416 réponses à ce sujet

[Drummernate]

All these Prothean threads lead to major trolling.

No wonder I am here....

[SDW]

Zaraki kanzaki wrote...

before posting, if you're not agre with this thread please don't start to comment because ii'm a little stressed with people that continue whining about it, so please respect all the ideas

I'm indifferent about the topic. But when you make a petition for inclusion of Protheans, those who don't want them also have a right to tell Bioware so. Otherwise, with only "yes, we want it!" in the thread, they might put work into something that only a few people are interested in.
I do understand that discussing if it's worth it gets tiresome after a while. So, what about creating a poll?
Then everybody can leave a quick "Yes"/"No".

[a ViciousFerret]

Oh yah, and if Bioware ever does get around to making Prothean characters despite half the community clearly against it, please make the characters N7 rare?

If more Protheans are discovered, there still won't be many of them either way. Most of them I assume wouldn't be able to cope psychologically with the whole civilization being wiped out, 50,000 years into the future and reapers invading thing, and there would probably be a couple thousand Protheans wanting to return to fighting at most. It would make sense if they were N7 rare.

[Wesus]

Sure i dont mind if its n7 rare. Its just the fact they are possible.

[a ViciousFerret]

XxTaLoNxX wrote...

a ViciousFerret wrote...
The only simple-minded one is the one that thinks space magic can fix anything, even logical fallacies.

Actually the only simple-minded one is the one that thinks BioWare hasn't already used space magic to fix anything...
Or did you already forget about the Crucible?

And look where that brought Bioware.

And either way, how does that make using more space magic acceptable? Because the ending is ruined because of it, why not ruin the entire lore?

[Wesus]

They already ruïned the whole prothean lore,

Me 1 and me 2 extinct me3 they found one, if they made the story good , but no they left immense gaps Leaving so many possibilities with the protheans to be done,

[Nocturnalfox]

Wesus wrote...

They already ruïned the whole prothean lore,

Me 1 and me 2 extinct me3 they found one, if they made the story good , but no they left immense gaps Leaving so many possibilities with the protheans to be done,

As I said in last post I think it was BW ploy all along. I think they intend to add a "epilogue" of sorts and Protheans are going to turn up.
Either from stasis or come back from being collectors. Will probably try to take over the galaxy again as well. 

Might be canon, might not be 

Modifié par Nocturnalfox, 26 avril 2012 - 10:55 .

[Zaraki kanzaki]

SDW wrote...

Zaraki kanzaki wrote...

before posting, if you're not agre with this thread please don't start to comment because ii'm a little stressed with people that continue whining about it, so please respect all the ideas

I'm indifferent about the topic. But when you make a petition for inclusion of Protheans, those who don't want them also have a right to tell Bioware so. Otherwise, with only "yes, we want it!" in the thread, they might put work into something that only a few people are interested in.
I do understand that discussing if it's worth it gets tiresome after a while. So, what about creating a poll?
Then everybody can leave a quick "Yes"/"No".

it's simple:polls are not  very popular here

[Talhydras]

I appreciate that everybody's got their own thing they'd pay money to have in MP. For me, it's playable Rachni, and lots of people think that's bollocks cause of animation or engine limitations. That's cool! That's their right to voice the concern that BW would be better off diverting the significant resources needed to make a fully nonhumanoid MP playable character to other stuff like new weapons, new maps, new enemies, and bugfixes. Of course there's no lore problem since Shep was actively promised a Rachni army to fight the Reapers with in ME2, but even then since there's those other objections about resource allocation it remains a worthy idea subject to valid criticism.

In the case of MP Protheans, a lot of those same objections - that resources would be much better spent on fleshing out the other races, on bugfixes, and on new enemies and maps and gamemodes - still apply in addition to the huge lore problem.

I personally would be deeply annoyed to see Protheans running around my MP servers - and what's worse is I'd start getting the cards and I wouldn't be able to pretend it never happened. If it was paid DLC, I might actually have the option to not participate which would be kinda ideal; on the other hand if it gets bundled with something I do want, I'll be even more annoyed to have to pay for features I actively don't want to get things I do. 

So yeah... good luck, and I respect that you have your own vision for what you want to buy for DLC in ME3 MP, but if I have to share the MP game with Protheans I'm going to be upset. From a lore point of view, it's hard to believe other bunkers full of equally plot-useless Javikoid soldiers exist. From a story point of view, additional Protheans require rewriting of Javik. Some of Javik's survivor's guilt gets turned into pure wangst if Shep just finds a bunker full of his people, at least in my reading of it. Like that scene with Javik on the Citadel, with the Asari and Hanar all like "Oh hey, it's the last Prothean", except now Shep would be theoretically able to interrupt and be like "Naw, there's like ten thousand of them derping around the galaxy as special ops soldiers. Heck, this one I've got with me is honestly kind of lame. All he does is talk crap to my crew compared to these hardcore dudes in the N7 teams who actually work for a living."

