220 réponses à ce sujet

[iamthedave3]

Mordin's death but only if betrayed.

If not it's triumphant. As in that thing the ending was supposed to be. He finally redeemed himself and laid all of his ghosts to rest, and did something that changes the universe for the better. In other words he did all of the things a doctor wants to be instead of all the things STG forced him to be.

[Mr.House]

-Mordins death
-Legions sacerfice
-The fall of Thessia and Liara's reaction
--All the final goodbyes at the FOB
-Andersons "I'm proud of you."

[robtheguru]

The moment when I wept because I realised I had been epicly trolled by Bioware.

[Menethra]

Try to watch this without feeling sad.



It's the Quarian destruction scene if you choose the geth followed by tali's suicide :'<

[PlatonicWaffles]

"You did good child/ son. I'm proud of you."

Modifié par Dylia, 14 avril 2012 - 04:43 .

[78stonewobble]

Darth_Trethon wrote...

Bfler wrote...

Tali's suicide. I only watched it via youtube but it almost broke my heart.

Same here....didn't get it, never will, so my in-game saddest is still Mordin and Wrex's deaths but really....there is no mass effect, no Shepard, without Tali...my Shep would have jumped after her regardless, the end.

Agreed.



@Menethra: I watched it... For the second time and I won't voluntarily watch it again. EVER! *makes shepards speech pointy finger before wiping watery eyes*

Modifié par 78stonewobble, 14 avril 2012 - 04:52 .

[animallover11]

Mordin. Luckily for me I was able to broker peace, so I never saw Tali die.

[Iakus]

Top five best "good" tragic scenes, roughly in order.

1)Thane's death/prayer for Shepard
2) Mordin's sacrifice
3) Conrad's death (interestingly, Conrad's "death" can also be one of the most amusing moments)
4)) The Illusive Man's death, if you paragon him "I tried, Shepard"
5) Traumatized asari's tale.  Made all the sadder when Joker tells you about his family on Tiptree

Bad tragic:

The ending.  Pure tragedy.

[noobcannon]

Bfler wrote...

Tali's suicide. I only watched it via youtube but it almost broke my heart.

[MACharlie1]

I would have to say when Grunt tells Shepard to go while he faces off with Ravagers. That silent glance that they give each other - they know damn well that Grunt won't make it out alive. This was the one moment in the entire series that I just wanted to hug someone.

But Grunt goes down taking several Ravagers. This moment turned from the saddest moment into the happiest moment when he then emerges from the cave covered in Rachni blood.

[Quietness]

The extended Anderson death speech (damn you for being cut)

[Beerfish]

dielveio wrote...

Tali's suicide.
I NEVER saw that coming.

I think Mordin was the saddet part but I agree about never seeing Talis coming.  I was really caught off guard.

[nickkcin11]

I think Legion's death was the saddest moment. He basically becomes an individual for a few seconds and in that time, he made the choice to sacrifice himself. And when Tali answers his question and he responds, "Keelah se'lai" and just kind of goes limp, I started to get goosebumps and my eyes started to water. Poor Legion.
Mordin's death was very sad too, with him singing that song again. But I expected Mordin to die, I didn't expect Legion to. Anderson's death was touching too.
Honestly, BW had a big chance to make Shepard's death extremely sad, like to the point where I actually cry. But it was so stupid, I just feel cheated.

Modifié par nickkcin11, 14 avril 2012 - 05:02 .

[Zix13]

Mordin, especially if you have to kill him.
Legion was sad, cause it was Legion, and Legion was ****ing awesome.
Um............. Everytime Shep forgot he was a biotic in cutscenes also made me very sad.

[Zardoc]

Darth_Trethon wrote...

Mordin's death and the sad thing is....there is no choice, the Krogan are just not ready to be cured, Wrex and Eve are just two Krogan and most are just too violent. Even without the genophage to avenge they'd start wars because that is what they do, that is what started the Krogan rebellions that forced the Turians and the Salarians to create the genophage in the first place, even Eve admits that most would now want revenge....I simply do NOT see enough improvement in them to believe they would be peaceful. Every playthrough I regret having to shoot Mordin and Wrex but trillions of lives are at stake and as a Spectre I have an absolute duty to ensure the universe gets the peace it deserves once the reapers are gone.

From a tactical perspective it also makes the most sense....the real threat are the reapers in the sky far more than the puppets on the ground and the Krogan bring nothing to that. I need the scientists to better build the crucible so it can be aimed only at the reapers and I need the salarian ships to help fight in the sky. Nonetheless at the end of the day I only lose Wrex and Clan Urdnot while I keep all the rest of the Krogan clans and the Turians are on board so at the end of the day that is the best result I can get....rest in peace my friends, you will be missed and honored but trillions of lives hang in the balance, I wish things went differently.

Wrex and Eve have the backing of pretty much all the females of the krogan, and seeing how they want to rebuild their culture and stop the pointless fighting, curing the genophage is a pretty good idea. Not curing it is a way bigger problem, because once the krogan find out they've been tricked there will be massive bloodshed, that will most likely only end once the last krogan is dead. By not curing the genophage you are essentially wiping out an entire species, one way or another.

Modifié par Zardoc, 14 avril 2012 - 05:05 .

[MrTijger]

Mordin sacrificing himself, while heroic it was also very sad, his line about sea shells was very poignant.

Anderson dying was another hard hitting moment.

[Skarwael]

Menethra wrote...

QuintSWE wrote...

Mordin, trying to crawl his way to the console to fix the sabotaged cure after beeing shot in the back by Shepard.

There's a special place in hell for mordin killers :<

Curing the genophage is a biiiiig mistake, and it doesn't matter who's in charge of them. Mordin was blinded by his own guilt.

[Phaedros]

heathxxx wrote...



Very "sad" indeed...

Yup!  Buy DLC ..  The Final Insult.

[Kara Nan]

The game had quite a few (very well done) sad moments. However the one that hit me the hardest was Thane's death.
It was so obvious that it was coming, I mean it's basically the very first thing you hear when you meet him for the first time. "I'm dying." Yet when it finally happened, it hit me like a sack of bricks. Like I didn't want to believe it and never truly did.
I hadn't even romanced him in ME2 on my first playthrough and I still cried like a baby. I seriously couldn't play for a few minutes. I had to put down the controller and just sob for a while.
Incredible writing on that part.

Mordin's death comes in second for me.

I also cried at the ending but for... different reasons.

[Bob Walker]

Not necessarily the saddest scene, but I felt it was very moving when Shepard pondered if he/she was a VI who thought it was Shepard when they were inside Cerberus base.

[Samtheman63]

Mordins death is horrific

I shot him too, which makes it x1000 worse once the guilt sets in

[Mr. Big Pimpin]

Legion's death.

[BecBec]

 The 2 scenes that made me cry were the final talk with Anderson and the talk with Liara before the romance scene. I always lose it at "It would be easy for a ship to get lost up there wouldn't it? To find some place very far away where you could spend the rest of your life in peace and happiness."  

[Crazyjeffy]

....There was A LOT of emotional scenes. Everyone already listed em.

[desertwoman]

Legion's death.