769 réponses à ce sujet

[M Hedonist]

Harbinger of your Destiny wrote...

So what did everyone score the ending? I gave it a 0.

I'd give it a negative score if I could as it does more harm to the story than adding anything to it. So, 0.

[AxisEvolve]

"0" seems too biased IMO. IF they were to seriously look at this survey then they'd probably just ignore all of the replies with that.

I hated the ending with every fiber of my being, but it's still worth a "4" to me.

[DiegoRaphael]

Survey done! Waiting on results.

[Abreu Road]

0 for the ending is valid.

If you can't count with the zeros, you can't count the perfect 10's too.

But we all know Bioware love 10's. They have 75 perfect 10's.

[AxisEvolve]

Abreu Road wrote...

0 for the ending is valid.

If you can't count with the zeros, you can't count the perfect 10's too.

But we all know Bioware love 10's. They have 75 perfect 10's.

I agree that it's valid. But is it honest for us to do, as fans? I just think it takes away from the credibility and might make someone at Bioware overlook it by saying "oh they're just trolls". Which would be a shame.. 

I'm not doubting that the 10/10's aren't biased also (At least from the media). But Bioware will obviously let that pass. 

Modifié par AxisEvolve, 01 mai 2012 - 06:54 .

[Pottumuusi]

Misleading title is misleading.

[Ubiquitous]

Ah come on, giving the ending a 0 is a bit too harsh. Because of Mansell it's worth at least a 1.

[GuardianAngel470]

Sauruz wrote...

Harbinger of your Destiny wrote...

So what did everyone score the ending? I gave it a 0.

I'd give it a negative score if I could as it does more harm to the story than adding anything to it. So, 0.

Depends on how you define the ending. I defined it as everything after the elevator, so felt no qualms about giving it a zero. The way I see it, there are no redeeming qualities to the ending we have. I mean that from a strictly logical perspective; I can think of no aspects that I consider positive about the ending. Star child is a terrible idea, dialog is poorly written, choices are poorly thought out, consequences are poorly explained, characters are poorly characterized/out of character, cinematics are lazy, what consquences we can tell are horrific, choices are as immoral as could possibly be devised, and so on and so forth.

I suppose the ending isn't bugged horribly, but I would have taken bugs over what we were presented with thematically and literarily. Besides, a lack of bugs is expected so there's no free points for doing the bare minimum.

[GuardianAngel470]

Ubiquitous wrote...

Ah come on, giving the ending a 0 is a bit too harsh. Because of Mansell it's worth at least a 1.

Good music, poor placement. Out of place music is a con not a pro.

[SuperEngineer]

Survey completed

[Trentest0]

I gave the ending a three. Because the presentation was fantastic. How you have to limp towards the choice you made whilst some serious awesome music plays and a huge space battle goes on in the background. It was VERY well designed.

Unfortunatly, the logic of the ending was outright terrible. Was not what I was expecting. Wish they'd gone with the Dark Energy plotline and expanded it... would have been so much better....

[CroGamer002]

Already did that survey.

[noobcannon]

 just filled it out. not a very long survey but very thorough. asked alot of the questions i was hoping it would.

thanks for linking.

Trentest0 wrote...

I gave the ending a three. Because the presentation was fantastic. How you have to limp towards the choice you made whilst some serious awesome music plays and a huge space battle goes on in the background. It was VERY well designed. 

Unfortunatly, the logic of the ending was outright terrible. Was not what I was expecting. Wish they'd gone with the Dark Energy plotline and expanded it... would have been so much better....

 

felt the saem way about the ending. although i gave it a 4

Modifié par noobcannon, 01 mai 2012 - 07:38 .

[ShdwFox7]

Number seven thousand something, took it, but found some parts were odd.

The question that asked your most emotional moment should have had more highlights listed. The part I got the most emotional was during the Thane vs. Kai Leng fight on the Citadel. The fan service Bioware pulled there had me standing out of my chair waiting for the victor. But since that choice wasn't there I choose my secondary favorite, Grunt's scene with the Rachni.

