1087 réponses à ce sujet

[TheHugoGamer]

Yes, it does. IF, and only IF, the extended cut fixes the ending.

[TMZuk]

Not by a long shot, but who cares? Reviews means nothing, and neither does GOTY anymore.

[Getorex]

No.

It is worthy of "Most disappointing game of 2012" but not GOTY.

Vote for MDGOTY! It is a solid winner in that catagory!

Also, the year hasn't ended yet.  Good games (with proper, logical endings) can come out before the end of the year.  For instance, Half Life 2: Episode 3 is coming out later this year.  Half Life will ALWAYS be a GOTY-worthy game series.  Episode 3 will easily best ME3.  

The only thing HF is missing at this point is the abiltiy to interact with the other characters in a more RPG-ish mode.  It wasn't setup that way initially but it would be great to take it there.  You can be absolutely certain there will be NO Red, Blue, or Green ending!  That is GOTY-worthy in itself!

Modifié par Getorex, 21 mai 2012 - 09:19 .

[What a Succulent Ass]

Lol. No.

And that's without considering the ending butthurt firestorm.

[gert56nom]

99% of the game is great I liked MA3 so much I purchased MA2.

unfortunatly this just highlighted how disapointing the ending of MA3 is

please have a decent extended cut

[What a Succulent Ass]

gert56nom wrote...

99% of the game is great I liked MA3 so much I purchased MA2.

unfortunatly this just highlighted how disapointing the ending of MA3 is

please have a decent extended cut

I'm assuming this means you haven't played ME1.

[dmonorato]

Not just hell no but hell fu**ing no....

[MerchantGOL]

Yakko77 wrote...

Skyrim got GOTY, bugs and all so I guess ME3 can get it even with a craptacular ending.

Truesst thing said in this thread so far.

[Sajji]

MerchantGOL wrote...

Yakko77 wrote...

Skyrim got GOTY, bugs and all so I guess ME3 can get it even with a craptacular ending.

Truesst thing said in this thread so far.

Mass Effect 3 was also plagued with bugs. It just happened to be 300 times smaller.

[MerchantGOL]

Sajji wrote...

MerchantGOL wrote...

Yakko77 wrote...

Skyrim got GOTY, bugs and all so I guess ME3 can get it even with a craptacular ending.

Truesst thing said in this thread so far.

Mass Effect 3 was also plagued with bugs. It just happened to be 300 times smaller.

the only major bug ive have encounterd was the fall through the floor glitch in multiplayer


Where as in Skyrim i cant absorb dragon souls or shouts/ I enmeise dont see me/ and of course the infamous Saved game destroyer.

[Icinix]

Its a pretty good game, but it just doesn't feel like game of the year material - game of the year needs to have a game that is not necessarily flawless from start to finish, but it needs to suck you in, keep you engaged and feeling totally satisfied when the end credits roll up.

I just don't think ME3 has that.

Certainly a contender though.

[spirosz]

Knowing critics, probably. Knowing fans, probably not.

[MerchantGOL]

Icinix wrote...

Its a pretty good game, but it just doesn't feel like game of the year material - game of the year needs to have a game that is not necessarily flawless from start to finish, but it needs to suck you in, keep you engaged and feeling totally satisfied when the end credits roll up.

I just don't think ME3 has that.

Certainly a contender though.

hate to beat the dead horse, but skyrim won last year and it didn't do any of that for me.

where as ME3 is a game that makes grown men cry like babies, like or don't like the ending,its few games that can acomplish some thing like that.

[Icinix]

MerchantGOL wrote...

Icinix wrote...

Its a pretty good game, but it just doesn't feel like game of the year material - game of the year needs to have a game that is not necessarily flawless from start to finish, but it needs to suck you in, keep you engaged and feeling totally satisfied when the end credits roll up.

I just don't think ME3 has that.

Certainly a contender though.

hate to beat the dead horse, but skyrim won last year and it didn't do any of that for me.

where as ME3 is a game that makes grown men cry like babies, like or don't like the ending,its few games that can acomplish some thing like that.

Oh for sure, but being able to pull a few heart strings probably isn't enough to push it over the line.

[MerchantGOL]

Icinix wrote...

MerchantGOL wrote...

Icinix wrote...

Its a pretty good game, but it just doesn't feel like game of the year material - game of the year needs to have a game that is not necessarily flawless from start to finish, but it needs to suck you in, keep you engaged and feeling totally satisfied when the end credits roll up.

I just don't think ME3 has that.

Certainly a contender though.

hate to beat the dead horse, but skyrim won last year and it didn't do any of that for me.

where as ME3 is a game that makes grown men cry like babies, like or don't like the ending,its few games that can acomplish some thing like that.

Oh for sure, but being able to pull a few heart strings probably isn't enough to push it over the line.

But those heart stings couldnt be pulled if you weren't sucked in and engaged.

[Icinix]

MerchantGOL wrote...

Icinix wrote...

MerchantGOL wrote...

Icinix wrote...

Its a pretty good game, but it just doesn't feel like game of the year material - game of the year needs to have a game that is not necessarily flawless from start to finish, but it needs to suck you in, keep you engaged and feeling totally satisfied when the end credits roll up.

I just don't think ME3 has that.

Certainly a contender though.

hate to beat the dead horse, but skyrim won last year and it didn't do any of that for me.

where as ME3 is a game that makes grown men cry like babies, like or don't like the ending,its few games that can acomplish some thing like that.

Oh for sure, but being able to pull a few heart strings probably isn't enough to push it over the line.

