Aller au contenu

Photo

Is Mass Effect 3 GOTY worthy?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
1087 réponses à ce sujet

#951
Guest_greengoron89_*

Guest_greengoron89_*
  • Guests
Not a chance.

#952
Foehamer1

Foehamer1
  • Members
  • 31 messages
The moment you have to make an extended cutscene for an ending to a series, is when you know you failed to deliver a game that is worthy of being a Game of the Year.

#953
Documental

Documental
  • Members
  • 256 messages

Rockworm503 wrote...

A game that is terrible almost from start to finish and not only ruins its own replay value but the games that came before it. I have about 6 Shepards from ME1 and 2 that will never be imported to 3. Makes me wonder why I even bought those games. Right now I think it would be better off if I never even heard of Mass Effect.
I'm tired of people saying "its just the last 5 minutes your letting that ruin a great game"
No actually the ending isn't even the worst part and its more like your letting a couple of good parts blind you to just how god awful this game really was.
Game of the year? My ass if it doesn't make worst game of the decade I'll lose all faith in humanity.


lol. honestly just lol.

#954
Sarah_SR2

Sarah_SR2
  • Members
  • 564 messages
I can't remember if I've answered to this before but in case I haven't here goes. I would love to say yes to GOTY for this game, but... The game is great right up to and including the point where you fight and then joyfully renegade stab Kai Leng out of his miserable existence and leave Cerberus in ruins. For me, Priority : Earth might as well have been story-boarded by a group of prize winners who won the chance to narrate a level for a top 2012 game release! Okay that was very harsh and I whole-heartedly apologise but I needed to point out the writing inconsistencies it seems to me to have. I mean come on, that last mission has so many things Wrong with it that it brings down what was until then a totally brilliant game. I can live with the endings even though they should be way better, but that last hour of gameplay section could have and should have been so very much more IMO. For that reason, I doubt that it'll get GOTY but we'll find out in due course.

#955
The Unfallen

The Unfallen
  • Members
  • 1 102 messages
YES! Mass Effect 3 was an amazing game. The ending may have been less than stellar but it certainly is way better than what Halo can pull out of its ass now-days. I advocate Mass Effect 3 for Game of the Year and the Mass Effect Series as a whole for a new award, Video Game Event Of The Decade (VGEOTD)

#956
vurtual3

vurtual3
  • Members
  • 68 messages
Best game I've played this year so far. And given that it's the best game I've played this gen guess it's got a good chance of staying there!

#957
stonek89

stonek89
  • Members
  • 13 messages
No.

#958
Rockworm503

Rockworm503
  • Members
  • 7 519 messages

Documental wrote...

Rockworm503 wrote...

A game that is terrible almost from start to finish and not only ruins its own replay value but the games that came before it. I have about 6 Shepards from ME1 and 2 that will never be imported to 3. Makes me wonder why I even bought those games. Right now I think it would be better off if I never even heard of Mass Effect.
I'm tired of people saying "its just the last 5 minutes your letting that ruin a great game"
No actually the ending isn't even the worst part and its more like your letting a couple of good parts blind you to just how god awful this game really was.
Game of the year? My ass if it doesn't make worst game of the decade I'll lose all faith in humanity.


lol. honestly just lol.


Why?
Whats lol worthy about my post?
I'm 100% serious here nothing in ME3 is even remotely worth it.

#959
Giggles_Manically

Giggles_Manically
  • Members
  • 13 708 messages
There are giant smelly turds that come out the back end of an diseased and dying elephant that are more worthy of being called "GOTY" then Mass Effect 3.

Wont stop IGN or any other website that is getting paid by EA to say it is though.

#960
RedArmyShogun

RedArmyShogun
  • Members
  • 6 273 messages
Hahahaa what? Thank God Halo 4 and a few others come out this year. Sure it will Get RPG of the year by default however.

#961
ghost9191

ghost9191
  • Members
  • 2 287 messages

Giggles_Manically wrote...

There are giant smelly turds that come out the back end of an diseased and dying elephant that are more worthy of being called "GOTY" then Mass Effect 3.

Wont stop IGN or any other website that is getting paid by EA to say it is though.


next your gonna say cod will be game of the year cause it is shiny and can keep your attention for more then 2 secs. also opinion doesn't make fact but i am pretty sure people alot more important then you do think it is game of the year. but in the end it is what your personal opinion is of a game that counts, simply put you like shiny things :D  

all joke somewhat,  just saying that it is annoying to see ppl complain that they wasted their mothers money on mass effect 3 just because of the ending, it is like even if you hate the ending you still got 30 hours or so playtime which is more then a fps in story anyways, and mp so stop ****ing and get a cookie. also i think it is up there on the list , probably would make it now but it is only halfway through the year

Modifié par ghost9191, 10 juin 2012 - 11:53 .


