179 réponses à ce sujet

[Grimwick]

ME3 doesn't deserve it with respect to the ending and the quality of it's prequels. BW doesn't deserve a GOTY for being so arrogant and condescending about the whole affair.

As a standalone? Maybe.

[abaris]

I'm not sure.

The whole gaming industry is going down the money drain for some years now. You haven't got the feeling of embarking on a real adventure but having bought a cheap ride on the streamlining express. Might be that they deserve it after all, but not because they or their product are so good, but because the competitors have managed to produce something even weaker.

[DatIrishFella]

The auto dialogue killed it for me, so, no. It might be trivial to some people but it was the reason I replayed Mass Effect 1 & 2 countless times.

[megabug7]

No chance. The gameplay/story (up until the last 10 minutes) was great.

But no game deserves GOTY for being rushed, buggy and filled with negative controversy.

Thing is we (the fan) don't get a say if the game is awarded GOTY!

[Matic1093]

lonedude73 wrote...

slyguy200 wrote...

Matic1093 wrote...

No. Ghost Recon:Future Soldier is my personal GOTY. Supreme tactical 3rd person shooter, with gun smith=win in my books.

Halo 4 gets my vote.

me too

I am looking forward to Halo 4, but I prefer 3rd person tactical shooters, and I LOVE the idea of making "real" virtual firearms.

[Olueq]

no. **** ME3.

[Cancer Puppet]

No. The way Bioware handled the ending fiasco, and subsequently treated their fans, means no GOTY as far as I'm concerned.

Who knew being condescending to people made them angry?

[Cadence of the Planes]

I don't really care what a bunch of writers/judges think about the game, so I'm indifferent to it winning game of the year. What matters is that I enjoyed it

[Dendio1]

Witcher 2>Skyrim Mmk?

[Sgt.Catman]

With that atrocious ending, not a chance in hell.

[Bajger]

Real ending we will see in Summer. Without ending it is for sure one of the main games in this year and candidate for GotY award.
Witcher 2 and Skyrim was the best RPG in the last year.
At the moment for me: YES, but lets wait for Diablo 3, GW2 or Max Payne 3 and then we will see.

[Scam_poo]

I'll be quite sad if it's not GOTY, it's a great game. You guys are trolling about the ending a thousand times a day, whereas the overall game was just plain incredibly epic.

[Chewin]

No.


Even if they fixed the endings, it wouldn't change it.

[Occulo]

Even if the endings weren't terrible, I wouldn't vote Mass Effect 3 Game of the Year. Too many terrible design flaws that jolt the player out of the game and create impassable rifts between the player and Shepard.

[OutlawTorn6806]

Scam_poo wrote...

I'll be quite sad if it's not GOTY, it's a great game. You guys are trolling about the ending a thousand times a day, whereas the overall game was just plain incredibly epic.

Truth. Its defniitely a GOTY for me, as well as being one of my favorite games of all time.

[Trebor1969]

nope

[turian councilor Knockout]

It was okay but far from Goty.

[Guanxii]

I think 'Game of the Year' awards are a bit like TIME's 'Person of the Year'. It doesn't necessarily reflect the quality of the game; but the level of cultural impact it had for better or worse. For that reason I think it's probably in the bag.

[ObserverStatus]

MarchWaltz wrote...

No, I want it to be fail of the year.

RE6 or Diablo 3 deserve GOTY.

u crazy?  Capcom has announced that to make it sell better, they're going to tak out even more survival horror elements and make it more lamestream than RE5 was.

Modifié par bobobo878, 24 avril 2012 - 09:16 .

[The Sarendoctrinator]

If it means they'll release a GOTY edition with the DLCs on the disc? Yes.

If not, then it doesn't really matter to me. Sometimes the chosen game of the year is something that I would never even consider playing because it's just not my taste. And aren't there several different groups that choose their own game of the year? It's just that reviewer's opinion. I saw at least one reviewer call DA2 their biggest disappointment, but it was my favorite game that came out last year. It is nice to see the games I like succeed though.

As for ME3, I have mixed feelings about it. I'm really enjoying the game, but it has a lot of problems, and I'm not just talking about the ending. Yesterday, I played a mission where the dialogue audio didn't work for half of it, and most of those lines wouldn't even show up on subtitles. In spite of all that, it might still end up being my favorite. Amalur is great, but so far, I'm having more fun playing ME3. I just bought Witcher 2's enhanced edition, so I can't comment on it yet.

[TwelfthCrusader]

There is no single Game of the Year. Every single gaming website out there will be holding their own Game of the Year with different results and one of them is bound to pick Mass Effect 3. Everybody will have their own individual preferences to where they get information on what is GOTY but more likely they'll decide what they thought was the best game of the year themselves.

[Drake_Hound]

WTF the game that killed Bioware as I knew and now a long lost friend , has to win the game of the year award ?

People and there stupidity know no bounds LMAO .
Righto lets vote back Stalin in power ! cause atleast the streets are safe at night !

[Fearloc]

No ME3 does not deserve GOTY. Bioware took a starchild to the knee.