392 réponses à ce sujet

[Persephone]

Skyrim keeps popping up....

If THAT game "deserves" GOTY then:

Tons of game breaking bugs

Mediocre character writing

A rinse-repeat plot (A prisoner...AGAIN?) 

.....will win you GOTY.

Shiny graphics sure work better than space magic, eh?

[The_Crazy_Hand]

 I don't think the gaming media would dare even nominate it, at least not without first locking themselves in a blast shelter.

[hoodaticus]

N7L4D wrote...

So Im just not gonna read the other posts because I have a feeling I have already if you get what I mean, anyways, I will say yes it should win GOTY

And likewise, I will never read your posts.  Blocked.

Modifié par hoodaticus, 15 avril 2012 - 12:15 .

[Persephone]

LordJeyl wrote...

No. And that's not just because of the ending. This game just doesn't do anything new. In fact, I would say it does less than what Mass Effect 2 did. Why would we award the title to game of the year to a product that has less features than the previous installment?

As for waiting for the Extended Cut, I don't think that's appropriate. A GOTY award should be given to a game that's able to stand on it's own without DLC or extended endings.

EC qualiies more as a patch, a HUGE one, mind you, but still. If the Witcher gets away with it & still has its fans vote it up as GOTY, why not ME3? And SKYRIM....needed LOADS of ECs to be PLAYABLE. It's still a dull dud story wise.

[Mixorz]

Maybe. Still got to check out Halo 4, and Borderlands 2.

[Persephone]

hoodaticus wrote...

N7L4D wrote...

So Im just not gonna read the other posts because I have a feeling I have already if you get what I mean, anyways, I will say yes it should win GOTY

And likewise, I will never your posts.  Blocked.

You cannot block posts, fyi.

[hoodaticus]

Persephone wrote...

hoodaticus wrote...

N7L4D wrote...

So Im just not gonna read the other posts because I have a feeling I have already if you get what I mean, anyways, I will say yes it should win GOTY

And likewise, I will never your posts.  Blocked.

You cannot block posts, fyi.

That sucks.

[sH0tgUn jUliA]

It's only April. Too early to tell. Until I see what the EC looks like the jury is out. The EC needs to be damned good.

[SpartanCommander]

NO!!!! the past 2 ones were good enough but this one NO!!!!

They could have achieved a trilogy with this which would be a first but they didn't.

[Drxx]

No.

[Myrmedus]

No. Ending cripples it for me.

When you're talking about a game being GOTY it needs to be at very high standards consistently and not take a nose dive at one of its most important moments.

[CELL55]

No matter your opinion on the ending, I think it's clear from the massive amount of fan hatred for it that it doesn't deserve it. Unless of course most of the game media continues to point at it in awe with doe eyes and jaw agape, muttering "art, oohh, aaahh". Besides, aren't there like nine GOTY editions a year? The award seems pretty meaningless to me.

[shrimprahmen]

yes. even though the ending was sloppy and just horrible. even the rest of the game can use work..but its all little things. the MP is pretty cool...got me into the MP side of things...since i dont usually play any MP games.

[krayt298]

WeAreLegionWTF wrote...

Not until it's finished.

[shrimprahmen]

i said yes....and i still hold to it..but its still early in year.....so if Diablo 3, Xcom: Enemy unknown, or darksiders 2 is better....i would say those games...oh and the witcher

[wantedman dan]

sdfgdsfsdfsfs wrote...

Not until it's finished.

Even then, no. Any unfinished game that is published, released, and disseminated without a proper ending is not deserving of such a prestigious title.

[Myrmedus]

Persephone wrote...

Skyrim keeps popping up....

If THAT game "deserves" GOTY then:

Tons of game breaking bugs

Mediocre character writing

A rinse-repeat plot (A prisoner...AGAIN?) 

.....will win you GOTY.

Shiny graphics sure work better than space magic, eh?

Sorry Persephone but the only aspects of a game you allude to there are the typical traits of BW games - you skip out a whole lot of quality found in other types of games completely and go straight to graphics. TES's quality has never really been centred on the plot. Oblivion won GOTY and its plot, voice acting, script etc. were mediocre but it's everything else the games do that make them so damn good. And I get it if those aren't really the types of things you're personally interested in but the GOTY award takes into account all gaming qualities not just writing and plot.

It's true open-world gameplay, not just hub-world, and you literally can lose yourself in the games for tens of hours. Combine the quality and refinement they present for such ****ing enormous games and it's crazy to be honest. The sheer fact Skyrim took that formula and added a pretty good plot and script on top was just insane, I never expected it to be honest and was amazed because these games have never struck me as having room for that kind of quality to be added bar a development cycle of 20 years or something.

Modifié par Myrmedus, 15 avril 2012 - 01:07 .

[CabooseNomerson]

GOTY no doubt. COD and Halo, even though I love Halo, are going to lose

[Darth_Trethon]

Not until it gets a GOTY-deserving ending it doesn't.

[felipejiraya]

These awards are stupid.

And Grand Theft Auto V will win it if the game really is released on October.

[Myrmedus]

felipejiraya wrote...

These awards are stupid.

And Grand Theft Auto V will win it if the game really is released on October.

Gah, I sort of hope not.

I thought the PS2 incarnations of GTA were immense but I couldn't believe IV won it - felt like a step BACKWARDS from SA to be honest.

[gmboy902]

With the ending as it stands, hell no. With clarification, perhaps just slightly. With a good, solid, meaningful ending, it is definitely in the running.

[Teukki]

So far, ME3 is the GOTY for me. Even with the unfinished/broken ending. There's just so much good in it. I just can't replay it yet, knowing nothing I did matters in any way at the end.

I'm planning to buy Witcher2 for X360, so there will probably be one challenger. It'll be a pretty good year, I'm sure.

[The Almighty Ali]

Nope, there are probably several other contendants for that, Max Payne 3 perhaps.