Not anymore.
Do you think Mass Effect 3 deserves GOTY?
Débuté par
Guest_the_geo_law_*
, avril 14 2012 06:07
Retour en haut
#153
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 12:38
Kia Purity
-
- Members
- 1 054 messages
I'm hesistant to even consider to be GOTY due to several reasons:
1) That stupid bug that ate my first Kaidan cutscene conversation on Normandy about his family!
2) MIssing out on several other conversations due to the same bugs (see Ken and Gabby -- because you apparently need Ash alive for that ???)
3) Starkid
4) See 3.
5) See 3.
6) THE COLORS. THEY DO NOTHING.
The game isn't as polished as I'd like it to be.
Still, I did enjoy it up until the ending which well, has the awesome ability to destroy the entire franchise. First time I've ever seen that /happen/.
1) That stupid bug that ate my first Kaidan cutscene conversation on Normandy about his family!
2) MIssing out on several other conversations due to the same bugs (see Ken and Gabby -- because you apparently need Ash alive for that ???)
3) Starkid
4) See 3.
5) See 3.
6) THE COLORS. THEY DO NOTHING.
The game isn't as polished as I'd like it to be.
Still, I did enjoy it up until the ending which well, has the awesome ability to destroy the entire franchise. First time I've ever seen that /happen/.
#154
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 12:47
FS3D
-
- Members
- 436 messages
Mass Effect 3: DOTY Edition
Disappointment Of The Year
Disappointment Of The Year
#156
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 12:50
Ultra Prism
-
- Members
- 1 456 messages
no until its story is complete ... right now it feels its left out for MORE SPECULATIONS!!!!!
#157
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 12:52
glacier1701
-
- Members
- 870 messages
As others have mentioned will depend on who actually votes in these things - if it is limited to those who gave it perfect scores then maybe but outside of that it doesnt deserve GOTY because it was very badly ended and killed off an entire franchise.
#158
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 12:53
MicMaky
-
- Members
- 22 messages
Nope, Unfinished and with very little replayability in single player and multiplayer...
#159
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 12:54
Shawn Marrster
-
- Members
- 115 messages
No.
The game is very short. Its rushed. Very DA2 over it.
It looks great. Plays great. But underneath its really bad.
I just replayed ME1. It have its flaws, but the story is much better.
The game is very short. Its rushed. Very DA2 over it.
It looks great. Plays great. But underneath its really bad.
I just replayed ME1. It have its flaws, but the story is much better.
#160
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 12:54
pharsti
-
- Members
- 1 010 messages
Not so far no.
Besides, didnt Skyrim come out this year? That thing will take GOTY, not that i agree by a long shot, but itll still take it.
Besides, didnt Skyrim come out this year? That thing will take GOTY, not that i agree by a long shot, but itll still take it.
#161
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 12:54
omikron199
-
- Members
- 165 messages
unfinished product does not deserve even to be released, hell no for goty
#162
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 12:56
Reign Tsumiraki
-
- Members
- 789 messages
Nope. My money's on Bioshock Infinite.
#163
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 12:58
incinerator950
-
- Members
- 5 617 messages
Not even close, and I'm inclined to allow a BF3 or MW2.5 Expansion take that at this point. Even ORC and ACV are lower in expectation.
I can like the endings, but this game? No, Fallout New Vegas can take RPG of the Year from the Witcher and DA, this game can fall behind the next Skyrim Expansion.
I can like the endings, but this game? No, Fallout New Vegas can take RPG of the Year from the Witcher and DA, this game can fall behind the next Skyrim Expansion.
#166
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 01:00
Reorte
-
- Members
- 6 601 messages
Skyrim was last November or December.pharsti wrote...
Not so far no.
Besides, didnt Skyrim come out this year? That thing will take GOTY, not that i agree by a long shot, but itll still take it.
ME3 isn't perfect even without the ending, although it's pretty good until then. My experience of other games is very limited (i.e. none whatsoever for anything released so far in 2012) but it's not impossible to top ME3 even if the ending was perfect.
#167
Guest_Catch This Fade_*
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 01:01
Guest_Catch This Fade_*
Guest_Catch This Fade_*
-
- Guests
The post that I initially responded to wasn't about the topic.slimshedim wrote...
jreezy wrote...
What you said isn't in conflict with what I said. Again, huge expectation leads to huge disappointment.Elite Midget wrote...
jreezy wrote...
Were you expecting Mass Effect 3 to be the Game of the Decade or something? Huge disappointment can only happen because of huge expectation.slimshedim wrote...
the_geo_law wrote...
Well? Do you?Do you think Mass Effect 3 deserves GOTY?
