57 réponses à ce sujet

[interesting03]

Oh, i know. Freeing the werewolves from the curse, only to kill them after wards. That was pointlessly cold and evil.

[OneBadAssMother]

Oh, i know. Freeing the werewolves from the curse, only to kill them after wards. That was pointlessly cold and evil.

On elf playthroughs its easily justifiable.

[interesting03]

OneBadAssMother wrote...

On elf playthroughs its easily justifiable.

I don't know, i'd think a bitter elf would just be 100% pro-Zathrian,kill all werewolves on sight, etc,etc. Taking this route involves killing Zathrian and leaving the dalish without an experienced keeper. It doesn't really add up.

[OneBadAssMother]

True, I meant just the killing the humans part xD

Overall though you're right.

[Mnemnosyne]

Lotion Soronnar wrote...

Kuravid wrote...

Koyasha wrote...

To be honest, the thing that feels most "evil" to me throughout the game that I have done so far, is killing Loghain. There's no reason other than vengeance to do it, and every reason not to.
I suppose purging the Circle is probably also a pretty "evil" thing in my point of view, but at least that has some logic to it.

Yep, I agree with you there about the killing Loghain bit. There's no reason to do it other than to please Alistair's sense of vengeance (and your own, I guess, if you're playing it that way).

Wrong. There is EVERY reason to kill him (or throw him into prison for life).

While I've changed my opinion on this being the most "evil" moment in the game, I disagree that there is much reason other than vengeance to kill him.

As Riordan says (and later explains) there are compelling reasons for having more Grey Wardens about.  Furthermore, Loghain is better for the people and for the country as the Hero of River Dane who also died defeating the Blight, rather than a fallen hero-turned-tyrant.  Never a good thing to taint heroes in the eyes of the people, no matter how much they might deserve it.  Make him a legend and a symbol of a great person who gave everything for Ferelden, no matter what the truth might be, and the country will be better for it.

[Galad22]

Koyasha wrote...

While I've changed my opinion on this being the most "evil" moment in the game, I disagree that there is much reason other than vengeance to kill him.

As Riordan says (and later explains) there are compelling reasons for having more Grey Wardens about.  Furthermore, Loghain is better for the people and for the country as the Hero of River Dane who also died defeating the Blight, rather than a fallen hero-turned-tyrant.  Never a good thing to taint heroes in the eyes of the people, no matter how much they might deserve it.  Make him a legend and a symbol of a great person who gave everything for Ferelden, no matter what the truth might be, and the country will be better for it.

Stalin is still seen as somewhat of a hero in Russia, I wouldn't call it a good thing. Nor would I say that Russia is better thanks to it.

[Vaeliorin]

Purple Lady wrote...
Chose to kill on a whim in the dwarf noble origin. Evil and made me laugh a lot. It's good to be bad.

I actually did this today (I'd somehow lost my achievement for the dwarf noble origin, so I just played through the origin part again) and it was pretty hilarious.  "Gorim, why is this man talking to me?  Kill him."

[Mnemnosyne]

Galad22 wrote...

Stalin is still seen as somewhat of a hero in Russia, I wouldn't call it a good thing. Nor would I say that Russia is better thanks to it.

Perhaps, but the difference is significant there.  Loghain did a lot of good for Ferelden overall, far more good than he did bad.  I couldn't say the same about Stalin and Russia, however - indeed, finding the things that he did which did benefit Russia is probably difficult.
Loghain's crimes took place over a period of months, and the worst he did (that would be written into history if you make him a legend) is to try to bully the Bannorn into defending Ferelden.  The rumors of him betraying the king at Ostagar would remain rumors, and soon be forgotten in the wake of his heroism at defeating the Blight.