1087 réponses à ce sujet

[Lamepro]

Seeing Bioware show the story of how a openly gay man flying in the sky he was shot down by enemy.I feel bad that Cortez became a inside joke forever known as "Tinkerbell" who gone down in a Blaze of Glory.

[kalle90]

Earlier I said that it's early and after ME3 I won't be surprised to see more flops. But now I can say that Max Payne 3 holds my GOTY spot so far. It's not exactly a masterpiece, but way more enjoyable and less lacking than ME3.

[ElementL09]

Its a big maybe in my opinion, we'll see what happens when some single player DLC comes out.

Modifié par ElementL09, 23 mai 2012 - 08:32 .

[ungodlike]

LoL sorry D3 is sooo GOTY. I mean seriously I've been replaying the starter edition over and over, when I have the full game just to power level and prep characters for the full game. I've only played ME 3 once now I don't even play ME3 mp anymore. All those perfect scores mean !#$@ all for ME3.

D3 is addictive, replayable + fun gameplay. GOTY so far. 

Modifié par ungodlike, 23 mai 2012 - 09:23 .

[kumquats]

ungodlike wrote...

D3 is addictive, replayable + fun gameplay. GOTY so far. 

It's true what you say BUT, Blizzard just did what they did in D2. They are no major innovations in D3, that's not enough for a GOTY title.

It's good, but not hyper super amazing awesome. That's what I expect from a GOTY.

[someguy1231]

Even if you set aside the ending, ME3 has too many problems for it to be GotY. Repetitive fetch quests, terrible journal, abundance of loading screens, increased linearity (for an RPG), abrupt introduction, characters forced on you that you might not be familiar with (Vega), a shallow villain who blatantly abuses bad writing techniques (Kai Leng), far less dialogue choices, etc.

I personally think GotY will be Halo 4 or Assassin's Creed 3. Pretty much everything I've seen from those two games is completely positive, both developers are clearly putting alot of effort into them, and their respective fans are extremely hyped.

[Kiadaw]

ME3 does have alot of room for improvement, but given the size of the game with respect to the development time, I think it did pretty well.

A typical shooter have like 1/4 of the content. SP alone is easily over 40+ hours without rushing. There is also sufficient differences between the classes, as well as minor differences between femshep, male shep, as well as renegade & paragon, to warrant at least another run or two.

And FFXIII took like 5 or so years, & the game offer almost no choices, with little replay value, super linear with dull combat mixed with CG heavy cut scene.

I have not played D3, purely as my PC cannot support the game, & I am home bound for the last 2 weeks (broke my ankle), & not able to buy a PC to play Diablo 3. I reserve my judgement until I played Diablo, but so far ME3 is GOTY worthy, & the EC & future DLC could be the deciding factors if it can win GOTY.

[incinerator950]

No, but D3 doesn't sound to be in the lineup either. I expect big name game like Halo or CoD to take it, with honest results instead of EA buying out every authentic reviewer.

[iamthedave3]

kumquats wrote...

ungodlike wrote...

D3 is addictive, replayable + fun gameplay. GOTY so far. 

It's true what you say BUT, Blizzard just did what they did in D2. They are no major innovations in D3, that's not enough for a GOTY title.

It's good, but not hyper super amazing awesome. That's what I expect from a GOTY.

There are no major innovations in most games these days, and the most innovative games rarely win. Besides, ME 3 can't compete on those grounds, either, unless we count the ending controversy as innovation

Trying to think of a Game of the Year winner that really deserves it on innovation grounds. Fallout 3 won didn't it? I'm sure Oblivion did, too, but neither provided massive innovations; they were just a further development on Bethesda's house style (Oblivion especially; Fallout was at least adapting their house style to a new setting).

Honestly, both games are in the running. If I were asked to pick I'd go with Diablo, though, because it's a cleaner package with fewer flaws (mainly referring to the horrific journal and side quest system of ME 3).

[Jadebaby]

No, it will be the game that has invoked the most emotion in me, but that doesn't mean it deserves GOTY.

