Codeka wrote...
Smitridel wrote...
Codeka wrote...
See, the ending is so bad I don't even believe people when they say they liked it. Like I don't get the urge to argue or anything, I just don't even believe it's true no matter how hard I try,
How absurd/plothole ridden must something be for you to dislike it? What if godchild had been let's say a Polar Bear or if Joker was seen crashing the normandy into a Borg Cube - would you then think it was bad or would it still be a masterpiece?
You know, I can accept liking the concept of the ending. I dislike it strongly but I would respect an opinion or personal preference that was for the concept. The issue doesn't stopped there - The Ending was rushed and poorly implemented by the developers - throwing all artistic integrity arguments out the window.
It's a testimony to game dev failure, nothing else and so no smart/perceptive gamer can honestly like the ending. The can like the concept of the ending, the literary(lol) aspect of it but they can never honestly say it was well programmed/designed/thoughtout
Sorry for not quoting before. There are a lot of posts, you know, that I have not had the time to answer.
Although I really dont get on what you want me to answer.
I respect your opinion, I dont agree, I find it a little too focused on the details not getting the whole picture, but still it's okay with me.
Although would you kindly elaborate on the programming or development failure?
How was it rushed and poorly implemented/designed/ thoughtout?
The way I see it, they wanted to give that vague or maybe incoherent feeling throughout the last moments, to get you right to the point of doubting if thats all there is, or maybe you (the player) can read more into it.
EDIT: Its all down to personal belief.
I choose to believe that it was all intentional, while you choose to believe that it was rushed, possibly taking into account the leaked interview about the Bioware writer and the cutting the ending story, while I havent read all that untill I had finished the game.
Some opinion's have more merit than others. My opinion is supported by evidence you actually point out in your edit there. All that considered you choose to ignore the evidence and still believe 
Again, had they kept the ending as is but not rushed it - kept the space magic but with higher production values and no plot holes - I would not argue against you. It's not the case though, the ending is crap and I can't respect the opinion that it's good anymore than I could respect the opinion that actual crap (feces) is good.
All opinions on a game being pleasurable or not, have merit.
It's not a matter of evidence.
It's not a matter of popular belief.
It's a matter of
personal preference while backed up by arguments.
I detect a kind of elitism here, no?
If you didnt read the "evidence" would you still think of it as crap? Or maybe the "evidence" made it a bit crappier?
Again, I dont choose to ignore the...evidence.
I liked the ending for the reasons explained above.
Now that I know the evidence, it doesnt make a difference to me, because I got what they wanted to give to the player even while not knowing why they cut some elements of the ending.
Retour en haut
!
*gallows humor*