But those heart stings couldnt be pulled if you weren't sucked in and engaged.

Not necessarily - I've seen people get misty at TV commercials they catch out the corner of their eye.

..but its not just one or two scenes that need to suck you in, its the whole game - and most critic reviews and fan reviews lean towards that for Skyrim. Where the line for ME3 is more along it being entertaining as opposed to being involving.  Either way, we'll have to wait and see. There are a lot of games coming out this year, so who knows what we'll get.

[MerchantGOL]

Icinix wrote...

MerchantGOL wrote...

Icinix wrote...

MerchantGOL wrote...

Icinix wrote...

Its a pretty good game, but it just doesn't feel like game of the year material - game of the year needs to have a game that is not necessarily flawless from start to finish, but it needs to suck you in, keep you engaged and feeling totally satisfied when the end credits roll up.

I just don't think ME3 has that.

Certainly a contender though.

hate to beat the dead horse, but skyrim won last year and it didn't do any of that for me.

where as ME3 is a game that makes grown men cry like babies, like or don't like the ending,its few games that can acomplish some thing like that.

Oh for sure, but being able to pull a few heart strings probably isn't enough to push it over the line.

But those heart stings couldnt be pulled if you weren't sucked in and engaged.

Not necessarily - I've seen people get misty at TV commercials they catch out the corner of their eye.

..but its not just one or two scenes that need to suck you in, its the whole game - and most critic reviews and fan reviews lean towards that for Skyrim. Where the line for ME3 is more along it being entertaining as opposed to being involving.  Either way, we'll have to wait and see. There are a lot of games coming out this year, so who knows what we'll get.

True enough, I think the only real contender outside of ME3 is Halo thogh. Some people say tomb raider and Max payne but i hav emy doubts for various reasons.

[shepskisaac]

MerchantGOL wrote...
True enough, I think the only real contender outside of ME3 is Halo thogh. Some people say tomb raider and Max payne but i hav emy doubts for various reasons.

Max Payne 3 is already out and neither fans nor critics are praising it very highly so it's out of the GOTY race. Tomb Raider and Bioshock Infinite got delayed till 2013.

EC will decide whether ME3 will be a heavy contender to GOTY or not.

Modifié par IsaacShep, 22 mai 2012 - 03:57 .

[Icinix]

MerchantGOL wrote...

Icinix wrote...

MerchantGOL wrote...

Icinix wrote...

MerchantGOL wrote...

Icinix wrote...

Its a pretty good game, but it just doesn't feel like game of the year material - game of the year needs to have a game that is not necessarily flawless from start to finish, but it needs to suck you in, keep you engaged and feeling totally satisfied when the end credits roll up.

I just don't think ME3 has that.

Certainly a contender though.

hate to beat the dead horse, but skyrim won last year and it didn't do any of that for me.

where as ME3 is a game that makes grown men cry like babies, like or don't like the ending,its few games that can acomplish some thing like that.

Oh for sure, but being able to pull a few heart strings probably isn't enough to push it over the line.

But those heart stings couldnt be pulled if you weren't sucked in and engaged.

Not necessarily - I've seen people get misty at TV commercials they catch out the corner of their eye.

..but its not just one or two scenes that need to suck you in, its the whole game - and most critic reviews and fan reviews lean towards that for Skyrim. Where the line for ME3 is more along it being entertaining as opposed to being involving.  Either way, we'll have to wait and see. There are a lot of games coming out this year, so who knows what we'll get.

True enough, I think the only real contender outside of ME3 is Halo thogh. Some people say tomb raider and Max payne but i hav emy doubts for various reasons.

Yeah, I'm in a similar boat. TR and MP haven't really got me interested (I was a huge fan of the first two Max Paynes and this one is..meh, not doing it for me) - but Halo. Yeah, I'm really interested to see where they go with that.

[MerchantGOL]

IsaacShep wrote...

MerchantGOL wrote...
True enough, I think the only real contender outside of ME3 is Halo thogh. Some people say tomb raider and Max payne but i hav emy doubts for various reasons.

Max Payne 3 is already out and neither fans nor critics are praising it very highly so it's out of the GOTY race. Tomb Raider and Bioshock Infinite got delayed till 2013.

EC will decide whether ME3 will be a heavy contender to GOTY or not.

I knew max Payne was gonna be mediocore.

[Dont Kaidan Me]

If you are putting your emotions aside when voting, then I don't possibly see how it could be worthy.

The bugs alone would disqualify it, I'd think (or at least it should).

[shepskisaac]

Icinix wrote...

Yeah, I'm in a similar boat. TR and MP haven't really got me interested (I was a huge fan of the first two Max Paynes and this one is..meh, not doing it for me) - but Halo. Yeah, I'm really interested to see where they go with that.

MP3 never looked any ultra special, but Tomb Raider reboot was Top 5 at last E3. 2013 GOTY will probably be between GTA5, Tomb Raider and Bioshock Infinite. Maybe The Last of Us too if it's extremly good (because zombie's attack surely ain't exciting nor fresh idea, especially this generation)

[MerchantGOL]

Dont Kaidan Me wrote...

If you are putting your emotions aside when voting, then I don't possibly see how it could be worthy.

The bugs alone would disqualify it, I'd think (or at least it should).

Skyrim says hi.

The game play and story is a hell of allot better then the previous GOTY, and it dosent have half the bugs and the bugs it dose have are minor.

Modifié par MerchantGOL, 22 mai 2012 - 04:06 .