20 réponses à ce sujet

[Stardusk]

Someone told me today that it only affects normal melee and not heavy melee. Can someone confirm this or post a source? Otherwise I will stop using it, cheers.

[peddroelm]

I will test this tomorrow - I am just about to go to sleep - and testing this takes time ...

[Biotic_Warlock]

It boosts both types.

[Stardusk]

Tested it. Yes, it does make heavy melee better.

[PsychoXR-20]

This seems like a good topic to ask this question, I'm sure its a stupid question, but do the melee mods continue to give benefit even if said weapon is holstered? If I take a shotgun and a pistol both with a melee mod will I get 2x the benefit, or only the benefit of the weapon I am currently holding?

[Felonious_Monk]

Why would you gain the benefit of something you're not using?

[Zenning]

Felonious_Monk wrote...

Why would you gain the benefit of something you're not using?

Space magic?

[Reciever80]

Zenning wrote...

Felonious_Monk wrote...

Why would you gain the benefit of something you're not using?

Space magic?

The greatest troll answer that's ever been invented on these forums. You can't argue with that kind of logic.... it's the answer to everything.

[PsychoXR-20]

Felonious_Monk wrote...

Why would you gain the benefit of something you're not using?

Why does it affect heavy melee then? Heavy melee doesn't use the weapon.

[Chugster]

PsychoXR-20 wrote...

Felonious_Monk wrote...

Why would you gain the benefit of something you're not using?

Why does it affect heavy melee then? Heavy melee doesn't use the weapon.

im sorry, but what part of a Krogan swatting someone round the head with their weapon like its a baseball bat did you miss?

[Speedoburito]

I do believe someone just got powned.

[stindo27]

Chugster wrote...

im sorry, but what part of a Krogan swatting someone round the head with their weapon like its a baseball bat did you miss?

yeah but I haven't noticed any shocking or stabbing during the process

[Felonious_Monk]

PsychoXR-20 wrote...

Felonious_Monk wrote...

Why would you gain the benefit of something you're not using?

Why does it affect heavy melee then? Heavy melee doesn't use the weapon.

The Krogans do heavy melee with their weapons. The weapon is at least in use in some form, even if the heavy melee *animation* doesn't use it. Either way, it doesn't make sense for the player to benefit from the stats of an item they are not using.

[peddroelm]

Ok  SP test results are in


Infiltrator Heavy Attack vs Ravager Insanity (35% Melee Damage from fitness)

H Attack with Viper drawn
6000 - 5392.5 = 607.5  
450 * (1 + 0.35) = 607.5  As expected

========================

H Attack with Scimitar // Predator drawn with melee add-on 22.5 %

6000 - 5255.8125 = 744.1875 HA

SURPRISE
450 * (1 + 0.35) * 1.225 = 744.1875
NOT ONLY DID THE MELEE ATTACHMENT WORK WITH HEAVY MELEE - IT ALSO STACKS MULTIPLICATIVELY with the bonuses from passives


=======
also tested normal attack

6000 - 5751.9375 = 248.0625
150 * (1 + 0.35) * 1.22500 = 248.0625

==================
==================

The melee add-on acts in a similar manner to a weak head shot modifier (*1.25 at  lvl V) for melee attacks (both normal and heavy)  ...

Modifié par peddroelmz, 16 avril 2012 - 04:36 .

[A Huge Surprise]

Zenning wrote...

Felonious_Monk wrote...

Why would you gain the benefit of something you're not using?

Space magic?

Seems legit. 

[KroganSmash]

Zenning wrote...

Felonious_Monk wrote...

Why would you gain the benefit of something you're not using?

Space magic?

This. Couldn't be more legit if it was from Bryan himself

[Eric Fagnan]

The melee mods affect regular melee and heavy melee.

[Mabari Owns High Dragon The 2nd]

Melee is melee, I never question whether it boosted Heavy Melee because it is MELEE.

[KroganSmash]

Eric Fagnan wrote...

The melee mods affect regular melee and heavy melee.

Hmm interesting. now the question i have, is that is melee damge capped? or say will all the power rank ups stack?

[Shampoohorn]

Eric Fagnan wrote...

The melee mods affect regular melee and heavy melee.

Followup question:  Does the weapon type have any effect on melee damage?  Does a krogan heavy melee with a claymore do the same damage than a krogan heavy melee with a shuriken?  Sometimes I run around with a scorpion+tazer on my krogan soldier.

Thanks!

Modifié par Shampoohorn, 16 avril 2012 - 10:28 .

[embracethymisery]

Shampoohorn wrote...

Eric Fagnan wrote...

The melee mods affect regular melee and heavy melee.

Followup question:  Does the weapon type have any effect on melee damage?  Does a krogan heavy melee with a claymore do the same damage than a krogan heavy melee with a shuriken?  Sometimes I run around with a scorpion+tazer on my krogan soldier.

Thanks!

I was just wondering the same thing, although I'm wondering for the Geth. Will a heavy melee with the shotgun/blade attatchment do more damage than a heavy melee using a pistol/stunner attatchment?

Modifié par embracethymisery, 19 avril 2012 - 03:29 .