153 réponses à ce sujet

[Fedi.St]

Hale;s voice is tough. Reeminds soldier. Though doesn't fit the default femshep face.

[Oldbones2]

Nah, JH hits the nail on the head just right for me. She's half the reason I even play FemShep.


Meer FINALLY did a great job with ME 3, but he still isn't up to JH' standard.

[lillitheris]

CC-Tron wrote...

My view is Meer was good in ME1 as renegade and that was consistent through all 3 games. His paragon has improved since ME1. Hale was better at paragon in ME1 but her renegade has never been all that great. The scene that comes to mind is the tone she used in ME2 to tell Kal' Reegar to stand down. It was over the top.

That's a good example, really. As I said, I hugely prefer Hale, but those scenes she doesn't sound good. I think she should have gone more for a slow, growly delivery than volume.

I hear Meer's better in ME3; I might give a try, although thus far I've not been convinced by the various YouTube clips.

[CC-Tron]

lillitheris wrote...

CC-Tron wrote...

My view is Meer was good in ME1 as renegade and that was consistent through all 3 games. His paragon has improved since ME1. Hale was better at paragon in ME1 but her renegade has never been all that great. The scene that comes to mind is the tone she used in ME2 to tell Kal' Reegar to stand down. It was over the top.

That's a good example, really. As I said, I hugely prefer Hale, but those scenes she doesn't sound good. I think she should have gone more for a slow, growly delivery than volume.

I hear Meer's better in ME3; I might give a try, although thus far I've not been convinced by the various YouTube clips.

Don't worry about being convinced. I don't think he's any better or worse in ME3. You just don't like his delivery and that's fine.

[Dorryn]

lillitheris wrote...

CC-Tron wrote...

My view is Meer was good in ME1 as renegade and that was consistent through all 3 games. His paragon has improved since ME1. Hale was better at paragon in ME1 but her renegade has never been all that great. The scene that comes to mind is the tone she used in ME2 to tell Kal' Reegar to stand down. It was over the top.

That's a good example, really. As I said, I hugely prefer Hale, but those scenes she doesn't sound good. I think she should have gone more for a slow, growly delivery than volume.

I hear Meer's better in ME3; I might give a try, although thus far I've not been convinced by the various YouTube clips.

Agreed, I do love Hale's VA and I only play as femshep but that line makes me cringe every time. I guess she was instructed to give that line like her voice needed to be heard over very loud gunshot, which is true overall in the scene but not at that precise moment.

As for Meer well... Haven't tried maleshep in ME3. I wanted to make one in ME2 and romance Tali but then I got to meet and talk to Kelly and she said "I knew I could close my eyes, fall back and you'd be there" and Shepard said "I might do more than catch you Kelly" and then I couldn't hear anything else cause my head was buzzing and blood was oozing from my ears...

After I managed to get ahold of myself I deleted that career quickly, and with my whole body trembling I swore that I would NEVER try to play as a maleshep again.

[GhostV9]

I agree.

[BourneBengal]

Alright and?

Seriously, why even post it?

Fine you find the woman overrated, she's still getting roles and is in a profession most people will never have the success she has.

[s17tabris]

Dorryn wrote...

lillitheris wrote...

CC-Tron wrote...

My view is Meer was good in ME1 as renegade and that was consistent through all 3 games. His paragon has improved since ME1. Hale was better at paragon in ME1 but her renegade has never been all that great. The scene that comes to mind is the tone she used in ME2 to tell Kal' Reegar to stand down. It was over the top.

That's a good example, really. As I said, I hugely prefer Hale, but those scenes she doesn't sound good. I think she should have gone more for a slow, growly delivery than volume.

I hear Meer's better in ME3; I might give a try, although thus far I've not been convinced by the various YouTube clips.

Agreed, I do love Hale's VA and I only play as femshep but that line makes me cringe every time. I guess she was instructed to give that line like her voice needed to be heard over very loud gunshot, which is true overall in the scene but not at that precise moment.

As for Meer well... Haven't tried maleshep in ME3. I wanted to make one in ME2 and romance Tali but then I got to meet and talk to Kelly and she said "I knew I could close my eyes, fall back and you'd be there" and Shepard said "I might do more than catch you Kelly" and then I couldn't hear anything else cause my head was buzzing and blood was oozing from my ears...