#962
wildannie

wildannie
  • Members
  • 2 223 messages
not even close

agree with this sentiment v v v

Modifié par wildannie, 10 juin 2012 - 11:54 .


#963
Seboist

Seboist
  • Members
  • 11 974 messages

Rockworm503 wrote...

A game that is terrible almost from start to finish and not only ruins its own replay value but the games that came before it. I have about 6 Shepards from ME1 and 2 that will never be imported to 3. Makes me wonder why I even bought those games. Right now I think it would be better off if I never even heard of Mass Effect.
I'm tired of people saying "its just the last 5 minutes your letting that ruin a great game"
No actually the ending isn't even the worst part and its more like your letting a couple of good parts blind you to just how god awful this game really was.
Game of the year? My ass if it doesn't make worst game of the decade I'll lose all faith in humanity.


Here here, if It wasn't for the fact that I met my RL waifu due to this ME3 fiasco I would have completely regretted ever getting into this series.

#964
ghost9191

ghost9191
  • Members
  • 2 287 messages

Seboist wrote...

Rockworm503 wrote...

A game that is terrible almost from start to finish and not only ruins its own replay value but the games that came before it. I have about 6 Shepards from ME1 and 2 that will never be imported to 3. Makes me wonder why I even bought those games. Right now I think it would be better off if I never even heard of Mass Effect.
I'm tired of people saying "its just the last 5 minutes your letting that ruin a great game"
No actually the ending isn't even the worst part and its more like your letting a couple of good parts blind you to just how god awful this game really was.
Game of the year? My ass if it doesn't make worst game of the decade I'll lose all faith in humanity.


Here here, if It wasn't for the fact that I met my RL waifu due to this ME3 fiasco I would have completely regretted ever getting into this series.

crymore that is my response

Modifié par ghost9191, 10 juin 2012 - 11:59 .


#965
-Skorpious-

-Skorpious-
  • Members
  • 3 081 messages

Foehamer1 wrote...

The moment you have to make an extended cutscene for an ending to a series, is when you know you failed to deliver a game that is worthy of being a Game of the Year.



#966
Giggles_Manically

Giggles_Manically
  • Members
  • 13 708 messages

ghost9191 wrote...

Giggles_Manically wrote...

There are giant smelly turds that come out the back end of an diseased and dying elephant that are more worthy of being called "GOTY" then Mass Effect 3.

Wont stop IGN or any other website that is getting paid by EA to say it is though.


next your gonna say cod will be game of the year cause it is shiny and can keep your attention for more then 2 secs. also opinion doesn't make fact but i am pretty sure people alot more important then you do think it is game of the year. but in the end it is what your personal opinion is of a game that counts, simply put you like shiny things :D  

all joke somewhat,  just saying that it is annoying to see ppl complain that they wasted their mothers money on mass effect 3 just because of the ending, it is like even if you hate the ending you still got 30 hours or so playtime which is more then a fps in story anyways, and mp so stop ****ing and get a cookie. also i think it is up there on the list , probably would make it now but it is only halfway through the year

Actually I dont play COD, I dont live with my mother, I hated all of ME3 except for a few parts and will probably say that XCOM will be GOTY right now from the looks of it.

But hey congratulations for beating up a Strawman.

#967
ghost9191

ghost9191
  • Members
  • 2 287 messages

Giggles_Manically wrote...

ghost9191 wrote...

Giggles_Manically wrote...

There are giant smelly turds that come out the back end of an diseased and dying elephant that are more worthy of being called "GOTY" then Mass Effect 3.

Wont stop IGN or any other website that is getting paid by EA to say it is though.


next your gonna say cod will be game of the year cause it is shiny and can keep your attention for more then 2 secs. also opinion doesn't make fact but i am pretty sure people alot more important then you do think it is game of the year. but in the end it is what your personal opinion is of a game that counts, simply put you like shiny things :D  

all joke somewhat,  just saying that it is annoying to see ppl complain that they wasted their mothers money on mass effect 3 just because of the ending, it is like even if you hate the ending you still got 30 hours or so playtime which is more then a fps in story anyways, and mp so stop ****ing and get a cookie. also i think it is up there on the list , probably would make it now but it is only halfway through the year

Actually I dont play COD, I dont live with my mother, I hated all of ME3 except for a few parts and will probably say that XCOM will be GOTY right now from the looks of it.