The gameplay, story, graphics and finishing polish of the game is what gets games GOTY.

ME3 fails on at least 2 of those.

Mole267 wrote...

I think Max Payne 3 might be GOTY material tho.

I've only played multiplayer so far, but I tell you what.. It looks amazing! Can't wait for this weekend to get stuck into the single-player!

[Jadebaby]

Other titles that could snatch it:

Halo 4
Asassin's Creed 3
Bioshock: Infinite
Max Payne 3

incinerator950 wrote...

No, but D3 doesn't sound to be in the lineup either. I expect big name game like Halo or CoD to take it, with honest results instead of EA buying out every authentic reviewer.

With the titles above mentioned.... GOD HELP US IF COD GETS GOTY!

[Random Geth]

No. Even aside from the rubbish ending, the game is clearly unfinished. Even if a lot of what we have is quite good, I would never recommend it as a game of the year what with all of the massive downgrades from ME2 (such as squadmate interaction on the normandy and the awful journal) and the over-simplification of dialogue options.

[NaastyNZL]

Alot of titles are being pushed back into 2013, so chances are Mass Effect 3 could easily get GOTY.... only because there isn't very much good games being released this year.

[mcz2345]

seanycourt wrote...

Nope. Halo 4

So true

[FlamingBoy]

Random Geth wrote...

No. Even aside from the rubbish ending, the game is clearly unfinished. Even if a lot of what we have is quite good, I would never recommend it as a game of the year what with all of the massive downgrades from ME2 (such as squadmate interaction on the normandy and the awful journal) and the over-simplification of dialogue options.

i want this to be what i said about the game, forget about what i said before!

THIS!!

[HowlingSiren]

It really pains me to say it, but no.

I think ME3 was too ambitious an undertaking to finish developing in 2 years. An RPG trilogy with thousands of different decisions to take into account is an overwhelming task, and I certainly felt that depth was sacrificed in the name of speed. Certain key elements of 1 and 2 were overlooked or under-developed (Collector Base, Rachni Queen, Dark Energy, Harbinger, ME2 squadmates, etc.) and the side quests combined with the broken journal felt more like fetch quests than in the previous installments.

Given its context, I expected ME3 to be the most immersive and gripping of the 3, but it wasn't. Combat was vastly improved, the locations were superb, and there were some truly great moments (the whole Genophage quest for one), but because I often felt that the game was trying to cram so much into so little and resorted to auto-dialogue quite a bit, it felt more superficial and passive than 1 or 2.

Finally, I cannot overlook the ending, which felt like a slap in the face. I felt directed and manipulated by a deus ex machina, and the lack of any closure or clarity was appalling. I'm all for making a difficult choice at the end, and to me, all 3 choices had an element that was profoundly repulsive. But to top it off by killing Shepard no matter what (if you play SP only), disconnect the universe through the destruction of the relays, leave you blind to the fate of the vast majority of squadmates and strand fleets away from their home and those closest to you on some unreachable Eden World was just overkill.

Even though BioWare is by far my favorite developer, they made some crucial errors in judgment with ME3 that would be validated by a GOTY win and that I fear would compromise the quality of their future games. So no, for the first time, I wouldn't vote for them.

[LinksOcarina]

slyguy200 wrote...

someguy1231 wrote...

Even if you set aside the ending, ME3 has too many problems for it to be GotY. Repetitive fetch quests, terrible journal, abundance of loading screens, increased linearity (for an RPG), abrupt introduction, characters forced on you that you might not be familiar with (Vega), a shallow villain who blatantly abuses bad writing techniques (Kai Leng), far less dialogue choices, etc.

I personally think GotY will be Halo 4 or Assassin's Creed 3. Pretty much everything I've seen from those two games is completely positive, both developers are clearly putting alot of effort into them, and their respective fans are extremely hyped.

This sums it up quite well.

choose a game thats not out yet, nice idea.

and honestly, Skyrim was a broken and bug-riddled game that won GOTY by numerous publications, so anything is possible.

[Eelectrica]

With Bioshock - infinity now delayed, maybe?