183 réponses à ce sujet

[Michale_Jackson]

like seriously?  Traynor seems so fake and not communciative at all compared to the previous woman that filled that position.  

Why Bioware?  Why couldn't you leave well enough alone and let Kelly get her job back on the Normandy like Dr. Chakwas.

Do anyone else here dislike Traynor?


<< btw I'm a male Shepard.

[fle6isnow]

Kelly has PTSD. The poor thing should be nowhere near combat.

[arial]

I like Traynor, at least she has a personality (unlike Chambers).

not to mention
Chambers has been mentally traumatized after the collector base

[Gallimatia]

Kelly is the first to go if you don't hurry through the Omega relay. She is dead in many games. Even if they had her fill the role Traynor, or someone else, would have to be available as a replacement. That is the situation with Chakwas who is the last to go if you don't hurry (Michel being her replacement).

[VampireSoap]

Wait, are you saying this just because Kelly can flirt with you whereas Traynor is lesbian? I guess Traynor can be very "communicative" if Shepard is a lady. :lol:

Modifié par VampireSoap, 30 avril 2012 - 11:54 .

[chengthao]

b/c Kelly Chambers isn't Alliance or even former Alliance

[quickitsbob]

Kelly does not have any major reason to be affiliated with the alliance. The reason traynor is not a communicative is that she is a scientist in communication tech. Unlike Kelly who is psychologist that TIM chose to get Shepard to have a more positive view of Cerberus. Plus she had a little ptsd flashback if you talk to her right after being rescued. From a writing point of view Traynor is there to give missions without seeming too plot-devicey. Liara could have functioned the same way but then people on BSN would be whining about her as a creators pet 10 times worse

[Melca36]

Michale_Jackson wrote...

like seriously?  Traynor seems so fake and not communciative at all compared to the previous woman that filled that position.  

Why Bioware?  Why couldn't you leave well enough alone and let Kelly get her job back on the Normandy like Dr. Chakwas.

Do anyone else here dislike Traynor?


<< btw I'm a male Shepard.

Nope. I like her better than Kelly.

I think you're just mad because your straight.

[Sdrol117]

Melca36 wrote...

Michale_Jackson wrote...

like seriously?  Traynor seems so fake and not communciative at all compared to the previous woman that filled that position.  

Why Bioware?  Why couldn't you leave well enough alone and let Kelly get her job back on the Normandy like Dr. Chakwas.

Do anyone else here dislike Traynor?


<< btw I'm a male Shepard.

Nope. I like her better than Kelly.

I think you're just mad because your straight.

I prefer Traynor and I'm straight. 

[Mr.House]

Um Chambers and Sam have two different jobs.

[Michale_Jackson]

I'm not mad because I'm straight, after seeing how Jack's romance is a let down in ME3. I'm trying to go straight gay with Kaiden now.

Traynor is dull and that was just a bunch of writers bull puck they wrote for Kelly Chambers. How is she going to be traumatized by the Collector invasion when she acted perfectly fine after she was rescued and even partied with me at my cabin.

Bioware wasted their time replacing Chambers with a new non-personality Yeoman would they could have used that time to work on the story.

[Michale_Jackson]

simfamSP wrote...


This.

But besides that... Kelly was a joke of a romance and as flat as characters get. She was cool, yes, to that I agree. But Traynor actually DID something. She FELT like part of the crew...

And it was nice hearing another accent other than American/Canadian for once :-)

How did Traynor play like part of the crew?  I'm on my second male playthrough of ME3 and Traynor is just as dull and boring as my first run.   

Kelly was a real keeper, she always asked how were you doing, told you the status of the crew members, even offered to tidy up your Cabin.  You get none of these pleasentries from Traynor.

[quickitsbob]

Michale_Jackson wrote...

 How is she going to be traumatized by the Collector invasion when she acted perfectly fine after she was rescued and even partied with me at my cabin.
 

Apart from the first conversation where she has a thane-esque  ptsd flashblack of the base? She may act fine because she might be in denial about the effects of the base had on her emotionally.

[Hogge87]

I never cared more for Kelly. Traynor is WAY hotter, more interresting, more funny and so on. Whenever I get around to play Femshep, she's gonna romance Traynor in ME3.

[arial]

Michale_Jackson wrote...

simfamSP wrote...


This.

But besides that... Kelly was a joke of a romance and as flat as characters get. She was cool, yes, to that I agree. But Traynor actually DID something. She FELT like part of the crew...

And it was nice hearing another accent other than American/Canadian for once :-)

How did Traynor play like part of the crew?  I'm on my second male playthrough of ME3 and Traynor is just as dull and boring as my first run.   

Kelly was a real keeper, she always asked how were you doing, told you the status of the crew members, even offered to tidy up your Cabin.  You get none of these pleasentries from Traynor.

she did not do that because of her personality, she did it because TIM placed her there to spy on you

[Mr.House]

Michale_Jackson wrote...

simfamSP wrote...


This.

But besides that... Kelly was a joke of a romance and as flat as characters get. She was cool, yes, to that I agree. But Traynor actually DID something. She FELT like part of the crew...

And it was nice hearing another accent other than American/Canadian for once :-)

How did Traynor play like part of the crew?  I'm on my second male playthrough of ME3 and Traynor is just as dull and boring as my first run.   

Kelly was a real keeper, she always asked how were you doing, told you the status of the crew members, even offered to tidy up your Cabin.  You get none of these pleasentries from Traynor.

Because that was Kellys job, not Sams, Sam is the com officer. She helps with mission details, com chananels ect. Two diffrent characters, two diffrent jobs. The only thing they have in common is they tell you if you have a message, someone wants to see you and they are in the same place.

[Link Ashland 614]

Traynor is better than Kelly because she actually does something useful.

Now, if we could just pust Traynor and Chanbers together, your opinion would change completely.

[jeweledleah]

you are not supposed to like every character (or even returning character development). imagine how dull would life be if we all shared exact same preferences and opinions?

personally I liked both Kelly and Samantha.

I've grown to be greatly irritated by Vega and ME3 Joker.

etc, etc.

just, I guess accept that Samantha was written for other people rather then you.

[jlb524]

TRAYNOR

is awesome

[Ghost Lightning]

I wish I could get Kelly back. Traynor is so boring. Kelly is awesome.

[ADLegend21]

Kelly has PTSD after being captured and she was a ship psychologist. TRaynor is a communications specialist who's seeing her first frontline action as part of the Normandy's crew they're two separate people and they're both awesome. All the ME2 debut charcters get shafted anyway and guess which game Kelly came from! -____-

btw I love them both their romances are two of my favorites.

Modifié par ADLegend21, 01 mai 2012 - 12:31 .

[bleetman]

Michale_Jackson wrote...

Traynor seems so fake and not communciative at all compared to the previous woman that filled that position.

Considering that Kelly was onboard the Normandy to spy on Shepard, the irony of this is wonderous.

[The Minority]

I'd do Traynor's accent.