No, I rather think it deserves the title "Disappointment of the year" or maybe even "Disappointment of the decade/century" since that's just what it is.
No, we expected what Bioware promised. What they gave is radically different than all the promises they made for a whole year about ME3 being the next coming of Jesus.
Your argument is similar to the artistic integrity joker. Just dish it out and you can never be wrong again, right? Don't make the same mistake as Bioware did and point the finger at people yelling: "This is your fault!". Disappointment or not is not the topic here.
Modifié par jreezy, 14 avril 2012 - 01:03 .
#168
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 01:02
heathxxx
-
- Members
- 349 messages
Simply put, no. Not GOTY material.
Whilst it may be difficult for some to do so, let's forget the "ending". The game itself falls way to short of living up to either of the first two games. Not enough content or "substance" compared to the previous two games. Very poorly executed aspects to the game, with the fetch/carry "missions" being perhaps the best example.
Look beyond (or perhaps literally more accurate would be "before") the ending fiasco, there's much, much more wrong with the game, that's poorly designed and executed.
This was a game and culmination of a series of games, which warranted far more development time and leeway for Bioware, than it ultimately got. Anyone who's taken the time to look at the game without wearing those unavoidable "ending" goggles, can see that very clearly indeed.
Can't suggest alternative GOTY worthy selections at the moment, as the year is yet young, but even now, there's several games out there far more worthy of the accolade.
Whilst it may be difficult for some to do so, let's forget the "ending". The game itself falls way to short of living up to either of the first two games. Not enough content or "substance" compared to the previous two games. Very poorly executed aspects to the game, with the fetch/carry "missions" being perhaps the best example.
Look beyond (or perhaps literally more accurate would be "before") the ending fiasco, there's much, much more wrong with the game, that's poorly designed and executed.
This was a game and culmination of a series of games, which warranted far more development time and leeway for Bioware, than it ultimately got. Anyone who's taken the time to look at the game without wearing those unavoidable "ending" goggles, can see that very clearly indeed.
Can't suggest alternative GOTY worthy selections at the moment, as the year is yet young, but even now, there's several games out there far more worthy of the accolade.
Modifié par heathxxx, 14 avril 2012 - 01:03 .
#169
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 01:04
Vigil_N7
-
- Members
- 794 messages
Possibly, but there are plenty more games to be released.
It has all the credentials though, great story, awesome graphic design once again, improved and exciting combat, and the on-line multiplayer is really good, if not a little repetitive however.
It's definitely up there, but who knows? Plenty of more games to come out.
It has all the credentials though, great story, awesome graphic design once again, improved and exciting combat, and the on-line multiplayer is really good, if not a little repetitive however.
It's definitely up there, but who knows? Plenty of more games to come out.
#171
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 01:10
Otaku Hanzo
-
- Members
- 173 messages
heathxxx wrote...
This was a game and culmination of a series of games, which warranted far more development time and leeway for Bioware, than it ultimately got. Anyone who's taken the time to look at the game without wearing those unavoidable "ending" goggles, can see that very clearly indeed.
Exactly my point from previously! It needed at least another year. At least.
#172
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 01:12
elferin91
-
- Members
- 329 messages
Walgreen2345 wrote...
Halo 4 will likely be Game of the Year.
i don't even like halo, but i'd rather that they get it then ME3
#173
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 01:15
Occulo
-
- Members
- 472 messages
Yep.heathxxx wrote...
This was a game and culmination of a series of games, which warranted far more development time and leeway for Bioware, than it ultimately got. Anyone who's taken the time to look at the game without wearing those unavoidable "ending" goggles, can see that very clearly indeed.
Even if the game had endings worthy of the series, I still wouldn't vote Mass Effect 3 Game of the Year. The glitches, the horrible animations, use of stock assets poorly, retarded quest log, numerous fetch quests, requiring multiplayer to access the full ending... Yeah no.
#174
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 01:16
PrimeOfValor
-
- Members
- 456 messages
With soul-crushing, disappointing ending, no way!! Hell, if we knew about endings during before VGA 2011, we have never voted ME3 for the most accpaticated game of the year award, it should halo 4, diablo 3 or bioshock infinte.
#175
Posté 14 avril 2012 - 01:16
nitefyre410
-
- Members
- 8 944 messages
elferin91 wrote...
Walgreen2345 wrote...
Halo 4 will likely be Game of the Year.
i don't even like halo, but i'd rather that they get it then ME3
Mark my words watch everyone is iffy about Halo 4 and that game is going to be rather good. Reach was pretty good game that had a good story. The only problem was that awesome cast was Doomed by Plot because it was prequel.
Modifié par nitefyre410, 14 avril 2012 - 01:17 .
