1087 réponses à ce sujet

[ZtalkerRM]

Link Ashland 614 wrote...

For fans, just dissapointment.

For critics, it will be GOTY.

Did you hear that? Van Ord is making drool pools on the floor again...

[ProtoMan 2.0]

Arik7 wrote...

Not with the current (or extended) ending. Just NO.

Borderlands, ME2, Batman arkham asylum, Fallout 3, Bioshock, Halo, Halo 2, Halo 3, Metal Gear Solid 2 and MGS4.

All these games had really terrible endings.

All these games won numerous GOTY awards

[Transgirlgamer]

I love ME3, I really do, but I don't think it should be game of the year. The story is an integral part and personally, I believe ME3's story fails because the endings come out of nowhere. Only if evey other game released in the required period is actually worse than ME3 should it be goty, and I don't think that will be the case.

Of course it's various reviewers who decide on their game of the year, and from what I've heard, a lot of professional writers don't seem to have a problem with the endings.

[PluralAces]

No it is not, GOTY means everything about the game was awesome, and unfortunately this is not the case....there will be other games still to come that I think will outshine ME3 in terms of overall greatness

[PluralAces]

Link Ashland 614 wrote...

For fans, just dissapointment.

For critics, it will be GOTY.

I agree. I think fans will say no, critics will say yes, they already have according to ME3 advertisements

[Travie]

Yeah, the critics are almost completely removed from the fans at this point.

For me, all that matters is consumer reviews.

[Lee T]

ProtoMan 2.0 wrote...

Borderlands, ME2, Batman arkham asylum, Fallout 3, Bioshock, Halo, Halo 2, Halo 3, Metal Gear Solid 2 and MGS4.

All these games had really terrible endings.

All these games won numerous GOTY awards

I don't know about the Halo and MGS but here's what I can say about the other on that list :

Only Borderland had a sucky ending (I liked all the other's), the ending was somewhat worse than ME3 since it was  a repeat of the already sucky ending og HL:OpFor. Errare humanum est, perseverare diabolicum.

However I enjoyed playing Borderlands, ME2, Batman Arkham Asylum, Fallout 3, and Bioshock more than playing ME3. Regardless of the ending.

I enjoyed playing ME1 more than those games though.

ME3 is not my game of the year, but to each his own.

Modifié par Lee T, 13 avril 2012 - 01:52 .

[TweedleDee66]

Unfortunately I’m sure it will get GOTY nominated. Considering the ending of the game and all the bad publicity EA and BioWare has gotten from it, it shouldn’t even be considered though. That’s like giving an Oscar to a film with a bad ending that they re-released with an “extended cut” version explaining the ending a few months later.

[matthewmi]

Yes it is easily GOTY worthy even with a subpar ending and admit it guys it is pretty weak, but still love the game and series anyways.

[Melancholic]

PluralAces wrote...

GOTY means everything about the game was awesome

http://en.wikipedia...._of_the_Year.29

Modifié par Melancholic, 13 avril 2012 - 01:58 .

[mbr.to]

i guess it will be goty worthy for the next 10 years xD

please prove me wrong gaming industry

[CrazyRah]

It might just compete about it but i doubt and hope it don't get it

[Degs29]

There is no way ME3 is worthy of a GOTY title, with all the fan disappointment in the ending.  If it was the receive the award, it would have to be just to spite the fans and show how little their input means to the higher-ups in the videogame industry.

[Icemix]

ME 3 is the GOTY, it has improved on everything from ME 2 and that game won more than 160 awards so that should say something. I myself despise the ending and I think it ruins the entire franchise, but the rest of the game is nothing short of amazing. You can nitpick all you want, no other game comming out this year can compere to the level of emotional involvement that ME 3 has. And how dare you people say that an Assassin's Creed game has a better chance at GOTY that ME? Are you out of your freaking minds?

[LeBurns]

Melancholic wrote...

PluralAces wrote...

GOTY means everything about the game was awesome

http://en.wikipedia...._of_the_Year.29

Intersting list thanks.

For the 2011 winners I played both Portal 2 and Skyrim and loved them both.  Biggest difference to me is I beat P2 in 11 hours and it has ZERO replay value since once you figured out a puzzle, you got it.  Skyrim I've just went over 550+ hours and am still waiting to try new characters.  Pretty soon I'll actually be at the point where Skyrim cost me only 10 cents an hour to play.  That's freaking incredible when I'm not even tired of it yet.

It's almost sad to see ME2 in those numbers, knowing that ME3 should have followed suit, but just failed because of the rush job BioWarEA did.

[SturmMedik]

No. Not even if the ending was good.

[ognick23]

chris2365 wrote...

Yes. 5 minutes of meh doesn't ruin 2400 minutes of pure awsomeness

i wish i could copy and paste this onto every thread here

[Resse]

Well, let me say it this way:

www.youtube.com/watch

Modifié par Resse, 13 avril 2012 - 02:43 .

[kalle90]

ognick23 wrote...

chris2365 wrote...

Yes. 5 minutes of meh doesn't ruin 2400 minutes of pure awsomeness

i wish i could copy and paste this onto every thread here

Pure awesomeness of eavesdropping a conversation, then going to scan clusters and play Benny Hill with the Reapers? Pure awesomeness of squadmates having barely anything to say? Pure awesomeness of majority of past choices forgotten, character X replaced with character Y or the X appears anyway? Pure awesomeness of combat that still can't match up to the best systems? Pure awesomeness of building an epic army and then noticing they decided to ditch the final battle anyway?

The game had around 20 minutes of pure awesomeness IMO (final resolutions of Tuchanka and Rannoch and some smaller bits here and there). Those were 10/10 material while most is 8 or 7, with the ending being a 3. If a 7/10 wins any sort of GOTY I'm really dissapointed with the games of 2012.

[Icinix]

No.

Its good - but not Game of the Year worthy. Even ending aside, there is too much in the game which is left a bit empty, and a lot of missed opportunities.

Its a good game, but not that good.

[Rothgar49]

nope

[fruton]

ZtalkerRM wrote...

Link Ashland 614 wrote...

For fans, just dissapointment.

For critics, it will be GOTY.

Did you hear that? Van Ord is making drool pools on the floor again...

Lol, I wrote to him about the problems regarding the face import situation, but he didn't end up writing a story on it.