But hey congratulations for beating up a Strawman.



if you do not understand the word joke or don't get sarcasm. never said you played cod , said you would prrobably like it cause it is shiny. i was saying that ppl that think me3 is a good game arn't just saying it cause they get paid to. just because someones opinion is defferent from yours doesn't mean they are wrong. but you are wrong for thinking so :lol:

#968
Seboist

Seboist
  • Members
  • 11 974 messages
Mass Effect is far worse than CoD. That series doesn't mind boggling moronic plots like humans being slurpeed into a space terminator due to "genetic diversity"....lmao.

I will give the ME series one thing, EAware created the first interactive Ed Wood movie with it.

#969
ghost9191

ghost9191
  • Members
  • 2 287 messages

Seboist wrote...

Mass Effect is far worse than CoD. That series doesn't mind boggling moronic plots like humans being slurpeed into a space terminator due to "genetic diversity"....lmao.

I will give the ME series one thing, EAware created the first interactive Ed Wood movie with it.


by your statement i will stick by CoD attracting people with shiny          but i guess your opinion is what it is, but don't think it is better then anyone elses, i mean the fact you put cod higher then mass effect 3 probably means your a 13 year old child that is wanting a cookie, and if not then whatever, your opinion is yours mine is mine. i don't think it is going to get GOTY but will be close, good game , not great or awesome but better then some



but again this is all a joke, mass effect has it's good and bads , but based on opinion whether or not you think it is goty worthy, but it is just your opinion not the worlds. let the voting comme nce

Modifié par ghost9191, 11 juin 2012 - 12:12 .


#970
Grumpy Old Wizard

Grumpy Old Wizard
  • Members
  • 2 581 messages

Documental wrote...

Yes, I wrote a review for a website I write for and it is my Game of the Year already, there won't be another game which will compel or invoke more emotion from me than this game this year.


You mean provoke more fan rage?  Diablo 3 is provoking a lot of fan rage at the moment. But no, ME3 is not GOTY worthy. Bioware keeps insisting fans are wrong and that they will stick to their "artistic vision."  They are too full of themselves.

Modifié par Grumpy Old Wizard, 11 juin 2012 - 12:20 .


#971
Guest_slyguy200_*

Guest_slyguy200_*
  • Guests

ghost9191 wrote...

Giggles_Manically wrote...

There are giant smelly turds that come out the back end of an diseased and dying elephant that are more worthy of being called "GOTY" then Mass Effect 3.

Wont stop IGN or any other website that is getting paid by EA to say it is though.


next your gonna say cod will be game of the year cause it is shiny and can keep your attention for more then 2 secs. also opinion doesn't make fact but i am pretty sure people alot more important then you do think it is game of the year. but in the end it is what your personal opinion is of a game that counts, simply put you like shiny things :D  

all joke somewhat,  just saying that it is annoying to see ppl complain that they wasted their mothers money on mass effect 3 just because of the ending, it is like even if you hate the ending you still got 30 hours or so playtime which is more then a fps in story anyways, and mp so stop ****ing and get a cookie. also i think it is up there on the list , probably would make it now but it is only halfway through the year

IGN had better be prepared for the flak they are going to take for nominating ME3, but they are biased anyway.
EA pays people to review games, it seems only fair that they tell them what they want to hear, naybe they even add a generous bonus for going public with good reviews.
I wasted my money on ME3 it's mediocre game. It is not just the ending that sucks, the whole darn thing is low qualtiy and lazily slapped together.
MP was also a fairly cheap copy of GoW 2 horde mode in an ME skin with a time-limit. Honestly, prototype 2 was better than ME3.
Yet again we arrive at the enevitable conclusion that ME3 will not get GOTY from anyone who matters.
The video in this poll will explain much about EA.
http://social.biowar...25/polls/34544/

Modifié par slyguy200, 11 juin 2012 - 12:32 .


#972
wildannie

wildannie
  • Members
  • 2 223 messages

Grumpy Old Wizard wrote...

Documental wrote...

Yes, I wrote a review for a website I write for and it is my Game of the Year already, there won't be another game which will compel or invoke more emotion from me than this game this year.


You mean provoke more fan rage?  Diablo 3 is provoking a lot of fan rage at the moment. But no, ME3 is not GOTY worthy. Bioware keeps insisting fans are wrong and that they will stick to their "artistic vision."  They are too full of themselves.


I find their arrogance to be particularly irritating.  