Not sure if I liked the scoring system. Gave the game pre-ending a score of ten. Gave the ending a score of zero. Gave the game overall an eight. I do my own rating on a scale of one to five, so that eight is really a four in my book. Was thinking about giving the ending a score of one at first. But after thinking about it, it's been almost two months since the game's release and I'm still talking about and still hating the ending so I ultimately went with the zero. I'm undecided if I should have lowered the overall product's score or not to better get my point across though. But I find it really hard to justify lowering a game's (or any product for that matter) score more than a single point, for only a single problem. For example: I hated how poorly balanced the Mako felt in ME1 on insanity mode. However, I still consider ME1 my favorite game and it's still a five out of five game in my book, despite the Mako issues.

I'm floored that the" will you buy more ME3 DLC" question didn't have a "only if the EC DLC is good" option. So I choose "No, not really" simply based on my skepticism in regards to the EC DLC.

My 140 character message was: "A good business listens to their customers, a bad one does not. I'll happily play and buy more DLC, only if, the EC DLC is satisfactory."

[ShdwFox7]

Trentest0 wrote...

I gave the ending a three. Because the presentation was fantastic. How you have to limp towards the choice you made whilst some serious awesome music plays and a huge space battle goes on in the background. It was VERY well designed.

Unfortunatly, the logic of the ending was outright terrible. Was not what I was expecting. Wish they'd gone with the Dark Energy plotline and expanded it... would have been so much better....

    I understand where your coming from but I disagree. Yes the presentation of the ending was great, I do not disagree with that. However, I look at it in this way: a video game is an interactive story. You can have great music/graphics/whatever, but, if the story doesn't hold up, then the rest of it doesn't really matter. An analogy: If I were to order a hotdog and it came with a bun, ketchup, and mustard, but no actual hotdog, can it still be considered a good hotdog?

(Edit) Do agree with the second portion fully though.

Modifié par ShdwFox7, 01 mai 2012 - 07:54 .

[darthnick427]

Did the survey.

[Acturas]

Tis done - hopefully the consensus will be a logical one

[Lost Mercenary]

I nearly died laughing when I saw that the ending was an option for most emotional moment in the game XD

[Spanky Magoo]

did it as honestly as possible.

[Necroscope]

lostmercenary99 wrote...

I nearly died laughing when I saw that the ending was an option for most emotional moment in the game XD

Yeah ;p...

Anyway, done.

[Aznable Char]

Surveyed . Now to spread the word .

[LKx]

there should have been another option for the dlc quesiton: "yes, if you fix the damn endings!!"

[MikeC99]

-Draikin- wrote...

You're making this sound like it's a survey from Jessica/Bioware themselves while it's not. I'd suggest making that clear in the OP. Also, correct me if I'm wrong but there doesn't seem to be anything stopping people from submitting the form more than once...

I suspect they will check IPs. But they should say so ie how they dealt with duplicates.  While I thoroughly support this survey, it's a shame we've had NO acknowledgment of other surveys - like Mass Effect Ending - Towards A consensus follow up survey (HERE). Yes I'm doing a free plug - but it's frustrating that it seems that Bioware's "We're listening"  is only half the phrase; what's missing is the second half:  "... but only to what we want to hear." But good survey - yes. Just wish Bioware would use both ears to listen.
cheers
MikeC

[UrgentArchengel]

Told them that Mass Effect 3 is not the type of game you rush.

Pre-Ending=9(Would be higher when DLC fills the missing content)

Post-Ending=7(It's just a typical, meh game with the current endings.  Almost like another universe compaired to ME1-2)

Ending Score=2(Pure total garbage, and a disgrace to the previous content.  At lest the music and presentation was well done as usual.)

Most Emotional Moment....I had too many, but I picked Shooting Cans with my Bro Garrus, just two friends chilling as the universe crumbles.

Modifié par UrgentArchengel, 01 mai 2012 - 10:19 .