After I managed to get ahold of myself I deleted that career quickly, and with my whole body trembling I swore that I would NEVER try to play as a maleshep again.

Yep, that line always made me cringe.  The delivery would have been appropriate if some loud gunfire noises on the background could be heard.

[CHALET]

BourneBengal wrote...

Alright and?

Seriously, why even post it?

Fine you find the woman overrated, she's still getting roles and is in a profession most people will never have the success she has.

Why post about the ending? Why post about how great the game is? Why post threads about Garrus? Why complain about the Thane romance?

[Haristo]

Mark Meer is not ''the lesser one'', both are great...

I just think that what you call ''desesperatly trying to look tough'' is in fact strong emotions. and that makes Hale the better one, even though both are awesome.

[Foxhound2121]

I think Hale is just overrated because everyone gives her the credit for femshep.

Mark Meer voice acting was far superior in my opinion. The renegade conclusion for Tali and Legion fight in ME2 was much better in acting with Mark Meer.

Meer performs it well with fluid emphasis and gives it intensity. Hale sounds like she is trying to whisper and yell at the same time in but can't make up her mind which one she wants to do in the renegade response.

Modifié par Foxhound2121, 24 avril 2012 - 12:54 .

[chengda85]

you big stupid jellyfish

[JohnTSCC]

I agree I'm already sick of Hale. she is just as overrated than Megan Fox.

[Vicious Mello]

I respect OP's opinion, though I sort of disagree with it. I think Jennifer Hale is absolutely fantastic, though I agree that Mark Meer is underrated. He was... sufficient in ME, improved greatly for ME2, and then really upped his game in ME3, to the point where I think he and Jennifer did jobs of similar quality.

I love them both and think they both did amazing work.

[Brian.V3]

Forget Hale, forget Meer... Blum FTW!!!!

[GhostV9]

Hale is really, really, bad at times. The "That's not gonna happen" renegade interrupt with Liara's father is hilarious. I'm sure the same can be said for Meer, but I honestly think they're both good and bad at times. It's really just fanboys and feminists going on and on about how much better she is.

[Hadea]

I love Hale's ME work. But the flirty dialogue with Jacob in ME2 sounded so creepy and awkward. I felt like my Shep was going to be slapped with a sexual harassment suit before she ever got a chance to save the galaxy.

[Cyne]

Her voice acting is quite good. FemShep is a strong, vibrant character because of her. That being said, it's clear that Mass Effect was written with a male protagonist in mind.

[Thepeak12]

Hadea wrote...

I love Hale's ME work. But the flirty dialogue with Jacob in ME2 sounded so creepy and awkward. I felt like my Shep was going to be slapped with a sexual harassment suit before she ever got a chance to save the galaxy.

HAHAHA this one wins.

[lillitheris]

GhostV9 wrote...

It's really just fanboys and feminists going on and on about how much better she is.

Really?

Really?

Sure hope there aren't any fanboy feminists or feminist fanboys in there. Who knows what THEY might do.

Modifié par lillitheris, 24 avril 2012 - 03:48 .

[nocbl2]

Y U NO COMPROMISE FORUMS

[CHALET]

Brian.V3 wrote...

Forget Hale, forget Meer... Blum FTW!!!!

Blum just does the same voice for every role. It's an awesome manly voice but it is still the same voice. Every. Time.

Modifié par CHALET, 24 avril 2012 - 12:11 .

[Agent_Dark_]

Hadea wrote...

I love Hale's ME work. But the flirty dialogue with Jacob in ME2 sounded so creepy and awkward. I felt like my Shep was going to be slapped with a sexual harassment suit before she ever got a chance to save the galaxy.

I found that hilarious in an awesome way.  Chicks are allowed to be sleazebags too lol. 

[Random Geth]

GhostV9 wrote...

Hale is really, really, bad at times. The "That's not gonna happen" renegade interrupt with Liara's father is hilarious. I'm sure the same can be said for Meer, but I honestly think they're both good and bad at times. It's really just fanboys and feminists going on and on about how much better she is.

Or people who think Hale does a good job and Meer can't play Shepard worth a damn.  There's that, too.

[Aleru]

i cant play Mass Effect with a fem shep because of jennifer hale's voice Dx
I mean...she sound too tough, even for a female badass soldier. It doesnt feel natural. Meer sounds more natural, he doesnt overact his character...and male shep sounds right.