem lame by comparison.

[Jeb231]

The end of Angel was pretty cool. BSN would have hated it.

[JackofStaves]

Sifr1449 wrote...

At least with Joss you KNOW someone is likely going to die and it'll be a poweful punch to the gut.

Not a disappointing and collective kick in the quad.

Except when Buffy's mother died.

Completely did not see that coming at all....and it was one of the most disturbing, powerful episodes they had.

I think ME reaches that, in parts, but the end doesn't really get there....

[shrimprahmen]

spyridontrilogy wrote...

In fairness, had Joss written ME3, everyone--EVERYONE--would have died. The universe would have ceased to exist in the final image of the game.

and that would have been awesome compared to what we got.

[Nightwriter]

Jeb231 wrote...

The end of Angel was pretty cool. BSN would have hated it.

I didn't particularly care for it, but it inspired nowhere near the level of horror and disaste I felt for ME3's ending.

[DoktorAffentanz]

Opsrbest wrote...

So since Bioware has been ignoring people, is that a form of child abuse?

This! So friggin' This!!

Cause I think it's so true

[Ziggeh]

DoktorAffentanz wrote...

Opsrbest wrote...

So since Bioware has been ignoring people, is that a form of child abuse?

This! So friggin' This!!

Cause I think it's so true

wut?

[PrinceHamlet82]

spyridontrilogy wrote...

In fairness, had Joss written ME3, everyone--EVERYONE--would have died. The universe would have ceased to exist in the final image of the game.

And that would have been ok, because it would have been done well, because its Joss. But I would argue that you're over exagerating, Joss's work tends to have only some sacrifice in it, and actually true bittersweet endings. (here's looking at you Serenity).

[Skyline45]

Hexley UK wrote...

sammysoso wrote...

Joss is pure genius

Bring back Firefly!!!

And Buffy, and Angel, and Dollhouse.....

Buffy and Angle where crap. Dollhouse was eh, but Firefly.... now that show was kick ass xD

[Iakus]

Nightwriter wrote...

Jeb231 wrote...

The end of Angel was pretty cool. BSN would have hated it.

I didn't particularly care for it, but it inspired nowhere near the level of horror and disaste I felt for ME3's ending.

Indeed.

I know people who didn't like how it ended, but I was generally okay with it.  There was sadness, and stuff unresolved, but Angel was still doing what he did best:  fighting evil and helping the helpless.  The story continued, we just weren't there to see it.

ME3 left me not sure I want to see how the story continues, even assuming this isn't the end.

[billida]

damn, i miss Buffy and Angel so much. Whedon knows how to tell a story.

[Iakus]

Skyline45 wrote...

Hexley UK wrote...

sammysoso wrote...

Joss is pure genius

Bring back Firefly!!!

And Buffy, and Angel, and Dollhouse.....

Buffy and Angle where crap. Dollhouse was eh, but Firefly.... now that show was kick ass xD

The Operative: Are you willing to die for your beliefs?
Capt. Malcolm Reynolds[/b]: I am...
[they draw. Mal fires first, and the Operative is forced to take cover[/i]]
Capt. Malcolm Reynolds[/b]: 'Course, that ain't exactly plan A.

yeah Bioware could have learned a thing or two from Firefly...

[humes spork]

Has someone mentioned Joker getting impaled in the chest yet? Because I think that's important.

[zarnk567]

I do miss Firefly......

[Enhanced]

This isn't directly related to ME3 story and campaign, is it? Why hasn't this thread been closed?