They hide behind good reviews that didn't take account of all the different choices that could be being imported and how these different choices were addressed in game.  
The 'professional' reviews are not looking at the bigger picture and rating the game as a stand alone linear shooter when its success in providing a satisfactory conclusion to an Action RPG  trilogy based on choice should have been central to any review.  
Reviewers who didn't bother to explore enough to realise that choice and player agency had been largely removed from the game are not really worth paying attention to.

#973
Rockworm503

Rockworm503
  • Members
  • 7 519 messages

ghost9191 wrote...

Giggles_Manically wrote...

There are giant smelly turds that come out the back end of an diseased and dying elephant that are more worthy of being called "GOTY" then Mass Effect 3.

Wont stop IGN or any other website that is getting paid by EA to say it is though.


next your gonna say cod will be game of the year cause it is shiny and can keep your attention for more then 2 secs. also opinion doesn't make fact but i am pretty sure people alot more important then you do think it is game of the year. but in the end it is what your personal opinion is of a game that counts, simply put you like shiny things :D  

all joke somewhat,  just saying that it is annoying to see ppl complain that they wasted their mothers money on mass effect 3 just because of the ending, it is like even if you hate the ending you still got 30 hours or so playtime which is more then a fps in story anyways, and mp so stop ****ing and get a cookie. also i think it is up there on the list , probably would make it now but it is only halfway through the year


Maybe you spent your moms money but I spent MY hard earned money on this series.  30 crap hours that I"ll never get back.  Seriously so long as I got the hours in it doesn't matter how bad it was just eat a cookie?
This is why I laugh at all those who love the game.  They seem to be in a vacuum where ME3 is the only game that exists.
Also why is it I see more of the so called "haters" being more decent about it than those who love the game?

#974
Rockworm503

Rockworm503
  • Members
  • 7 519 messages

ghost9191 wrote...

Seboist wrote...

Mass Effect is far worse than CoD. That series doesn't mind boggling moronic plots like humans being slurpeed into a space terminator due to "genetic diversity"....lmao.

I will give the ME series one thing, EAware created the first interactive Ed Wood movie with it.


by your statement i will stick by CoD attracting people with shiny          but i guess your opinion is what it is, but don't think it is better then anyone elses, i mean the fact you put cod higher then mass effect 3 probably means your a 13 year old child that is wanting a cookie, and if not then whatever, your opinion is yours mine is mine. i don't think it is going to get GOTY but will be close, good game , not great or awesome but better then some



but again this is all a joke, mass effect has it's good and bads , but based on opinion whether or not you think it is goty worthy, but it is just your opinion not the worlds. let the voting comme nce


/facepalm..
You think the rules of the forum don't apply to you because you love the game?

#975
ghost9191

ghost9191
  • Members
  • 2 287 messages

Rockworm503 wrote...

ghost9191 wrote...

Giggles_Manically wrote...

There are giant smelly turds that come out the back end of an diseased and dying elephant that are more worthy of being called "GOTY" then Mass Effect 3.

Wont stop IGN or any other website that is getting paid by EA to say it is though.


next your gonna say cod will be game of the year cause it is shiny and can keep your attention for more then 2 secs. also opinion doesn't make fact but i am pretty sure people alot more important then you do think it is game of the year. but in the end it is what your personal opinion is of a game that counts, simply put you like shiny things :D  

all joke somewhat,  just saying that it is annoying to see ppl complain that they wasted their mothers money on mass effect 3 just because of the ending, it is like even if you hate the ending you still got 30 hours or so playtime which is more then a fps in story anyways, and mp so stop ****ing and get a cookie. also i think it is up there on the list , probably would make it now but it is only halfway through the year


Maybe you spent your moms money but I spent MY hard earned money on this series.  30 crap hours that I"ll never get back.  Seriously so long as I got the hours in it doesn't matter how bad it was just eat a cookie?
This is why I laugh at all those who love the game.  They seem to be in a vacuum where ME3 is the only game that exists.
Also why is it I see more of the so called "haters" being more decent about it than those who love the game?


1. i never once said whether or not i liked or disliked mass effect,  "when you assume, you make an ass out of you and me"      

2. don't recall ever putting your name in that post, that and i said that with the 30hours gameplay and mp if you play it you got your monies worth, whatever your opinion is you got what you paid for, fps give you what 4 hours worth of gameplay and they go for the same amount be happy and stop whining like a child

3. my opinion is my own, i do not need others to read it to feel good about myself

FYI none of my posts were directed at you, your not that important

Modifié par ghost9191, 11 juin 2012 - 01:18 .