1087 réponses à ce sujet

[dirtdiver32318]

Hell yes its GOTY worthy the game is fantasic even if you think the last 20 mins or so was blah. The game up to that point was great and i personally enjoyed the expierence...

[The fool you should have eaten]

So the points that I mentioned don't bother you at all?

[Nightingale]

Terror_K wrote...

chris2365 wrote...

Yes. 5 minutes of meh doesn't ruin 2400 minutes of pure linearity, railroading, cheap substitutions, autodialogue, lies and a complete lack of choices and satisfying conclusions

Fixed.

This. I imagine most critics would just overlook that, but between that and the backlash from the end, it probably doesn't stand much chance anymore. I suppose it depends on how well its competition does and the DLC, but I still think it lost the chance at GOTY when they messed up the choices in addition to the ending.

[BadJustice]

Maybe. pretty strong contender but not 100% assured.

[PaulSX]

Yes, it's worthy. This game is still a well-designed experience except the depressing ending.
but I think Assassin's Creed 3 will get most GOTYs this year, ME3 might only get a few votes.

[Lee80]

Depends on how the EC, DLC, and other things play out. However, I would have to say I'm leaning towards a yes.

[Tazzmission]

suntzuxi wrote...

Yes, it's worthy. This game is still a well-designed experience except the depressing ending.
but I think Assassin's Creed 3 will get most GOTYs this year, ME3 might only get a few votes.

my money is on gta 5 if the october 2012 release is true because man that game will outsellf ac3 imo


i want me3 to win but i do agree certain things need to be corrected to fix alot of things

[PaulSX]

Terror_K wrote...

chris2365 wrote...

Yes. 5 minutes of meh doesn't ruin 2400 minutes of pure linearity, railroading, cheap substitutions, autodialogue, lies and a complete lack of choices and satisfying conclusions

Fixed.

Those are more of personal preferences and do not make a game good or bad.
for example, Uncharted 2 has most of these features you listed above, but it's still one of the best games in recent years.

Modifié par suntzuxi, 23 mai 2012 - 04:55 .

[Terror_K]

suntzuxi wrote...

Yes, it's worthy. This game is still a well-designed experience except the depressing ending.

The awful Journal and face import bug alone throw mud in the face of that claim... let alone all the other awful design decisions (linearity, lack of dialogue choices, autodialogue, purely cosmetic choices that don't really matter, everything is about combat, etc.).

[Terror_K]

suntzuxi wrote...

Terror_K wrote...

chris2365 wrote...

Yes. 5 minutes of meh doesn't ruin 2400 minutes of pure linearity, railroading, cheap substitutions, autodialogue, lies and a complete lack of choices and satisfying conclusions

Fixed.

Those are more of personal preferences and do not make a game good or bad.
for example, Uncharted 2 has most of these features you listed above, but it's still one of the best game in recent years.

Uncharted 2 isn't supposed to be an RPG with player choice a major factor, and it never claimed to be; it's an action-adventure title. Uncharted 2 also doesn't stray from the formula set by its direct predecessor, and in fact builds on it.

ME3's main weaknesses stem not so much from being a bad game, but a bad Mass Effect. Almost all the things that Mass Effect was supposed to be about was thrown down the toilet with ME3. Yes, the combat was finally perfect... but that's not what Mass Effect is supposed to be and not what I came to it for. If I want to play great TPS combat, I'll go to a pure TPS game like Gears or Space Marine. I wanted an immersive sci-fi roleplaying experience that felt personal, which ME1 was, and even ME2 brought for the most part. ME3 failed in every single area that it should have excelled at and excelled at the stuff that didn't really matter.

Modifié par Terror_K, 23 mai 2012 - 05:00 .

[TaHol]

Hell no, ME3 is not a Goty-game. 2011 Goty was Skyrim, and ME3 is no way near the sells figures of Skyrim. I can't find how much Skyrim has sold, but it is most played game in Steam. I don't want to talk about quality here, Skyrim has problems too, but Skyrim was praised by reviewers AND customers. There are still many games coming this year, and I'm sure some of them beats ME3. I haven't followed how things went with Diablo 3, I was betting it to be Goty of this year, but what little I heard it was disappointment for some people. But, so was Skyrim too, no way everyone can be happy with something.

Modifié par TaHol, 23 mai 2012 - 05:05 .

[QwertyMusicMan]

No, not even remotely close. And that's for other reasons than the ending, I could care less about that s**tstorm at this point.

[PaulSX]

TaHol wrote...

Hell no, ME3 is not a Goty-game. 2011 Goty was Skyrim, and ME3 is no way near the sells figures of Skyrim. I can't find how much Skyrim has sold, but it is most played game in Steam. I don't want to talk about quality here, Skyrim has problems too, but Skyrim was praised by reviewers AND customers. There are still many games coming this year, and I'm sure some of them beats ME3. I haven't followed how things went with Diablo 3, I was betting it to be Goty of this year, but what little I heard it was disappointment for some people. But, so was Skyrim too, no way everyone can be happy with something.

if we use popularity to decide game of the year, then Call of Duty should win GotY every year, no Competition.

[Slayer299]

No, ME3 is not even close to being a GOTY title and not even factoring in the horror that was the ending. ME3 has too many problems with it in the main game; tons of auto-dialoge for BW's Shepard, an insanely linear campaign, broken journal, face import bug, horrible char. animations and fetch quests to name a few things off the top of my head.

[augmented shephard]

It is GOTY without a doubt!

[augmented shephard]

Lets admit it, if the ending was fine everybody would say yes to this question.

[Slayer299]

No, because not everyone's problem with ME3 has to do solely with the ending, as I listed above.

[Annie_Dear]

Slayer299 wrote...

No, because not everyone's problem with ME3 has to do solely with the ending, as I listed above.

This.

The game has it's faults, and it's not just that "ending".

[M2S SOLID JOSH]

absolutely not even if the game had a better ending theres still quite a few problems i had with it that makes it fall short

[Maugrim]

augmented shephard wrote...

Lets admit it, if the ending was fine everybody would say yes to this question.

I'll admit it I probably would've said yes. But you know what?

I would've been wrong.  That just goes to show in some ways how easy Bioware has it and how with just writing a half way decent ending I and most other fans would've forgiven them almost anything.  So now they are getting called out on everything that was wrong outside of the ending as well.  Boo fricking hoo.  Thing is even now if Bioware really knuckled down and produced a superb EC with 16~ different endings that don't rely on space magic and showed all the variables etc... I and I bet many other would still overlook all the things wrong with ME3.

We might rage but ultimately the majority of us are an easily pacified and forgving lot.  It's up to Bioware now really.

[skiadopsendow]

I don't know if it's worth, we have to wait for SP DLCs

[kumquats]

I like ME3, it's good game, like D3 and MP3 are good games, but I expect more from a GOTY contestant. Good, is not good enough.