179 réponses à ce sujet

[BellatrixLugosi]

I think it should be nominated at least. Whether it actually deserves it, well there's other games coming out this year that have so far have shown some nice caliber so its up to the competition.

[kbct]

slyguy200 wrote...

bleachorange wrote...

if they fix the plot problems, sure. if not, no.

With all of the upcoming competition for them, i doubt ME3 will win

I would think there would be zero chance given the public backlash over the ending. After all, the EA ad said this is the biggest reaction to the ending of a game ever. I don't think the reaction was postive.

[Shadow Shep]

bclagge wrote...

DJCubed wrote...
I know that's an opinion and all, and I am also frustrated with EA more often than not.  That being said, worst company in America?  Like of all the companies in America?  I can surely think of a number that are far worse in my opinion.

http://consumerist.c...a-for-2012.html

Actually it's a fact that EA was recently voted the worst company in America.  "Worst" is ultimately an opinion of course, but it's an opinion shared by most of the people who voted.

I really don't want to sound like I'm defending EA's here, and that was an Interesting article.  It certainly does bring up some of the dirty tactics EA likes to employ, but I dunno I just feel like it is making a bit of a leap to say they are the absolute worst.  This again comes back to the opinion thing so I'm not going to try and press that mine is somehow more valid.  On the contrary it sure does speak volumes to look at the number of people who made that vote. 

I'm getting a bit off topic though, so in regards to the OP no I do not feel ME3 should be given GOTY at this time (and that's not likely to change)  

[MagmaShishio]

I can't give it such support no. Hoping Bioshock Infinite takes the title this year. If it is as good as it looks.

[Il Divo]

kbct wrote...

Il Divo wrote...

Potentially. It will depend largely on how Bioshock Infinite, Assassin's Creed 3, Halo 4, and the Witcher 2 turn out. I'm curious, to say the least.

All else equal, you have a 20% chance, Il Divo...

I've had worse odds. Luckily, I keep my d20 close at hand.

[Uriko128]

 Its quite soon to say they deserve the Game of the Year Award, but at least, they have to be nominated of course.

Skyrim and The Witcher 2 will be hard rivals.

Modifié par Uriko128, 17 avril 2012 - 02:55 .

[Mria]

DJCubed wrote...

Mria wrote...

 EA was already the worst company of america.

I know that's an opinion and all, and I am also frustrated with EA more often than not.  That being said, worst company in America?  Like of all the companies in America?  I can surely think of a number that are far worse in my opinion.

That being said, at current I do not believe it should be game of the year.  I also have taken a break from playing cause I feel disconnected from my Shep.  After I finally complete the game i'll have a more definite opnion on the matter.  Just my .02

Actualy that was a vote from a real contest 

http://consumerist.c...a-for-2012.html 

If i think that is correct ? no, Different from the BoA, EA hasn't destroyed lives and i think the vote made by ppl was not right and missguided somehow, but defnetly we can all agree that EA has become more of a cancer then a actual company and that bioware is following its downfall.

[Eclipse merc]

Nope, other games will probably get that title.

[Lee T]

The year is still young, ME3 isn't in a good position to be my GOTY but I see no point in declaring it a winner or a looser while there's 8 months to go.

Modifié par Lee T, 17 avril 2012 - 03:53 .

[Mria]

Hey ppl check my poll as well and send your vote !

Btw, check the vote choices color and peoples opinion in the poll and tell me what you see there =p

Modifié par Mria, 17 avril 2012 - 04:08 .

[TheRealJayDee]

mauro2222 wrote...

HellbirdIV wrote...

Mass Effect 3 will be voted "Game of the Year" by people who assume the ending is the only problem with it and therefore don't want to "give in" to fan backlash.

The ending is the worst part sure,but there are plenty of huge flaws with the game as a whole which left it massively disappointing and in many ways a technical failiure, so no, I really don't think it should be on anyone's Game of the Year list.

+1

+1

[loungeshep]

OUtside of the flawed ending, yes, it should be a game of the year game.

[MelodicGrim]

Well me3 was a good game, minus the bugs and glitches and the horrid ending... It still had a solid emotional storyline (until the end). Seeing how their false advertisement ploys and the way they "handle" their forums I don't think they deserve to even be on the list. They screwed up, gave us a rushed product. They hide behind the term "artistic Intergrity" They aren't even using it correctly. They claim they listen but they aren't. They shouldn't get any award what so ever. If me3 had more elements from the first 2 and it had an ok ending id want it nominated. 

Modifié par MelodicGrim, 17 avril 2012 - 04:39 .

[Gleym]

Hell no. Let a game that actually deserves it get the title. Any site that gives it ANYTHING 'of the Year' short of 'Biggest Letdown' should lose its merits.

[Overule]

I want ME3 to be cautionary tale of the year.

[Mercedes-Benz]

No.

[MrRag]

BiancoAngelo7 wrote...

ME3 does not deserve any awards after betraying its fans by focusing on rushing the completion of the game at all costs and gouging the consumer for content that was already ON DISK, don't believe me, google it.

And that's not even mentioning the whole "the last mission and ending was so bad it made me cry" part...

Basically this and for telling everyone who didn't like the ending to deal with it.

ME3 would easily win "Most disappointing game ending of 2012" tho.

[Degs29]

Not yet.  Maybe later.  You know, after they CHANGE  the endings, instead of elaborate on them.

Modifié par Degs29, 17 avril 2012 - 05:14 .

[EHondaMashButton]

The only competition so far is Kingdom of Alamur, which I haven't played. So I'd say yea until Max Payne comes out, or if the Witcher 2 can be counted twice.

[Farbautisonn]

Overule wrote...

I want ME3 to be cautionary tale of the year.

-Dont worry. It will go down in history as a shiny example of how not to:

1) Write a story.

2) Disregard your fanbase till it gets Irate and then continue.

3) Engegage PR and spin reps against your loyal fanbase.

4) Handle consumer wishes.

Plenty more examples but those are the ones that stand out.

[hypothead]

No.

[Niulus Kriyk]

If the other games turn out to be crap, ie. Max Payne, Ghost Recon, Halo 4, Bioshock, Assasins Creed. ME3 could still be a GOTY for me.

Uriko128 wrote...

 Its quite soon to say they deserve the Game of the Year Award, but at least, they have to be nominated of course.

Skyrim and The Witcher 2 will be hard rivals.

Why do people keep forgetting that Skyrim was GOTY last year? And Witcher 2 I doubt it will be eligible.

[Kakita Tatsumaru]

ME3 being the best game of the year was what I hoped before playing it, so in that regard I wish ME3 to be GOTY. But as it really is, with numerous annoying bugs, watered down role playing part, horrible ending, side quest journal useless, boring side quests, no exploration, still nerfed squadmates to force player to play the game Gear of War like instead of a more RPG fashion, etcs... No, I don't wants it anymore.