1087 réponses à ce sujet

[napushenko]

slyguy200 wrote...

napushenko wrote...

me 3 is my game of the year (for now) because i enjoyed it tremendously except the ending and its my favourite in the series.

You mean you liked the crappy quest system, crappy eavesdropping missions, scanning, auto-dialog, etc.?

same as liked i crappy mineral scanning, no vertical combat,  crappy level design with all boxes, crappy mercenaries everywhere, much less dialogue, etc in me 2 and crappy generic mountains, crappy same generic areas in side missions, mhm, crappy loads of useless weapons etc in me 1. 
they didnt make me hate the game, why should some minimal things like that crappy journal planet clicking which is better then me 2 crappy planet clicking make me hate the game ? 
and auto-dialog was great, felt movie like, besides, every important conversation had dialogue tree. and im willing to bet that number of times you can use dialogue tree was about the same as in me 1. 

besides, you can just put crappy journal for eavesdrop quests- missions scanning, cause is the same thing. and a lil bit better then crappy mineral scanning. same thing again. 

i dont know how your sensible taste managed to recieve all that crappines in first two parts. i didnt mind them, so. 

Modifié par napushenko, 21 mai 2012 - 06:01 .

[Oldbones2]

Mole267 wrote...

I had high hopes for Mass Effect 3. Most of the game lived up to my expectations, but there were things that never came to fruition that I was really expecting.

Remember getting the message from the Rachni queen on Illium, and she said "we shall burn the darkness clean"?

To me, that suggested the Rachni would serve a more direct and obvious role in the fight against the reapers. The rachni were a major story point in the game, I mean, you encounter the SAME queen in all 3 games.

You didn't get back most of your squadmates... I was hoping for at least Wrex.

Then the wonky ending. From what I have seen, the ending is pretty much hated universally. Like 80-90% hate, 10-20% like.

IF the ending had just made more sense while still being the same ending, I think it would've been much better received. The ending was sloppy and maybe even seemed a bit rushed. Hopefully the DLC will make it better, I have my fingers crossed. BioWare still a great developer with a great history of games (excluding DA2 and ToR), and I haven't really given up on them. I paid nearly $90 after tax for my CE of Mass Effect 3, and considering I haven't touched the game in over a month now I am starting to regret buying it. I figured it'd be like ME2, which I put 260 hours into. And I paid $49.99 on Steam for that one.

ME3 should've set its stages better, and should've remained more cohesive at the end. What if some anti-Reaper machine or organic race showed up near the end, instead of having to rely on a "catalyst" ending? Even though it still would've been a deus ex machina ending, it would've just made more sense and not gone all wonky.

Anyway, I kinda got off my own topic, but I think ME3 should have been GOTY worthy. Why did they compromise so much?

I don't think it will end up being GOTY, unless the extended cut DLC is received to great praise. Even still, an at least $70 game, and they have to do an extended cut DLC... Just shows sloppiness all around. It probably won't end up making GOTY. Even though it deserved it.

I think Max Payne 3 might be GOTY material tho.

Fans will say no.  Critics will choose between this and Bioshock.

[Izhalezan]

No, I was bored out of my mind not even a 1/4 in. And the ending sure didn't help with that.

[SwitchN7]

Besides the ending(Cpt. Obvious to save the day) it deserves every praise and should be awarded the GOTY.

Modifié par SwitchN7, 21 mai 2012 - 06:15 .

[D24O]

We still have half a year to go, IMO its not a good idea to start throwing this around so early.

[Ryuukishi]

n/m

Modifié par Ryuukishi, 21 mai 2012 - 06:18 .

[Atakuma]

That would imply that the GOTY title has any actual worth. It's just a way for video game publications to suck up to whatever the most popular game was that year.

[Critchley2010]

Even with the incomplete ending it's still one of, if not the best, games I have ever played, so yes. I've actually got really high hopes for the EC.

[Maias227]

Hopefully!

[Ghost]

ME3 in my mind is GOTY material too bad that Bioshock Infinite and Tomb Raider got delayed.

Modifié par Ghost1017, 21 mai 2012 - 06:44 .

[RiouHotaru]

 Of course it's GOTY-worthy.

ME2 got GOTY and according to the BSN it was full of mistakes, problems, and plotholes.

[Haiyato]

ME3 is a good game, but I don't think its worthy to be GOTY.

[LKx]

Unfortunately, even ignoring the endings, it doesn't deserve the GOTY.
It's good, but not that good.
Even if it have some moments of excellence, it's rushed under a lot of aspects, and overall it doesn't even live up to ME2.

[Joecos]

No way. But you can bet your ass that some magazine like GameInformer will say it is. I loved ME1 and ME2 but ME3 was just garbage made to cater to several audiences but ultimatley failed where it mattered the most. In retrospect the first two games weren't perfect but they were a lot better! 

Now another thing is I always hear that the Multiplayer isn't that bad "blah blah blah". I personally abhor it. I've played as an Adept to Level 20 for about 15 or so hours. The EMS decays WAY to quickly, all the RNG uprgrades and extra race uprgrades being random are so frustrating on so many levels ( What were the Developers thinking? ) and it's so boring that I just want to fall asleep. It's the same damn thing! 

Now about the ending...What the hell were they thinking? The worst ending in ME2 when Shep dies at the end of the Collector Base was leagues above the "Space Magic" garbage. Such a terrible way to end an otherwise great series.

So no GOTY in my honest opinion.

Modifié par Joecos, 21 mai 2012 - 07:27 .

[Yakko77]

Skyrim got GOTY, bugs and all so I guess ME3 can get it even with a craptacular ending.

[Ninja Mage]

Hell no.mas effect is like a big juicy red apple and when u take the final bite u taste part of a night green worm and realize u just ate a rotten apple

[chengthao]

Oldbones2 wrote...

Fans will say no.  Critics will choose between this and Bioshock.

or Halo 4 or COD56 or COD Black Ops 2 (whoops i mean "MW2")