esper wrote...
KiddDaBeauty wrote...
Cantina wrote...
I would like to know why is it if I choose to side with the mages and save Anders life, then choose to run away with him my character does not get that last “I love you” and a kiss? I felt like I was being punished and I chose the wrong side.
I suppose that's just how the scene plays out. Not all romances should do the same things at the same time, that's a good thing. And well, "Ten years, a hundred years from now, someone like me will love someone like you, and there will be no templars to tear them apart" is definitely one of my favourite lines ever. Oh the tears the first time I heard that line... I'd never trade that for a simple "I love you," myself =) Though of course, they're by no means exclusive.
It is also important to point out that Anders say 'I love you' times before that. He says it after the sex in act 2 and on friendship path he says it on his final question belief 'pillow talk'. There is no need to say it on friendship path in the Gallows pre-final fight talk, because that is not the issue. And I too would not trade Anders' final speech for something as simple as a kiss.
On rivalry path he doesn't say I 'love you' in question believe, but he does say it pre-final fight. I think it is a nice contrast.
And is characther is individuel so they shouldn't follow the same pattern.
Having contrast is nice and I understand the rivalry and friendship romances are different. Be rather silly if they were the same all around.
On the friendship path, Anders apologizes to Hawke for the events to come and believes he is going to die for his actions. Yes, he says he loves you (twice if you chose the right dialogue options), but for someone who thinks he is going to die, I would at least thought he want a kiss. That last moment of feelings expressed through physical contact.
However, aside from not getting a kiss in that scene, the fact is Anders believes this is the last time he will ever be able to express those feelings. In my case and the case of some other players, this is not true.
As far as I am aware if you rival Anders and chose the mage side, the ending stays the same. Were as if you side with Templars you have a different ending, the kiss etc.
Again, Anders expressed his feelings earlier simply because he assumed that was his final chance to do so. IF you chose to side with the Templars instead of mages, how then would he have known that you were going to spare his life and he have the opportunity to say and express his feelings? Contrast is nice to have, when it makes sense.
The final dialogues between Anders and Hawke could have been the same but different at the same time too. You do not need to remove the dialogue in order for it to happen.
This is a sample I wrote months back:
Hawke: Then we will be fugitives together
Anders: I should have seen it sooner. All you did for me,
for the mages. I never thought in my life that I would find someone who believes
as much as I do in this cause.
<Kiss>
<Pulls away and looks into Hawke’s eyes>
Anders: We will fight for a world, were are children can be
born mages and free. Ten years, hundred years from now, someone like me, will
love someone like you and there will be no Templars to tear them apart.
Anders: I love you
and always will. Please be careful for if you die tonight I will too.
May the Maker bring us victory or everything
else is meaningless.
If you chose to spare his life and stay with him, the conversation should come off with emotion and feeling. I just felt that not only saving his life but also staying with him, the conversation came off as wooden and shallow.
At any rate the dialogue should be different depending on the path you took, however just because you took a different path does not mean one side should get a kiss and the other should not, especially when the last conversation takes place.
Modifié par Cantina, 26 avril 2012 - 03:21 .