xconceptualx wrote...
Getorex wrote...
slyguy200 wrote...
Getorex wrote...
...
Easy (with qualifications...not "realistic" but also NOT really sci-fi either): biotics. Not sci-fi. Biotics (ie, "magic") is actually fantasy, the ugly cousin of sci-fi. The mass effect itself is sci-fi-y but biotics (adepts, et al) are absolutely NO different from wizards/sorcerors/witches/warlocks/what have you in silly midieval fantasy games. Instead of making incantations and wearing leather/chain mail/plate armor/flowing robes they wear space armor or slinky dresses...or bikini tops and leather pants (Jack). Fantasy all the way.
The non-sex "sex" that the asari have (mystical soul connection instead of the good stuff) is kindof a bastard daughter between sci-fi and fantasy. All magicky but with an attempt (weak though it is) at a "sciencey" explanation.
As for "realistic"...hmmm. The fact that humans in the game can mate with humans. That's realistic. All the other mix-and-match stuff is not realistic and is pure sci-fi/fantasy. After expending some real effort, however, that is the only "realistic" part in the entire series that I can put forth.
Only 1 thing, i figured as much.
Barely even that really. I thought when I started typing I would be able to come up with a couple or three things but I got almost nothing. Humans mating wth humans is the best I can do but it isn't very good because it is wrecked by everyone being able to mix and match across species and entirely independent evolutionary histories. Pyrrhic at best.
The only mixing and matching going on between species (in terms of actually reproduction) occurs with the Asari. Interspecies sex is certainly occuring, but no interspecies offspring are being produced. Why is that unrealistic?
As far as adepts being fantasy and not sci-fi, I suppose you could make that case. But it's not like Bioware simply presents us with adepts without attempting to give us a science (however unrealistic it may be) behind their capacities. And if that is indeed the case, you cannot call Star Trek or Star Wars science fiction either. Vulcan mind melding, Di-Lithium crystal hyperdrives, and the Force are all just as "fantastic" as adepts manipulating dark energy with brain implants.
Really? That's easy. Let's go with spiders and dogs. Let's assume some genetic manipulation (for some bizarre reason) so that we have a BIG spider (about the max theoretical size possible at around the size of a chihuahua). Let's also assume an actual chihuahua so that the two different species (but from the same planet and who both actually share a common ancestor...though WAY back about 500 million years or so) around the same size. Can the dog and spider have "sex"? NO! Totally different sexual organs, totally different method of having sex. That's pesky evolution for you. Aliens will be MORE divergent than even a spider vs a dog!
Let's get closer still: a chihuahua and a big rat. Can they have sex? NO! They wouldn't even be interested in each other (though you can cheat and smear female-in-heat scent on the female in the pair from the opposite species so that the MALE of the pair has an 'interest' - the female, not at all). They might go through the motions but the equipment doesn't mesh. Totally different evolutionary history and even with a very similar physical body plan it still can't work.
Aliens from an entirely separate planet with an entirely independent evolutionary history HAVE to be incompatibly different in that department. It cannot work. You cannot expect a quarian to have a conveniently located (and physically compatible) vagina that will happily accomodate a human male penis. That woudn't even happen between turians and quarians...merely being "dextro" doesn't have anything to do with sex organ layout and mechanics. There can be no sex between aliens. There cannot even be sexual ATTRACTION except by those extreme minorities that are deviant/dysfunctional and get into cross-species "liasons" as it is (sorry, but it is NOT acceptable to be a human interested in sex with dogs, goats, horses, whatever. That is NOT discriminatory and prejudicial, that is just universal and proper. It would NOT change the issue if dogs had intelligence similar to humans - it would simply be deviant and dysfunctional and unacceptable for a human to boink a dog, regardless of the intelligence of either).
We're talking "realistic" here, not what is "acceptable" trope in sci-fi. Star Trek goes there all the time but then all aliens that are potential sex interests are ALWAYS exceedingly human and never really "alien". Not realistic at all.
Oh, and the same critique I have for ME (biotics ARE magic and thus fantasy, NOT sci-fi) goes for Star Wars (the "force" IS magic. Period) and to a lessor extent, Star Trek (mind melds, telepathy, are magic). Magic is fantasy, not sci-fi. You can toss magic into sci-fi but it isn't then purely sci-fi is it? it is science fantasy at that point. Thus ME and Star Wars is science fantasy in a BIG way and Star Trek is sci-fi with fantasy elements. Personally, I'd be happy with a sci-fi game, movie, series that totally dispensed with ANY magic and simply stuck with the science part of the sci-fi equation. For ME that would mean you could keep the magic-LIKE tech stuff (the combat drone stuff, electroshock stuff, all from the multitool thingy) but dump the magicky biotic stuff. You can get to a rough equivalent of the biotic magic without actually having it work like magic - via types of tech that follow very circumscribed rules. Not a huge leap needed but better than just having people being able to magically move sh*t with a thought. Ugh. You get a lot of good tech that does the job in Deus Ex: Human Revolution but it is all TECH, none of it is magicky. You get a LOT more realism in that game than in any ME game, especially since they started wtih real tech and real planned tech and extrapolated rather than making sh*t up from nothing.
Modifié par Getorex, 24 mai 2012 - 05:42 .