Part of the success of Javik's scenes is that he, well, is the last Prothean. He says that exact thing several times if my memory serves me, so unless BW is gonna dummy those lines out in this hypothetical prothean addon, we'll have made the MP outright contradict all ME3 playthroughs as opposed to now where it only contradicts some with that whole geth/quarian thing. I hope then that I've not offended too much with my criticism, that was never my intent. I only wish to conscientiously object to the inclusion of Protheans.

Modifié par Talhydras, 27 avril 2012 - 12:25 .

[DasLeid]

No and hopefully never.

[Zaraki kanzaki]

as i wrote before, this is a thread dedicated for people who WANT to see prothean in next DLC, a way of reference, if you're not agree you should post in other posts, because i'm quite nervous of people that continues to insult each one, and this is refered also to people who is agree, because you are showing you're close-minded as someone who posted here

[Nocturnalfox]

People who argue lore are clueless anyway.
Think about it, if you only care about lore well why are you still playing the MP after completing SP- it doesn't make sense AFTER you beat the reapers all ready.

I think Protheans are coming, because at this point the MP is (or should be) more about fun then lore- because as I said the lore is is now broken.

It wont surprise me if they add DLC to explain more protheans, could be a simple online comic or video or even playable DLC.

The fact is they need more characters, enemies and maps.

[Mckay91]

They'll be happy if they released Protheans, and in the description by the character is said

"Discovered among the frozen ruins of "Planet XXX", 4 Protheans were discovered in Cryo-Tubes among the ruins of a Prothean Research Outpost, eager to avenge the death of trillions, these Protheans have agreed to fight the Reapers".

And the ****ing would cease. All this case of "Lore" is rubbish anyway, there is almost no lore in multi-player.

Modifié par Mckay91, 27 avril 2012 - 04:51 .

[mrcanada]

signed.

[uzivatel]

I demand playable clones of Shepard...

[CapnCruuunch]

I see the points of both sides, but ultimately I do support playable Protheans.

New game modes NEED to be the priority, in my opinion. I won't turn down new, cool ways to decimate the enemy. The geth chars were a fabulous addition. But, yeah, I would happily wait on all the Vorcha, Prothean, Elcor, Volus, Rachni chars if it meant (awesome) new game modes would roll out first.

If we can't have Protheans, I would happily accept the particle rifle, though not sure if it would be as awesome as it is in SP.

[Distilled Poison]

Multiplayer takes place during Shepard's gathering of war assests, and that's why Protheans won't happen. There were no legions of Protheans during that time, so there won't be any in multiplayer.

And everyone disregarding lore: Go play Gears of War or something. Mass Effect has been creating it's lore and story for three games now. Throwing it away for some kids with ADD who don't care about Mass Effect's amazing story is stupid.

Though I don't know why I bother pointing this out. Bioware has stated that multiplayer won't break lore, so that's comforting enough.

[Wesus]

Lol amazing story you say? Me 3 is horrible

Me1 and me2 protheans are extinct in me3 they got à prothean and no-one cries about it, everyone deals with it. During the SP we have Mordin Solus on board, all hè needs to do is take à tissue sample and sent it to his homeworld and there you go à clone. An other thing. Earth has got à helload of fallout shelters, do you think an advanced space civilisation would make only one cryo sleep complex on 1 planet? Hell no.

Kids with ADD, ADD is an disorder where people are agressive. As well your reported for that comment.

[MissMinaethiel]

Wesus wrote...

Kids with ADD, ADD is an disorder where people are agressive. As well your reported for that comment.

Not necessarily. I've got ADHD which = Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disorder xD

I'm not aggressive unless someone really pisses me off (or if my siblings and I are fighting over something =P). Mostly I just lack the attention span of a kindergartner and can't sit still for more than 10 minutes without fidgeting.

[Wesus]

Add is different from ADHD, ADD causes agression where ADHD causes hyperactivity Often combined with sleepless nights and the lack of Concentration.

[MissMinaethiel]

Wesus wrote...

Add is different from ADHD, ADD causes agression where ADHD causes hyperactivity Often combined with sleepless nights and the lack of Concentration.

Hm... glad I'm not aggressive then. My temper, when lost, is something that would never be found. Like the Protheans though, we could probably clone it! =O

Modifié par MissMinaethiel, 27 avril 2012 - 05:42 .

[An D]

Say "No!" to  Protheans, they are extinct.